Skip to content

Alternating Proprietorship: Two Wineries, One Cellar

What an alternating proprietorship is for a winery: each proprietor bonded on its own, with its own records, labels and tax, and how custom crush differs.

By Koa Sterling. Product specialist at TaroStack and small business owner. Yes, I am a real human, and I actually sit in front of a computer and write these articles. Reviewed November 21, 2026 · 6 min read

An alternating proprietorship is the way to be a real winery without owning one. In the words of the federal regulator's circular on it, it's "two or more persons or entities taking turns using the same space and equipment to produce wine." An established winery, the host, rents space and equipment to a newcomer, the tenant. What makes it different from simply paying someone to make your wine is that each of them is a bonded winery in its own right. The tenant qualifies with the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB), keeps its own records, gets its own label approvals and pays its own excise tax. So when a host's bookkeeper asks whose monthly report a tenant's tanks belong on, the answer is the tenant's. Below is what each proprietor is responsible for, how a changeover works, how it compares with custom crush, and a checklist.

The short version

  • Two or more wineries take turns using the same premises and equipment.
  • Each qualifies independently as a bonded winery and holds its own permit.
  • Each keeps its own records and files its own reports.
  • Each gets label approval for the wine it bottles, and pays tax on the wine it removes.
  • The areas that alternate are described in the application, with a diagram.
  • TTB examines whether an arrangement is truly alternating or really custom crush.
  • TaroStack keeps each proprietor's wine as its own lots. More below.

Who is responsible for what

Alternating proprietorship Custom crush
Who is a bonded winery Each proprietor, separately Only the producer
Who makes the wine Each proprietor makes its own The producer, to the customer's order
Records and reports Each proprietor's own The producer's; the customer keeps records as a wholesaler
Label approval Each proprietor that bottles The producer, as bottler
Excise tax Each proprietor, on wine it removes Paid by the producer before the customer receives the wine
The transfer of finished wine Stays the tenant's own Treated as a sale from producer to customer

This is the circular's own comparison, in short. Its point is that a winery "cannot transfer or lend its qualification or premises to another person." Sharing a cellar doesn't share a permit.

How alternating works

The rule is 27 CFR 24.136.

  • The application names the areas. Where only part of the premises alternates, the application describes the areas, buildings, floors or rooms, with a diagram for each arrangement.
  • A changeover is complete. Operations in an alternated area are finished, and wine and other accountable materials are removed or transferred to the incoming proprietor. Wine may stay in locked tanks in the outgoing proprietor's custody.
  • Transfers are recorded twice. Any transfer of wine or spirits from one proprietor to the other shows in the records and reports of each.
  • A producing turn is at least a day. Operation of a bonded winery producing wine by an alternate proprietor is at least one calendar day in length.

In practice that means every tank, barrel and case in the building has an owner at every moment, and the tags and the books agree on who it is.

Is it really alternating?

TTB's circular says its examination of applications and of operations "includes whether the arrangement is truly an alternating proprietorship or whether it is really a custom crush arrangement." Among the problems it lists is "the use of permits by persons who are not engaged in the business of producing wine." In custom crush a customer pays a producer to make wine to order and then markets it, and the producer carries the responsibility. A tenant that holds a permit and makes no wine is the case the circular warns about. The other arrangement is in custom crush winery.

The circular is from 2008, and its paragraphs on tax credits predate later changes in the law. Read TTB's current pages, and ask TTB, before you sign. Your State licenses wineries too, and may treat a shared premises its own way. This is general information, not legal advice.

What each side should keep

  • A tag on every vessel with the owner's name and the lot.
  • A changeover log: date, area, who went out, who came in, what stayed in locked tanks.
  • A transfer record for anything that changes hands: grapes, juice, wine, spirits.
  • Each proprietor's own book of crush, additions, blends, bottlings and removals.

The cellar's day-to-day record is in wine making log sheet, stock in winery inventory spreadsheet, and the plan for the business in winery business plan.

Get the checklist

Download the alternating proprietorship checklist. One sheet and a read-me: ten questions for two wineries sharing premises, what TTB's circular and rule say on each, and a column for your own answer. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.

Where this stops working

Two wineries, one cellar, harvest. On a Tuesday in October the host presses three lots and the tenant two, some of the tenant's juice goes into a tank the host emptied that morning, and a pallet of the host's bottles is used for the tenant's bottling by mistake. Each event is the kind 24.136 wants in two sets of books. On a whiteboard and two spreadsheets, kept by the same tired cellar crew, the books drift from the tanks within a week.

How TaroStack does it

TaroStack keeps each proprietor's own record of its own wine.

Each winery has its own business in TaroStack, with its own stock, lots and batches. Nothing is shared by accident.

Every lot of grapes, juice and wine is a lot, and each crush, blend and bottling is a batch that notes which lots it used, automatically.

Stock is held by location, so a tank or a barrel row is a place, and what's in it is known.

Every adjustment carries a reason, and what ships is recorded by lot.

The question Whiteboard and sheets In TaroStack
Whose wine is in tank 7 The tag, if it's current That business's stock, by location
What went into this bottling The cellar book The lots on the batch
What was removed this month Add it up Shipped, by lot
What we received from the other proprietor Two sets of notes A delivery received, as a lot

TaroStack doesn't file TTB reports, apply for permits or label approvals, or work out excise tax. Recipes, batches and lots are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.

Questions people also ask

What is an alternating proprietorship?

Two or more wineries taking turns using the same space and equipment to produce wine. Each one qualifies independently as a bonded winery and is responsible for its own wine.

How is an alternating proprietorship different from custom crush?

In custom crush only the producer is a bonded winery, and it carries the records, the label approval and the tax. In an alternating proprietorship each proprietor carries its own.

Does each alternating proprietor need its own label approval?

Yes. TTB's circular says each alternating proprietor that uses the bottling equipment must obtain its own approvals for the wine it bottles.

Sources

  1. TTB Industry Circular 2008-4, Alternating Proprietors at Bonded Wine Premises (August 18, 2008) · read November 21, 2026
  2. 27 CFR 24.136 (procedure for alternating proprietors) · read November 21, 2026

We use AI to help with the research for these articles. Every one is read, checked against its sources and edited by Koa before it's published. Spot a mistake? Tell us and we'll fix it and say so. How we write these.

Let’s get your stack in order.

Get TaroStack

Sign up now for your free 14 day trial. No credit card required.