Before you decide what to charge for shipping, find out what it costs you, which is more than the label. An order's shipping cost is the carrier's rate, plus the box and padding, plus the minutes spent packing, plus insurance if you buy it. Then there are three ways to charge: the actual cost worked out at checkout, a flat rate on every order, or free shipping over a threshold, with the cost built into your prices. None of them makes shipping free. They decide who pays for it and whether a customer sees it. Flat and free are simpler to buy from, and they only work if you know your average. Below is a made-up candle maker's four orders, the three ways compared, and a calculator.
The short version
- Cost to ship = carrier's rate + box and padding + packing time + insurance.
- Weigh and measure a packed box for each thing you sell. Get real quotes.
- Actual cost is fair and adds a step at checkout.
- A flat rate works if overs and unders cancel out over a month.
- Free shipping is paid for in the price, by every customer.
- Charge wholesale orders their real freight.
- TaroStack keeps what shipped, to whom, by lot. More below.
What an order costs to ship
Rates depend on weight, box size and distance, and they change. The carrier figures below are placeholders: get quotes from your own account for a packed box of each product.
| Order | Box and padding | Carrier | Packing time | Cost to ship |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| One candle, 1.5 lb, same state | $1.10 | $6.40 | 5 min: $1.67 | $9.17 |
| Two candles, 3 lb, two states away | $1.60 | $9.80 | 6 min: $2.00 | $13.40 |
| Gift set of four, 6 lb, across the country | $2.40 | $17.30 | 8 min: $2.67 | $22.37 |
| Wholesale case of 12, 20 lb | $3.50 | $24.60 | 10 min: $3.33 | $33.43 |
The wholesale case includes $2 of insurance. Packing time is at $20 an hour.
Two things here surprise people. The box, the paper and the tape are a dollar or two on every order. And packing a glass candle so it arrives whole takes five to ten minutes of somebody's time. On the smallest order those two together are 30% of the cost.
Size counts as well as weight. Carriers charge for a large light box as if it were heavier. Use the smallest box that protects the product, and measure it.
Three ways to charge
This maker charges a flat $8.95.
| Order | Cost to ship | Charged | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| One candle, same state | $9.17 | $8.95 | −$0.22 |
| Two candles, two states away | $13.40 | $8.95 | −$4.45 |
| Gift set, across the country | $22.37 | $8.95 | −$13.42 |
Every order loses, and the gift set loses $13.42. The flat rate was set from the label on a single candle, with no box and no time in it.
| Way | The customer sees | You need to know | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Actual cost | A price that depends on where they live | Each product's packed weight and size | A high number at checkout loses the sale |
| Flat rate | One number | Your average cost to ship, over a real month | Far-away and heavy orders cost you |
| Free over a threshold | "Free shipping over $60" | Your average cost, and your margin | Small orders just under it still need a rate |
| Free on everything | Nothing | That your prices carry it | Local and pickup customers pay for it too |
Setting a flat rate. Add up a month's real shipping costs and divide by the number of orders. If 60 orders cost $720 to ship, the average is $12, and a flat rate below that is a discount you're giving on every order. Two flat rates, one for small boxes and one for large, get closer than one.
Setting a free threshold. Put it a little above your average order, so that it pulls orders up. Then check the sum: an order at the threshold has to carry its shipping out of its margin. If a $60 order leaves $27 after the cost of the candles and $13 goes to shipping, free shipping takes about half of what's left. Either the threshold goes up or the prices do.
Wholesale. A shop buying at half price can't also have free freight. Charge what the case costs to send, or set a minimum order that makes it worth including. More in minimum order quantity.
Food that has to stay cold is its own subject: see shipping perishable food for a small business. Keeping a record of what went out is in shipping log template, and pricing the candles themselves in how to price candles.
Get the calculator
Download the shipping charge calculator. One sheet and a read-me: for each order, type the box, the carrier's rate, the packing minutes and what you charged. It works out the cost to ship and the difference. Add the difference column up over a month to see what your shipping policy costs. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
A customer writes that her gift set arrived with one candle cracked. Which box was it, packed on which day, and were those candles from the batch with the thin jars? The shipping sheet has costs. The carrier has a tracking number. Neither knows what was in the box.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack records what went into each order.
Customers and sales orders, with one picking list for the day's boxes.
What ships is recorded by lot, so an order leads back to the batch its candles came from.
Delivery notes for what's in the box.
One report for a lot: which customers got it, if a batch turns out to have a fault.
A reorder list in days of cover for boxes, padding and tape as well as wax and jars.
| The job | Shipping sheet | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| What was in the box | From memory | The sales order |
| Which batch those candles were | Unknown | The lot shipped |
| Who else got that batch | Unknown | One report |
| Boxes running low | When they run out | The reorder list |
TaroStack doesn't buy postage, compare carriers or work out shipping at checkout. Stock, lots and sales orders are on every plan, from $9.99 a month. The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
