Skip to content

Ingredient Price Increase: What It Does to Your Margin

What to do when an ingredient price increase hits: recost each product, see the margin it leaves, the price that restores it, and five options, with a sheet.

By Koa Sterling. Product specialist at TaroStack and small business owner. Yes, I am a real human, and I actually sit in front of a computer and write these articles. Reviewed November 21, 2026 · 6 min read

When an ingredient goes up, the first job isn't deciding what to do. It's finding out how much it matters. A 22% rise in almonds sounds alarming and may add 46 cents to one product and nothing to another. So recost every product that uses the ingredient, at what you're paying now. Then look at two numbers for each: the margin you're left with if you change nothing, and the price that puts it back. There are two versions of "back". Keeping your dollars means adding only the extra cost to the price. Keeping your percentage means raising it more. Only then choose: absorb it, raise the price, change the pack, change the recipe, or buy differently. In the example below, three price rises take a granola maker's best seller from a 50% margin to 43%, and it takes a 46-cent increase to stand still. Below are the sums and a sheet.

The short version

  • Recost from the invoice you just paid, freight included.
  • A big rise in a small ingredient may not matter. A small rise in your main one does.
  • Keep the dollars: price + extra cost. Keep the percentage: new cost ÷ (1 − old margin).
  • Five options: absorb, reprice, resize, reformulate, rebuy.
  • Tell wholesale customers in writing, with notice.
  • TaroStack shows a supplier's price creeping and recosts every product that uses it. More below.

Step 1: recost

A made-up granola maker. Pecans are up 18%, almonds 22%, honey 15%, oats 6%.

Product Cost before Cost after Up
Maple pecan, 12 oz $3.10 $3.34 $0.24
Honey almond, 12 oz $3.25 $3.71 $0.46
Plain oats and honey, 12 oz $2.40 $2.58 $0.18

Honey almond takes two hits, so it moves most. The plain granola barely moves, though honey went up 15%, because there isn't much honey in a bag. This is why you recost by product and don't apply one percentage across the list.

Step 2: what it does, and what puts it back

Product Price Margin before Margin now Price to keep the dollars Price to keep the margin
Maple pecan, wholesale $6.50 52.3% 48.6% $6.74 (+3.7%) $7.00 (+7.7%)
Honey almond, wholesale $6.50 50.0% 42.9% $6.96 (+7.1%) $7.42 (+14.2%)
Plain oats and honey, wholesale $5.50 56.4% 53.1% $5.68 (+3.3%) $5.91 (+7.5%)
Honey almond, farmers market $10.00 67.5% 62.9% $10.46 (+4.6%) $11.42 (+14.2%)

Keep the dollars. Honey almond made $3.25 a bag. At $6.96 it still makes $3.25. Your income per bag is unchanged, and your percentage slips a little because the price is bigger. For most small makers this is the honest minimum: you're passing on the cost, no more.

Keep the percentage. At $7.42 the margin is 50% again, and you make $3.71 a bag, more dollars than before. If you sell through distributors or shops who think in percentages, and your own overheads are rising too, this is the number to aim at.

Do nothing. Honey almond stays at $6.50 and makes $2.79. On 2,000 bags a month that's $920 a month gone.

Step 3: choose

Option When it fits Watch for
Absorb it The rise is small, or temporary, or your margin has room Three "small" rises in a row
Raise the price The rise is real and lasting Round to a price that looks deliberate: $6.95, not $6.96
Resize the pack Price points matter more than weight to your buyers A new weight means new labels, and customers notice
Reformulate The dear ingredient can be reduced without changing the product It's a new recipe: allergens, label and nutrition panel all recheck
Rebuy Another supplier, a bigger pack, a forward contract Minimum orders and the cash they tie up

Often it's two together: buy almonds by the pallet to claw back half, and raise the price for the rest.

Reformulating is not free. Swapping some almonds for sunflower seeds changes the ingredient list, may change the allergens, and makes every printed label wrong. Do the label sum before the ingredient sum.

Rebuying. Ask your supplier before you leave them: what's behind the rise, will a larger order hold the old price, is a contract possible. The emails are in request a price list from a supplier.

Telling customers

Retail prices at a market change with a new sign. Wholesale customers need notice in writing, usually 30 days or whatever your agreement says, with the new price list and the date. Say what went up, in a sentence, and don't apologize for three paragraphs. A letter to adapt is in price increase letter.

Time it. If the almond price rose in November, a January 1 price list is easy for a shop to accept. A second increase in March isn't. Do the whole recost once, and move every product that needs it together.

Catching the next one earlier

The rise that hurts is the one you find at tax time. Keep a line for each main ingredient with every price you've paid: the sheet is in supplier price tracking template. And recost on a schedule, not on a feeling: quarterly for the whole range, at once for any ingredient that's more than a tenth of a product's cost. The costing itself is in batch cost calculator and ingredient cost calculator.

Get the sheet

Download the repricing sheet. Type each product's price, its cost before and its cost now. It works out both margins, the price that keeps your dollars, the price that keeps your percentage, and the rise each needs. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.

Where this stops working

"Cost after" is the hard column. To fill it in you need each recipe, each ingredient's current price with freight, and the sum redone for every product: for twelve products and thirty ingredients, an afternoon. So it's done once a year, and in between the almond price moves three times. By the time the sheet is opened, the margin has been thin for months and nobody can say since when.

How TaroStack does it

TaroStack does the recost every time you buy.

A price-creep report for each supplier. What each ingredient cost at each purchase. The 22% is visible on the day the invoice is entered, not in April.

Cost follows what you paid. Stock is held in cost layers, freight included, and each batch is costed from the lots it used.

Every recipe that uses the ingredient moves with it. Honey almond and maple pecan are recosted without anyone opening a spreadsheet.

Margins on what things actually cost, by product, so you see which lines have gone thin.

Actual against standard cost, batch by batch.

The job Repricing sheet In TaroStack
Notice the price moved Compare invoices The price-creep report
Recost each product An afternoon From the batches
Which products are hurt most Work each out Margin by product
Since when Unknown Purchase by purchase

TaroStack doesn't decide your prices or write to your customers. Purchasing, recipes and costing are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.

Questions people also ask

How much should I raise my price when an ingredient goes up?

To keep the same dollars on each unit, add the extra cost to the price. To keep the same margin percentage, divide the new cost by one minus your old margin.

Should I absorb an ingredient price increase?

If it's small, temporary, or your margin has room, perhaps. Recost first: several small rises absorbed in a row are how a margin disappears.

How do I tell customers about a price increase?

In writing, with the new prices and the date they start, giving the notice your agreement promises: commonly 30 days.

We use AI to help with the research for these articles. Every one is read, checked against its sources and edited by Koa before it's published. Spot a mistake? Tell us and we'll fix it and say so. How we write these.

Let’s get your stack in order.

Get TaroStack

Sign up now for your free 14 day trial. No credit card required.