There's no single good gross margin for a manufacturer, for a reason that has nothing to do with industries. Two makers can run identical businesses and report very different margins, because gross margin depends on what you count as cost of goods. Count only materials and packaging, and the made-up granola maker below has a gross margin of 74%. Add the wages of the people who make the product and the production space, as larger businesses and their accountants do, and the same month shows 52.5%. Neither is wrong. They aren't comparable, and a benchmark is useless until you know which kind it is. The better question is what gross margin your business needs: enough to cover everything below the gross profit line, plus the profit you want. For this maker that's about 39% counted one way and 61% the other, and it clears both. Below are the two sums, the margin you need, what moves it, and a worksheet.
The short version
- Gross margin = (sales − cost of goods sold) ÷ sales.
- What's in cost of goods decides the number. Say which when you quote it.
- Materials-only margins look high. They have more left to pay for.
- The margin you need = (everything below the line + the profit you want) ÷ sales.
- Compare with your own last year, counted the same way.
- TaroStack reports margin by product on what things actually cost. More below.
One month, two gross margins
| Materials only | With production labor and overhead | |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | $41,200 | $41,200 |
| Materials and packaging | $10,600 | $10,600 |
| Production labor | $6,200 | |
| Production overhead | $2,750 | |
| Cost of goods sold | $10,600 | $19,550 |
| Gross profit | $30,600 | $21,650 |
| Gross margin | 74.3% | 52.5% |
The left column is how many small makers keep their books: wages and kitchen rent are expenses of the month. The right is how a larger company, a lender or a buyer of the business would look at it. The bottom line is the same either way. Only the label on the subtotal moves.
So when you read that a maker "should" have a gross margin of some figure, the first question is which column. A 50% materials-only margin and a 50% fully loaded margin are very different businesses.
The margin you need
Work from the bottom up.
| With labor and overhead in cost | Materials only | |
|---|---|---|
| Production labor and overhead | (already in cost) | $8,950 |
| Selling and delivery | $5,100 | $5,100 |
| Office and other operating expenses | $6,900 | $6,900 |
| Profit you want the month to leave | $4,000 | $4,000 |
| Gross profit needed | $16,000 | $24,950 |
| Gross margin needed | 38.8% | 60.6% |
| Gross margin you have | 52.5% | 74.3% |
This maker clears its own bar by about 14 points either way, which is $5,650 a month above the $4,000 it wanted: the month leaves $9,650.
That bar is the only benchmark that matters. A business with a salesperson, a broker and trade show costs needs a higher gross margin than one that sells at a market stall. A business that wholesales through a distributor needs room for the distributor's share.
By channel
One blended figure hides the spread.
| Channel | Price a bag | Materials | Materials-only margin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Farmers market | $10.00 | $2.55 | 74.5% |
| Own website | $10.00 | $2.55 | 74.5%, before shipping materials and fees |
| Wholesale to shops | $6.50 | $2.55 | 60.8% |
| Through a distributor | $5.20 | $2.55 | 51.0% |
The same bag earns 74% at the market and 51% through a distributor. A maker moving from markets to wholesale watches its gross margin fall while its sales rise, and that isn't a sign of failure. It's the channel. What a distributor takes is in distributor margin.
What moves it
| Change | Effect on this maker's month |
|---|---|
| Materials up 8% | −$848; two points of margin |
| A price rise of 5% across the range | +$2,060; about 2.5 points |
| Waste and giveaways cut from 4% to 2% of materials | +$212 |
| Wholesale share of sales up from 40% to 60% at lower prices | Margin down several points, dollars up if volume follows |
| A second shift, same overhead | Overhead a unit falls: the fully loaded margin rises |
Price is the strongest lever and materials the most watched. The quiet one is yield: a batch that makes 96 bags where the recipe says 100 costs 4% more a bag, and nobody sees an invoice for it.
Margin isn't markup
A 52.5% margin is not a 52.5% markup. Margin is profit over price; markup is profit over cost. The fully loaded bag here, at 52.5% margin, carries a 110% markup. Mix them up on a price list and you'll be a long way out: the two are set side by side in markup vs margin, and the sum itself in gross margin formula.
How cost of goods sold is built for a maker, with the three inventories, is in accounting for a manufacturing business. This is general information, not accounting advice: your accountant decides what goes into your cost of goods.
Get the worksheet
Download the gross margin worksheet. Type seven figures on the Inputs sheet: sales, materials, production labor, production overhead, selling expenses, other expenses, and the profit you want. The Result sheet gives gross margin both ways, what the month leaves, and the gross margin you need. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The worksheet gives one margin for the business. The business is thirty products in four channels. Some earn 80% and some, after a year of ingredient price rises nobody traced, earn 35% and are being sold to the biggest customer. The blend looks fine. The decisions (what to push, what to reprice, what to drop) are in the parts.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack reports margin where the decisions are.
Margins by product, on what things actually cost. Each batch is costed from the lots it used, freight included, so a product's cost is this month's, not last year's.
Actual against standard cost, batch by batch: yield and usage show up as a number.
A price-creep report for each supplier.
Recipe truth: whether a recipe makes what it claims.
Waste by reason: expired, damaged, samples.
| The question | Worksheet | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Gross margin of the business | Yes | Use the worksheet, or your books |
| Margin of each product | No | By product, on real cost |
| Why a margin fell | No | Price creep, yield, waste |
| What a bag costs this month | Last costing | From the batches |
TaroStack isn't an accounting system. Every list exports to CSV for your accountant. Recipes, batches and costing are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
