Ketchup sits on a shelf at room temperature for one reason: it's acid. The vinegar and the tomato hold its pH under 4.6, the federal line for a food sealed in a container and kept at room temperature. So a ketchup plan has two critical points. pH, measured on every kettle before filling, because the acid is the safety. And the hot fill, which deals with the yeasts and molds that acid doesn't stop. A third control isn't a critical point but matters as much: the recipe is weighed, because the vinegar is what keeps the number low. Whether your ketchup is an acid food or an acidified food, and what its limits are, comes from a process authority. Below are the rules as read today, a plan for a made-up maker, and a worksheet.
The short version
- The federal standard says what may be called ketchup: tomato, vinegar, sweetener, spices.
- pH 4.6 is the legal ceiling for an acid or acidified food. Your own limit will be lower.
- A process authority reviews the recipe and writes the process. Get the letter.
- Check pH on every kettle, with a meter, before filling.
- Hot fill at the temperature in your letter, cap, hold.
- A new lot of tomato paste is a reason to watch the pH, not a formality.
- TaroStack keeps the pH and fill temperature on each batch, with the lots that went in. More below.
What the standard calls ketchup
FDA has a standard of identity for it, under three spellings: catsup, ketchup, catchup. It's the food prepared from tomato ingredients (tomato concentrate, or the strained liquid from red tomatoes), with one or more ingredients from each of three groups added: vinegars; nutritive carbohydrate sweeteners; and spices, flavoring, onions or garlic. It may contain salt.
The same section says how it's kept: preserved by heat sterilization, refrigeration or freezing, and "when sealed in a container to be held at ambient temperatures, it is so processed by heat, before or after sealing, as to prevent spoilage". And it sets a thickness: in a Bostwick consistometer the finished ketchup flows no more than 14 centimeters in 30 seconds at 20°C.
Two things follow for a small maker. If the label says ketchup, the standard is what the product is measured against, so read it before adding an ingredient outside those groups. And LII's copy of the section, read on November 21, 2026, carries a note that an amendment was published on October 13, 2026: read the current text before you rely on any line of it.
Acid or acidified?
| Kind | What the rule says |
|---|---|
| Acid food | Natural pH of 4.6 or below |
| Acidified food | A low-acid food with acid or acid food added; finished equilibrium pH 4.6 or below; water activity above 0.85 |
| Outside the acidified-food rule | Among others: acid foods, "condiment sauces" included, that contain small amounts of low-acid food and whose finished pH doesn't differ significantly from the acid food's own; and foods stored, distributed and sold refrigerated |
The definitions also say tomatoes and tomato products with a finished equilibrium pH below 4.7 aren't classed as low-acid foods.
Ketchup is mostly tomato and vinegar, with onion, garlic and spices in small amounts. Whether those amounts are "small", and whether your recipe's pH "differs significantly", isn't yours to decide. A process authority looks at the recipe and says which kind of food it is, and writes the process if one is needed. The difference is laid out in acid food vs acidified food, and what the letter contains in process authority letter.
Either way, a facility covered by FDA's preventive controls rule writes a hazard analysis, whatever it concludes, and the rule names acidifying and heat processing as examples of process controls, each with a maximum or minimum value. That's what the two points below are.
The two points
A made-up maker of bottled ketchup. Its process is invented for the example.
| CCP | Limit | Checked | If it's missed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 pH | Legal ceiling 4.6. This maker's process: 3.9 or below | pH meter, each kettle, before filling | Hold the kettle, add vinegar as the process allows, mix, retest, log the deviation. Never fill above the limit |
| 2 Hot fill | This maker's process: 190°F or above at the filler, capped at once, bottle inverted 2 minutes | Start of the fill and every 30 minutes | Stop and reheat; set aside bottles filled since the last good reading |
pH. The rule's phrase is finished equilibrium pH. For an acidified food it requires that the pH be 4.6 or lower, with testing frequent enough to be sure of it, and it requires a pH meter, not strips or color, when the finished pH is above 4.0. This maker uses a meter for every reading and calibrates it each day with pH 4 and pH 7 buffers. The method is in pH testing for acidified foods.
