A supplement recall nearly always starts as a complaint. So a recall plan for a supplement brand has two halves. The first is the complaint procedure the supplement manufacturing rules already require: every complaint written down, reviewed by a qualified person, and investigated when it could mean a failed specification or a risk of illness, across "all relevant batches". The second is the recall procedure: stop and hold, trace the raw lot to every finished lot that used it, find who got each one, tell them, check they acted, and deal with the product. The link between the halves is the lot number. Below are both, an example, and a template.
The short version
- Write down every complaint, with the lot number if the customer has it.
- A qualified person reviews each one; quality control approves the decision.
- An investigation covers every batch that shares the cause, not only the one complained about.
- Trace back to the raw lot, out to its sister batches, forward to the buyers.
- A notice names the product, size and lot numbers, the reason and what to do.
- TaroStack records which raw lots went into each finished lot and who bought it. More below.
Which rules apply
| Rule | What it covers |
|---|---|
| 21 CFR part 111, subpart O | Product complaints: written procedures, review, investigation, records |
| 21 CFR 117.5(e) | The food rule's hazard analysis and recall plan subpart doesn't apply to a supplement made in compliance with part 111 and with serious adverse event reporting |
| 21 CFR 7.42, 7.49 | FDA's guidance on recall strategy and recall communications |
So the written recall plan in 21 CFR 117.139 isn't what governs a compliant supplement maker. The complaint rules do, and a recall is conducted under FDA's general recall guidance. Serious adverse events have a reporting requirement of their own, which this article doesn't cover: ask counsel. This is general information, not legal advice.
Half one: the complaint
Section 111.570 lists what each complaint record must include.
| The record | Example |
|---|---|
| Name and description of the supplement | Noni capsules, 90 count |
| Batch, lot or control number, if available | NC-1006 |
| Date received; complainant's name, address or phone, if available | November 17; J. Tran, by email |
| Nature of the complaint, including how the product was used | Capsules smell musty on opening. Stored in a kitchen cupboard, opened two weeks ago |
| The reply, if any | Refund sent; asked for the bottle back |
| Findings and follow-up, when investigated | See below |
Then section 111.560: a qualified person reviews every complaint to decide whether it involves a possible failure to meet a specification or another requirement, "including those specifications and other requirements that, if not met, may result in a risk of illness or injury", and investigates if so. Quality control reviews and approves both the decision and the findings. The review has to extend to all relevant batches and records.
"All relevant batches" is the phrase that turns a complaint into a possible recall. A second musty report on the same lot two days later makes it one. A log for complaints is in customer complaint log.
Half two: the recall
A made-up capsule brand.
| Step | Example |
|---|---|
| Who decides | Owner; backup, quality lead |
| First hour | Stop shipping NC-1006. Put what's on hand on hold. Pull the batch record and the retained sample |
| Trace back | NC-1006: powder lot NP-250822, capsules VC-7731, bottles and labels by lot |
| Trace out | NP-250822 also went into NC-1110. Both are in scope until testing says otherwise |
| Trace forward | Orders by lot: 3 retailers, 141 online orders, 1 practitioner |
| How far | A contaminant or an undeclared allergen: to the consumer |
| Tell them | Each direct account, the same day, in writing |
| Tell regulators | The FDA recall coordinator |
| Check it worked | Contact each account; bottles accounted for against bottles shipped |
| Afterwards | Cause in writing; returned product counted and destroyed; procedures changed and dated |
Trace out is the step that gets missed. The complaint was about NC-1006. The cause, if it's the powder, is in NC-1110 as well, and that lot is still in quarantine and hasn't shipped. Finding it there is the difference between a recall of 600 bottles and a recall of 1,200.
The retained sample is how you test the lot without waiting for the customer's bottle. Keep a few from every lot: see supplement inventory template.
The notice
FDA's guidance on recall communications asks for a notice that is brief and identifies the product, size and lot numbers, explains the reason and the hazard, gives specific instructions, and offers a ready way to report back.
| Say | Example |
|---|---|
| That it's a recall | URGENT: DIETARY SUPPLEMENT RECALL |
| Product, size, lots | Noni capsules, 90 count, lot NC-1006, expiry 08/2028, printed on the bottle's base |
| Reason and hazard | Testing found mold above our specification |
| What to do | Stop using it. Don't throw it away: return it with the prepaid label |
| What you'll get | A full refund or a replacement from a different lot |
| How to reply | Reply to this email, or call 555-0155, with how many bottles you have |
Retailers are asked to pull the lot and to tell their own customers where they can. Depth, public warning and effectiveness checks are worked through in recall strategy template.
Get the template
Download the supplement recall plan template. Twelve sections from complaint to close-out, what to decide in each, and the example beside a place for yours, with a read-me. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers. The batch record it leans on is in herbal products batch record.
Where this stops working
"Trace out" and "trace forward" are one line each in the plan. In the office they're a morning with batch records, then another with order exports from two sales channels, matching lot numbers that were typed by hand, if they were typed at all. Online orders in particular rarely record which lot was in the box.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the lot on every step, so the tracing is a report.
Raw lots at receiving. Each delivery is a lot with its supplier, lot number and expiry, and your own receiving checks, such as "certificate received".
Batches note what they used. Record a batch and the powder, capsule and bottle lots are on the batch record automatically. From a raw lot, every finished lot that used it is listed.
Orders record the lot shipped. So the report names the retailers and customers who got NC-1006.
On hold. A lot on hold, in quarantine or under investigation, is kept out of what you can sell. Starting a recall holds every affected lot at once.
The recall report and the notices. Customers and suppliers with where to find them, as one file, and a notice to each customer from your own mailbox with the answers kept.
| The job | Paper | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Sister batches of a raw lot | Read every batch record | Listed from the lot |
| Who got NC-1006 | Order exports, matched by hand | The recall report |
| Stop it shipping | Tell the packer | On hold at once |
| Bottles accounted for | A spreadsheet | Shipped, on hand and returned, by lot |
TaroStack doesn't keep a complaint against a lot: log complaints yourself, with the lot number. It isn't a quality system and doesn't decide a release or a recall. Lots, batches and recalls are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
