A used item has no cost to build a price from. You paid $2 for the cookbook because that's what the thrift store wanted, not because that's what it's worth. So a resale price is set from the other end: what the same thing has actually sold for elsewhere, in the same condition. That gives you a range. Where you land in it depends on condition and how fast you want it gone. Then comes the check that separates a business from a hobby: take off the platform's fee and the shipping you pay, subtract what you paid and anything you spent cleaning or fixing it, and see what's left. Do that before you buy, and some bargains stop looking like bargains. Below is the method in four steps, four made-up items worked through, and a worksheet.
The short version
- Look up sold prices, not asking prices.
- Match the condition honestly. A chip or a stain moves the price.
- Price inside the range: high if you can wait, low if you need the space.
- Left = price less fee, less shipping, less what you paid and spent.
- Work the sum before you buy, with the low end of the range.
- Heavy, cheap things are the trap: shipping eats them.
- TaroStack tracks each item's cost and what's still unsold. More below.
Step 1: find what it sold for
Search the platform you sell on, and one other, for the same item, and filter to sold or completed listings. Asking prices are wishes. An item listed at $60 for a year tells you only that it doesn't sell at $60.
Note the lowest and highest sold prices for items in your condition, and how many sold recently. Three sales in a month at $35 to $60 is a market. One sale two years ago isn't.
Step 2: grade the condition
| Condition | What it means for price |
|---|---|
| Like new, complete | Top of the range |
| Good: used, clean, works | Middle |
| Fair: wear, a small flaw you'll disclose | Bottom, or below |
| Damaged or incomplete | Often not worth listing, unless it's rare or sold for parts |
Photograph and describe every flaw. A return costs you the shipping twice.
Step 3: pick the price
Inside the range, the price is a trade between money and time. This seller's rule is the middle of the range for ordinary things and the top only for something in demand that's in better condition than the others. If it hasn't sold in thirty days, drop it. Stock that sits ties up the cash you'd spend on the next find.
Step 4: check what's left
| Item | Paid | Repair | Sold range | Price | Fee | Shipping | Left | Return |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hardcover cookbook | $2.00 | $0.00 | $9 to $16 | $12.00 | 13% | $4.50 | $3.94 | 197% |
| Denim jacket, vintage | $8.00 | $3.00 | $35 to $60 | $45.00 | 13% | $8.00 | $20.15 | 183% |
| Mid-century side chair | $25.00 | $12.00 | $90 to $160 | $120.00 | none | $0.00 | $83.00 | 224% |
| Vintage mixing bowl, chipped | $4.00 | $0.00 | $10 to $22 | $12.00 | 13% | $9.00 | −$2.56 | −64% |
Left is the price, less the fee, less shipping, less what you paid and spent. Return is what's left divided by what you put in. The 13% fee is a made-up figure for the example: use your platform's own, and count every part of it. The chair was sold locally for cash, with no fee and no shipping.
Two things stand out.
The bowl loses money at a fair price. $12 is inside its sold range. But it weighs four pounds, needs a big box and padding, and the fee comes off the top. The fault wasn't the price. It was buying a heavy, chipped, $12 item to ship.
The cookbook's return looks best and earns least. A 197% return on $2 is $3.94. Ten of those is an afternoon of photographing and packing for $39. The chair's $83 took one listing. Percentages flatter small things.
So run the sum in the shop, on your phone, with the bottom of the sold range. If it doesn't clear what you need at that price, leave it on the shelf.
Pricing by kind
- Books. Common titles sell for little, and shipping is most of the price. Look up the exact edition.
- Clothes. Brand, size and condition decide it. Measure, don't trust the tag.
- Furniture. Sells locally. Price for pickup, and remember your own time moving it.
- Vintage and collectibles. The range is wide, so the sold listings matter more. Flaws matter most here.
What to charge the buyer for postage is in how much to charge for shipping. Keeping track of what you've bought and what's listed is in reseller inventory spreadsheet, and the difference between markup and margin in markup vs margin.
Get the worksheet
Download the resale pricing worksheet. One sheet and a read-me: type what you paid, what you spent on it, the sold range, your price, the fee and the shipping, and it works out what's left and the return. The four examples are filled in. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
One item at a time, the worksheet is enough. A reseller with three hundred things in a spare room has a different problem. What did this jacket cost? It came in a $40 bag of twelve. How long has it been listed? Is it in the room, or did it sell last month on the other platform? The pricing sum is easy. Knowing the cost and whereabouts of every single item is what goes wrong.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps each item with what it cost and where it is.
Receiving records what you bought and what it cost, so a bag of twelve can be received as twelve items with a cost each.
Stock by place: the shelf, the bin, the rack, so a sold item can be found.
Counting works on a phone with no signal. A count shows what each difference is worth.
Every adjustment carries a reason: damaged, donated, kept.
Stock value at cost, by month, so you can see how much cash is sitting in the spare room.
| The question | Spreadsheet and memory | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| What did this one cost | Somewhere in a haul | On the item |
| Where is it | A bin, probably | Its place |
| How much is tied up in unsold stock | Unknown | Stock value |
| What did I write off | Unknown | Adjustments by reason |
TaroStack doesn't connect to Etsy, WooCommerce or Amazon, and it doesn't look up sold prices. Stock, costs and counts are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (50 items) or $39 a month (3,000 items). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
