What goes on a soap label depends on a question that comes before the label: is the bar soap, in the regulator's sense, or a cosmetic? FDA's definition of soap is narrow. The bar has to be made mainly of the alkali salts of fatty acids, clean only by them, and be labeled and sold only as soap. Say on the wrapper that it moisturizes, and the same bar is a cosmetic, with a cosmetic's label: an identity, a net weight, your name and place of business, and every ingredient in order. Say it treats eczema and it's a drug. So the words you choose decide the list you owe. Below is the test, the cosmetic label line by line, how to write the ingredients, and a checklist.
The short version
- Soap, by FDA's definition: mostly alkali salts of fatty acids, cleaning only by them, sold only as soap.
- A claim beyond cleaning, such as moisturizing, makes it a cosmetic.
- A claim to treat or prevent a condition makes it a drug.
- A cosmetic's label: identity, net weight, name and place of business, ingredients.
- Ingredients go in descending order. Fragrance may be listed as "fragrance".
- True soap is under the Consumer Product Safety Commission, not FDA.
- TaroStack keeps each batch's recipe and lots behind the label. More below.
First, which is it?
| The bar | What it is | Who regulates it |
|---|---|---|
| Fats and lye, sold as "lavender soap" | Soap | Consumer Product Safety Commission |
| The same bar, sold as "moisturizing" or "deodorant" soap | Cosmetic | FDA |
| A bar that cleans with synthetic detergents | Cosmetic | FDA |
| A bar sold to treat acne or kill germs | Drug | FDA |
This is FDA's own three-part test from its page for soap makers. The page adds that you can still use the word "soap" on a cosmetic or a drug. It's the claim that moves the product, not the name. More examples are in FDA soap regulations.
For true soap, FDA says to direct questions about requirements to the Consumer Product Safety Commission. One soap maker's answer is to label every bar to the cosmetic list below, so that a change of wording on one wrapper never leaves a bar short of what its label owes.
The cosmetic label
| On the label | Where | The rule |
|---|---|---|
| Statement of identity | Principal display panel | 21 CFR 701.11 |
| Net quantity of contents | On the label | 21 CFR 701.13 |
| Name and place of business | On the label, conspicuously | 21 CFR 701.12 |
| Ingredients | An information panel, letters at least 1/16 inch high | 21 CFR 701.3 |
Identity is the common name, such as "soap", or a descriptive name.
Net quantity is by weight for a solid. The soap rule itself says a cleansing bar that's a cosmetic bears "an accurate statement of the weight of the bar in avoirdupois pounds and ounces." Weigh bars after they've cured: a bar loses water as it cures, and the weight has to be true when it's sold.
Name and place of business is the maker's, the packer's or the distributor's.
Listing the ingredients
The rule asks for the name of each ingredient in descending order of predominance. Fragrance may be listed simply as "fragrance".
A soap maker has a choice to make about how to name what's in the bar, because the oils and lye that go into the pot aren't what comes out of it.
| Written as what went in | Written as what's in the bar |
|---|---|
| Olive oil, coconut oil, water, sodium hydroxide, oatmeal, fragrance | Sodium olivate, sodium cocoate, water, glycerin, oatmeal, fragrance |
Both forms are in use among soap makers. This page doesn't settle which the rule prefers: ask FDA, or follow a labeling guide written for soap makers, and then be consistent across your line. Whichever you use, the order comes from the weights in your recipe. The cosmetic rules in full are in cosmetic labeling requirements.
Claims
FDA's page says the laws it enforces have no definition of "natural" or "organic", and that the same requirements apply whether ingredients are plant, animal, mineral or synthetic. "Organic" on a cosmetic is USDA's word: see organic claims on cosmetics. This is general information, not legal advice.
Get the checklist
Download the soap label checklist. One sheet and a read-me: the test for soap, cosmetic or drug, each part of the cosmetic label with its section, a made-up example and a column to tick. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
Twelve bars, each with its own oils, each label listing them in order of weight. Then the oatmeal bar's recipe changes: more coconut oil, for a harder bar. The ingredient order on a thousand printed labels is now wrong, and nothing says which batches were made before the change and which after. The batch code on the wrapper is the only link, and it links to a notebook.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the recipe behind each label.
Recipes by weight, with versions. A changed recipe is a new version, and each batch records which version it made.
Each batch notes the lots it used, automatically, as oils, lye and fragrance come off stock.
Every batch is a lot, and lot labels print with the code.
Your checks are fields on the batch record: cure date, bar weight, the label version.
| The question | Notebook | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Is the label's order still right | Reweigh the recipe | The recipe, by weight |
| Which batches are the old recipe | Unknown | The recipe version on each batch |
| Which fragrance lot went in | The bottle, if it's still there | The lots on the batch |
| What a cured bar weighed | A note | A field on the batch |
TaroStack doesn't design labels or decide whether a claim makes a bar a cosmetic. Recipes, batches and lots are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
