A supplement brand's margin on a bottle is wide, and that's the trap. A bottle of capsules that costs $4.20 from a co-packer and sells for $28 on your own website keeps 74.6% of its price after the mailer, the packing and the card fee. Numbers like that are why so many people start a supplement brand. What they leave out is the cost of finding the customer. Supplements are sold by advertising, and in the made-up brand below, advertising is the largest cost in the business, larger than the product. A full-speed month brings $32,340 of sales and $21,802 of gross profit, and after $12,900 of fixed costs, most of it ads, $8,902 is left. Below are the bottle's cost, four ways of selling it, the month, and a calculator.
The short version
- A bottle's margin is 50% to 75% depending on where it sells.
- The product is cheap. The customer is expensive.
- Subscriptions earn less a bottle and keep the customer you paid for.
- A marketplace takes a fee and a fulfillment charge: check what's left.
- Testing, insurance and compliance are fixed costs, whatever you sell.
- TaroStack tracks each lot from the co-packer to the customer and costs it. More below.
A bottle, costed
The brand doesn't make the capsules. A co-packer does, and delivers finished, labeled bottles.
| A bottle sold on the brand's own website | Cost |
|---|---|
| Finished bottle from the co-packer, delivered | $4.20 |
| Mailer, insert and postage not covered by the shipping charge | $1.40 |
| Packing, 2 minutes at $20 an hour | $0.67 |
| Card fee, 3% of $28 | $0.84 |
| Cost | $7.11 |
The $4.20 is for a run of several thousand bottles. A first run of 500 can cost twice that a bottle, and the co-packer's minimum is the first number to ask for: see supplement co-packer.
Margins by product
| Product | Sold | Price | Cost | Gross profit | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capsules, 60 count | Own website | $28.00 | $7.11 | $20.89 | 74.6% |
| Capsules, 60 count | Subscription, 15% off | $23.80 | $6.98 | $16.82 | 70.7% |
| Capsules, 60 count | Wholesale to shops | $14.00 | $4.50 | $9.50 | 67.9% |
| Capsules, 60 count | Online marketplace | $28.00 | $13.40 | $14.60 | 52.1% |
The marketplace sells the same bottle at the same price and keeps 52.1%. A 15% referral fee and $4.50 of fulfillment take $8.70 before anything else. It may still be worth it, because the marketplace brings buyers you didn't pay to find.
Wholesale keeps 67.9% of half the price. $9.50 a bottle, with no advertising behind it.
A month at full speed
| Product | Units | Sales | Gross profit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Capsules, 60 count, own website | 400 | $11,200 | $8,356 |
| Capsules, 60 count, subscription, 15% off | 300 | $7,140 | $5,046 |
| Capsules, 60 count, wholesale to shops | 500 | $7,000 | $4,750 |
| Capsules, 60 count, online marketplace | 250 | $7,000 | $3,650 |
| Month | $32,340 | $21,802 | |
| Fixed costs | −$12,900 | ||
| Left | $8,902 |
Fixed costs are $12,900 a month: advertising ($9,500), testing and quality ($900), insurance ($600), a part-time helper ($1,500), and storage and software ($400). What's left is 28% of sales, before the owner's pay and tax.
Break-even
| Fixed costs a month | $12,900 |
| Gross profit on each dollar of sales | 67 cents |
| Sales needed to cover fixed costs | $19,135 |
| As a share of a full-speed month | 59% |
Below about $19,135 a month the brand loses money, however good the bottle's margin looks. And the advertising figure isn't really fixed: it's what buys the sales.
What moves it
| Change | Effect on the month |
|---|---|
| Advertising cost to win a customer rises by a fifth | −$1,900 |
| Half of website buyers move to a subscription | About −$800 this month, and more months from each customer |
| A failed test: one lot of 2,000 bottles destroyed | −$8,400 |
| The co-packer's price rises 40 cents a bottle | −$580 |
What a customer is worth. A website buyer who orders once brings $20.89. A subscriber who stays six months brings six times $16.82: about $101. That's the number to set the advertising budget against, and it's why supplement brands push subscriptions.
The lot you can't sell. A supplement brand is responsible for what's in the bottle even when a co-packer makes it. A lot that fails testing, or has to be recalled, costs the product and more.
The record behind each product is in master manufacturing record, what to do when a lot has to come back in recall plan for supplements, and label rules in dietary supplement labeling requirements. Stock by lot and expiry is in supplement inventory template.
Get the calculator
Download the supplement profit margin calculator. One line for each product and where it sells: price, materials, packaging, labor and fees. It works out the cost, the gross profit, the margin and markup, and the price a target margin would need. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The calculator knows one cost for a bottle. In practice there are three runs in the warehouse at three prices, one of them close to its expiry date, and the marketplace's fees changed in March. Which run a given order shipped from, and what it really cost, isn't in a margin table.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps each run as a lot, with its cost and its date.
Each delivery from the co-packer is a lot, with the co-packer's lot number, the expiry date and what it cost you, freight included.
The soonest expiry ships first by default, and an alert flags lots close to their date, with what they're worth.
Margins on what things actually cost, by product: the $4.20 run and the $4.60 run each carry their own.
One report for a recall: which customers and shops got a lot, and what's still on your shelf. Starting a recall holds the rest.
| The job | Calculator | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| What a bottle cost | One figure | The lot it shipped from |
| Stock near its expiry | Unknown | An alert, with its value |
| Who received a lot | Order exports | One report |
| Margin by product | At the price you typed | On real cost |
TaroStack doesn't run your ads or make anyone compliant with supplement rules. Stock, lots, expiry and recalls are on every plan, from $9.99 a month. The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
