A whoopie pie is two small cakes and a thick layer of filling, which makes it two bakes' worth of scooping and one round of piping for a single sale. The ingredients come to $1.09 a pie, and the filling is the larger half: butter, powdered sugar and marshmallow creme. A batch of eighteen takes a hundred minutes of hands-on work, $1.85 a pie at $20 an hour. With a bag and a label, one pie has cost $3.33. At $3 each, a common bake-sale price, every pie loses money. In the example below, $6 at a market leaves $2.49, a box of six for $32 leaves $1.84 a pie, and a cafe paying $4 leaves $0.67. Below are the sums, where the time goes, and a calculator.
The short version
- A pie costs about $3.33: $1.09 of ingredients, $1.85 of time.
- The filling costs more than the cakes.
- Thirty-six cakes to scoop for eighteen pies: a portion scoop pays for itself.
- Price each at about twice the full cost for a market.
- Boxes of six sell the batch faster.
- TaroStack keeps the cost current as butter and cocoa move. More below.
What a pie costs
A made-up market baker. One batch, eighteen pies.
| What goes in | Amount | You pay | Cost in the batch |
|---|---|---|---|
| All-purpose flour | 1.5 lb | $24.00 for 50 lb | $0.72 |
| Cocoa powder | 6 oz | $9.00 for 16 oz | $3.38 |
| Sugar | 1.25 lb | $8.50 for 10 lb | $1.06 |
| Butter | 12 oz | $4.80 for 16 oz | $3.60 |
| Eggs | 3 each | $4.20 for 12 each | $1.05 |
| Buttermilk | 12 fl oz | $3.20 for 32 fl oz | $1.20 |
| Powdered sugar | 1.5 lb | $2.60 for 2 lb | $1.95 |
| Marshmallow creme | 14 oz | $2.90 for 7 oz | $5.80 |
| Vanilla, baking soda, salt | $0.90 | ||
| Ingredients, the batch | $19.66 |
| For one pie | |
|---|---|
| Ingredients | $1.09 |
| Time: 100 minutes a batch at $20 an hour | $1.85 |
| Oven and kitchen: $3.00 a batch | $0.17 |
| Cello bag, label | $0.22 |
| Full cost | $3.33 |
Marshmallow creme is $5.80 of the batch, the dearest single line. A filling of butter, powdered sugar and a little meringue powder costs about half as much and pipes more cleanly. Taste both before deciding: the classic filling is what some customers came for.
Where the time goes
| Job | Minutes |
|---|---|
| Mixing the batter | 15 |
| Scooping 36 cakes, three trays | 20 |
| Baking and rotating (hands-on part) | 10 |
| Making the filling | 15 |
| Matching pairs, piping, sandwiching | 25 |
| Bagging and labeling | 15 |
| In all | 100 |
Scooping and assembly are nearly half of it. A #20 portion scoop makes the cakes the same size, so pairs match without sorting, and a piping bag with a large round tip is twice as fast as a spatula.
A double batch, thirty-six pies, takes about 150 minutes, not 200: time a pie falls from $1.85 to $1.39 and the full cost to about $2.78.
Three prices
| Where it sells | Price a pie | Fees | Left a pie | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Farmers market, each | $6.00 | 3% | $2.49 | 41% |
| Box of six, pre-order, $32 | $5.33 | 3% | $1.84 | 35% |
| To a cafe | $4.00 | $0.67 | 17% |
$6 each leaves $2.49. Regional favorites sell on nostalgia, and a hand-sized, hand-made one isn't competing with a wrapped snack cake.
A box of six at $32 is $5.33 a pie and moves a third of the batch in one sale. Add 90 cents for the box and it still leaves about $1.70 a pie.
The cafe at $4 leaves $0.67. That's not enough to be worth a delivery unless you bake the double batch, where it leaves about $1.22.
Before you sell
Whoopie pies with a shelf-stable filling are covered by many cottage food laws; fillings made with cream cheese or fresh cream usually aren't, because they need refrigeration. Check before you choose the filling: see can you sell baked goods from home. The label lists wheat, milk and egg as allergens, and soy if your marshmallow creme or chocolate contains it.
Sandwich cookies costed the same way: how to price oatmeal cream pies and how to price macarons. Plain cookies are in how to price cookies.
Get the calculator
Download the whoopie pie price calculator. Two sheets and a read-me: the batch cost, to type your own recipe and prices over, and the prices with what each leaves. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
Butter went from $4.80 a pound to $5.60 between October and December, the cocoa tin cost more than the last one, and the price on the chalkboard is still $6. The calculator knew the old butter price. Nobody typed in the new one.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the cost of a pie current without anyone opening a spreadsheet.
The recipe is by weight. Flour, cocoa, butter, eggs, powdered sugar, marshmallow creme, a bag and a label. Units convert, so what you buy by the sack and use by the gram is one item.
Cost follows what you paid. Each batch is costed from the deliveries it used. When a price goes up, the next batch costs more, and you see it.
"What could I make right now" says how many batches the ingredients and packaging on hand allow before a big order.
Allergens on Growth. With allergen tracking on, a batch can't start if its label leaves out an allergen its ingredients contain: wheat, milk and egg here.
Lots and dates. Each batch gets a lot code and a best-by, and lot labels print with both.
| The job | Calculator | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Cost a pie today | Retype the prices | From what you paid |
| Enough on hand for the order? | Check the cupboard | What could I make right now |
| Milk and egg on the label | Remember | Checked before the batch starts (Growth) |
| Which batch is this pie? | Unknown | Its lot code |
TaroStack costs ingredients and packaging. Your time is yours to add, as above. Recipes, batches and true cost are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes); allergen tracking is on Growth at $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
