Two agencies touch a cosmetic, and only one of them has anything to say about the word "organic". FDA, which regulates cosmetics, doesn't define or regulate the term for them. USDA does regulate it, for agricultural products, through its National Organic Program, and USDA's position is that a cosmetic made of agricultural ingredients may be certified under that program if it can meet the same standards as food. That makes the rule simple to state and demanding to meet: to call a balm "organic", the balm itself is certified, which means the farms, the ingredient handlers and you, the manufacturer, are each certified by a USDA-accredited certifying agent. Buying organic shea butter doesn't make the balm organic. Below is who decides what, the four label categories, a worksheet, and the records a claim rests on.
The short version
- FDA doesn't define or regulate "organic" on cosmetics.
- USDA regulates the term for agricultural products, under 7 CFR part 205.
- A cosmetic made of agricultural ingredients may be certified if it meets those standards.
- The ingredient producers, the handlers and the final manufacturer must all be certified.
- Once certified, the same four label categories apply as for food.
- The percentage is by weight or volume, leaving out water and salt.
- TaroStack records which certified lots went into each batch. More below.
Who says what
| What it says | Where | |
|---|---|---|
| FDA | It does not define or regulate "organic" as it applies to cosmetics, body care or personal care products | USDA's page, and FDA's soap page |
| FDA | The laws it enforces have no definition of "natural" or "organic"; the same requirements apply to every ingredient | FDA's soap page |
| USDA | It regulates "organic" for agricultural products through the National Organic Program | 7 CFR part 205 |
| USDA | A cosmetic containing or made of agricultural ingredients that meets the program's production, handling, processing and labeling standards may be eligible for certification | USDA's page |
| USDA | The operations that produce the organic ingredients, the handlers of them and the manufacturer of the final product must all be certified by a USDA-accredited certifying agent | USDA's page |
The four categories
USDA's page says certified cosmetics are eligible for the same four organic labeling categories as other agricultural products. The composition rule is 7 CFR 205.301.
| Category | Organic content, excluding water and salt |
|---|---|
| "100 percent organic" | 100 percent organically produced ingredients |
| "Organic" | Not less than 95 percent |
| "Made with organic (specified ingredients)" | At least 70 percent |
| Less than 70 percent | The organic ingredients themselves must still be produced and handled under the rule |
Water and salt are left out of the sum. That matters for a lotion, which is mostly water. A lotion's percentage is worked out on everything else in it.
What each category may print, and where, including the seal and the certifier's name, is in organic labeling requirements, with a calculator for the percentage.
A balm, worked through
This maker's balm, by weight:
| Ingredient | Share | Certified organic? |
|---|---|---|
| Shea butter | 45% | Yes |
| Coconut oil | 30% | Yes |
| Beeswax | 20% | No |
| Essential oil | 4% | No |
| Vitamin E | 1% | No |
Seventy-five percent of the balm is organic. That's above 70 and below 95, so the most the composition could support is "made with organic shea butter and coconut oil", and only if the maker's own operation is certified. It isn't, so a claim on the front of the jar would have no certifier behind it. A store's buyer who asks "who is your certifier?" is asking exactly this.
The honest label today lists the ingredients and makes no organic claim on the front. Before printing anything with the word on it, the maker talks to a certifying agent.
Organic doesn't mean safe
FDA's page for soap makers says not to assume that using only ingredients from plants will make a product safe. A cosmetic carries the same duties whatever its ingredients: see cosmetic labeling requirements and MoCRA for small businesses. This is general information, not legal advice.
Get the worksheet
Download the organic claim worksheet for cosmetics. One sheet and a read-me: nine questions, what USDA and FDA say on each, and a column for your answers. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
A percentage on a label is a claim about every jar. The certified shea butter runs out in March and a conventional lot fills in for two batches. The recipe didn't change, and the label didn't change, and for those two batches the claim is false. Certification depends on showing, batch by batch, which lot of which ingredient went in. The records that do that are in organic certification record keeping.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack records what a claim has to be able to show.
Receiving records each lot, with the supplier and the supplier's lot number, so a certified lot and a conventional one of the same ingredient are separate stock.
Recipes by weight, so the share of each ingredient is known.
Each batch notes the lots it used, automatically.
One report for a lot: which batches used it, and which customers got them.
| The certifier's question | Invoices and notes | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Which lot of shea went into batch 31 | Unknown | The lots on the batch |
| Was it the certified lot | Check the invoice | The lot's supplier and number |
| What share of the balm is shea | The recipe card | The recipe, by weight |
| Which jars came from that batch | Unknown | The lot's history |
TaroStack doesn't certify anything or calculate your organic percentage for a certifier. Recipes, batches and lots are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