Why 3.9 and not 4.6. A process sets a working limit with room under the legal line, because meters drift and ingredients vary. This maker's is 3.9, and most of its kettles read near 3.7.
The recipe is a control. The quickest way to move ketchup's pH is to change the vinegar. A cook who holds some back because the last batch tasted sharp, or thins a thick kettle with water, has made a different product. Weigh everything. No substitutions without asking the process authority, and that includes a different vinegar strength: 5% and 10% acidity aren't the same ingredient.
Tomato paste varies. Each lot has its own solids and its own pH. Keep each lot's specification sheet, and treat the first kettle from a new lot as the one most likely to read high.
Hot fill. Acid stops botulism. It doesn't stop mold or yeast, which is what the heat is for. Your letter gives the temperature and the hold.
The code on the bottle. For acidified foods the rule requires each container to carry a permanent code that identifies the establishment, the product, and the year, day and period it was packed. A code like that is worth having on any bottle: see how to create lot numbers. Glass belongs in the plan's prerequisites: see glass and brittle plastic policy.
A week of readings
| When | Batch | Check | Reading | Limit | OK? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 16, 9:20 AM | KT-1116 | pH | 3.72 | 3.9 or lower | Yes |
| Nov 16, 9:45 AM | KT-1116 | Hot fill | 194°F | 190°F or above | Yes |
| Nov 16, 10:15 AM | KT-1116 | Hot fill | 191°F | 190°F or above | Yes |
| Nov 18, 9:30 AM | KT-1118 | pH | 3.98 | 3.9 or lower | NO: act |
| Nov 18, 10:20 AM | KT-1118 | Hot fill | 188°F | 190°F or above | NO: act |
On the 18th the kettle read 3.98: under the legal 4.6, over the process limit of 3.9. It was the first kettle from a new lot of tomato paste. Vinegar was added as the process allows, the kettle was mixed for ten minutes, and it retested at 3.81. It went in the deviation log with the paste lot's number.
The same morning a label jam let the filler bowl cool to 188°F. The line stopped, the kettle went back to 195°F, and the 36 bottles filled since the last good reading at 10:05 were set aside.
This is general information, not legal advice. A process authority and your regulator have the last word. A sister plan with more vegetables in it is HACCP plan for tomato sauce, and the business side is in ketchup business plan.
Get the worksheet
Download the ketchup HACCP plan worksheet. Three sheets and a read-me: the hazard analysis from receiving to shipping, the plan with its two control points, and a monitoring log that checks each reading against its limit. Put your own process limits in place of the example's. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The log says KT-1118 read 3.98 and was corrected. It doesn't say which lot of paste was in the kettle unless somebody wrote it in the margin, or which other kettles that lot went into, or where the 36 bottles are now. A buyer's auditor asks for exactly that chain, from one bottle's code, and each link is on a different sheet.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the chain on the batch.
Each kettle is a batch with a lot code. Recording it takes the paste, vinegar and bottles from stock and notes which lots went in, automatically.
pH and fill temperature are fields on the batch record, with initials and a sign-off. The form prints with your own checklist.
Recipes are versioned. The recipe the process authority reviewed is the one the batch is made from, weighed in grams, and a change makes a new version.
Holds. Bottles set aside go on hold and are out of what can be sold or shipped until you release them.
One report for an audit or a recall: which supplier lots went into which batches, and which customers got them.
| The auditor asks | Paper | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| The pH of this bottle's batch | Find the sheet | On the batch record |
| Which paste lot went in | The margin, if written | On the batch record |
| Which other batches used that lot | Read every sheet | One report |
| Where the 36 bottles are | A note on a pallet | On hold, by lot |
TaroStack doesn't write your plan, set a limit or act as a process authority. Recipes, batches, lots and recalls are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
