An email asking a supplier for prices works when it does two things. It tells them who you are and how much you'll buy, so they know which price list applies and whether you're worth a reply. And it asks for everything that makes up the real cost, not just the price: pack size, minimum order, delivery charge, lead time and payment terms. A price list with none of those can't be compared with another. Send the same email to three suppliers, put the answers in one sheet, and work out the delivered price for each unit at the minimum order. The cheapest pound is often attached to a minimum you can't use. Below is the email, three more for what comes next, and a comparison sheet with an example.
The short version
- Say who you are, what you want and how much a month.
- Ask for pack size, price, minimum, delivery, lead time and terms in one go.
- Ask for the paperwork too: specification, allergen statement, certificate of analysis.
- Three suppliers, same questions.
- Compare delivered price a unit, and the cash the minimum order ties up.
- TaroStack keeps each supplier's prices, lead times and minimums, and shows when a price creeps. More below.
The email
Subject: Price list request: Hillside Granola, Portland
Hello,
I'm the owner of Hillside Granola, a small granola maker in Portland. We use about 75 lb of sliced almonds a month and are looking for a regular supplier.
Could you send your current price list for sliced and whole almonds, with:
- pack sizes and the price for each
- your minimum order
- delivery charge and lead time to ZIP 97214
- payment terms for a new account
- whether a certificate of analysis comes with each lot
If you have an allergen statement and a current third-party audit certificate, I'd be glad to have those too.
Thank you, Dana Whitfield, Hillside Granola, 503-555-0142
Why each part is there. The first two sentences let the supplier place you: a real business, a real volume, a repeat order. "About 75 lb a month" is more useful to them than "pricing, please". The list means you get one reply and not five. And asking for documents now tells them you'll be the kind of customer who keeps records, which the good ones prefer.
Write to a named person if you can find one. Otherwise the sales address on their site is fine.
Three more
A follow-up, after a week. Short, no reproach: you wrote last week, you're deciding by the end of the month, and you'd like to include them. Ask whether someone else handles new accounts. Half of all unanswered emails went to the wrong inbox.
Asking about volume. Once you have a price: "At the 25 lb case price we'd order about 75 lb a month. If we committed to 300 lb a quarter, delivered monthly, is there a better case price, or could the delivery charge be waived?" Offer something (a commitment, a larger drop, faster payment) and ask what it's worth.
Replying to a price increase. Ask what's behind it, whether orders placed before the date keep the old price, and whether a larger order now would help both of you. Polite questions get better answers than complaints, and sometimes a month's grace.
All four are in the file, ready to change.
Comparing the replies
A made-up granola maker, three sources of sliced almonds.
| Supplier | Pack | Pack price | Minimum | Delivery | Lead time | Price a lb | Delivered, at the minimum | Cash for the minimum |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ridgeline Nut Co. | 25 lb case | $118.00 | 4 cases | $45.00 | 5 days | $4.72 | $5.17 | $517.00 |
| Valley Wholesale Foods | 30 lb case | $132.00 | 10 cases | Free | 10 days | $4.40 | $4.40 | $1,320.00 |
| Warehouse club | 3 lb bag | $17.49 | 1 bag | Pickup | Today | $5.83 | $5.83 | $17.49 |
The cheapest pound isn't the answer by itself. Valley is 77 cents a pound under Ridgeline, delivered. But its minimum is 300 lb: four months of almonds at this maker's rate, $1,320 paid within 15 days, and a storeroom shelf. Nuts keep, so it may be worth it. For cream it wouldn't be.
Delivery changes the order. Ridgeline's $4.72 becomes $5.17 at the minimum order, because $45 is spread over 100 lb. Order 200 lb and it's $4.95.
The club is the backstop. At $5.83 it's the dearest, and it comes with no lot paperwork. It's where you go when a delivery is late, not where you buy.
What the sheet can't weigh: whether they answer the phone, whether the lots are consistent, whether the paperwork arrives. Those you learn over the first few orders, and a way to score them is in supplier scorecard.
Before the first order
Price is the second question. The first is whether you can buy from them at all: for a food ingredient, that means their answers on food safety and allergens. The form is in supplier questionnaire template. Then put the order in writing, with the price you were quoted on it: see what should a purchase order include. And keep the price list. In six months you'll want to know what you were quoted, which is what supplier price tracking template is for.
Get the sheet
Download the supplier price comparison. A Compare sheet that works out the price a unit, the delivered price at the minimum order and the cash that order takes; an Emails sheet with the four messages; and a read-me. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The comparison is right on the day you make it. Then Ridgeline's January invoice says $124 a case, not $118, and nobody notices, because the price list is in an email from November and the invoice was paid by whoever opened the post. A year later the granola's margin is three points thinner and there's no one moment when it happened.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the price you were quoted beside the price you paid.
Suppliers with lead times and minimums. Each supplier's terms are on the supplier, not in an inbox.
Purchase orders with approval. The order carries the agreed price, and receiving against it shows a difference when the goods arrive.
A price-creep report for each supplier. What each item cost at each purchase, so $118 becoming $124 is visible the month it happens.
Lead times checked against reality: what a supplier promises against how long deliveries really take.
Cost follows what you paid. Each batch is costed from the lots it used, freight included, so a dearer case of almonds shows in that batch's margin.
| The job | Emails and a sheet | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| What were we quoted? | Search the inbox | On the purchase order |
| Has the price moved? | Compare invoices by hand | The price-creep report |
| Is five days really five days? | Memory | Lead times against deliveries |
| What does it do to the margin? | Recost the recipe | The batch's own cost |
TaroStack doesn't write to suppliers for you or choose between them. Suppliers, purchase orders and costing are on every plan, from $9.99 a month. The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
