A jar of tomato sauce on a shelf at room temperature is safe for one reason: it's acid enough that botulism spores can't grow. The federal line is a finished equilibrium pH of 4.6. Tomatoes sit just under it, and everything a cook adds to make sauce taste good (onion, garlic, peppers, mushrooms, oil) pulls the wrong way. So a tomato sauce plan has three critical points: pH, checked on every batch before it's filled; the hot fill, which deals with the molds and bacteria that spoil acid food; and the label, if any sauce on the line contains an allergen. The first decision isn't yours to make alone: whether your recipe is an acid food or an acidified food, and what its limits are, comes from a process authority. Below are the rules, a plan for a made-up maker, and a worksheet.
The short version
- pH 4.6 is the legal ceiling. Your own limit will be lower.
- More vegetables, higher pH. Weigh the recipe; don't judge it.
- A process authority reviews the recipe and writes the process. Get the letter.
- Check pH on every batch, with a meter, before filling.
- Hot fill at the temperature in your letter, cap, hold.
- TaroStack keeps the pH and fill temperature on each batch, with the lots that went in. More below.
Acid or acidified?
The rules sort shelf-stable foods three ways.
| Kind | What the rule says | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Acid food | Natural pH of 4.6 or below | Plain crushed tomatoes |
| Acidified food | A low-acid food with acid or acid food added; finished equilibrium pH 4.6 or below; water activity above 0.85 | Peppers in a tomato base, acidified to stay under 4.6 |
| Low-acid food | pH above 4.6 and water activity above 0.85 | A cream sauce; needs a different, far stricter process |
Two lines in the definitions matter for sauce. Tomatoes and tomato products with a finished equilibrium pH below 4.7 aren't classed as low-acid. And an acid food that contains small amounts of low-acid food, with a finished pH that doesn't differ significantly from the acid food's own, is outside the acidified-food rules.
So a marinara that's nearly all tomato with a little onion, garlic and basil may be an acid food with small amounts of low-acid ingredients. A chunky sauce that's a third roasted vegetables probably isn't. "Small" and "significantly" aren't yours to interpret: a process authority looks at the recipe and says which it is, and if it's acidified, writes the scheduled process. The difference is laid out in acid food vs acidified food, and what the letter contains in process authority letter.
Sauces sold refrigerated are outside the acidified-food rules too, and under ordinary food safety rules, with a short shelf life. A sauce with meat in it generally comes under USDA, not FDA: ask before you start.
The three points
A made-up maker of marinara and vodka sauce. Its scheduled process is invented for the example.
| CCP | Limit | Checked | If it's missed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 pH | Legal ceiling 4.6. This maker's process: 4.2 or below | pH meter, each kettle, before filling | Adjust as the process allows, retest, log the deviation. Never fill above the limit |
| 2 Hot fill | This maker's process: 185°F or above at the filler, capped at once, held 3 minutes | Start of the fill and every 30 minutes | Stop and reheat; set aside jars filled since the last good reading |
| 3 Labeling | Vodka sauce jars carry the vodka sauce label (contains milk) | First and last jar of each run | Hold and relabel |
pH. The rule says finished equilibrium pH: the pH after the pieces and the liquid have evened out. A reading from the thin liquid at the top of a kettle flatters a chunky sauce. Blend a sample, cool it, then measure. Above pH 4.0 the rule requires a pH meter, not paper strips. Calibrate it each day with pH 4 and pH 7 buffers. The method is in pH testing for acidified foods.
Why the limit is lower than 4.6. A process letter sets a working limit with room under the legal line, because meters drift and onions vary. This maker's is 4.2.
The recipe is a control. The fastest way to move the pH is to change the recipe: a cook who adds two more pounds of onion because the kettle "looked thin" has made a different product. Weigh every ingredient, and don't substitute fresh tomatoes for canned without asking the process authority: fresh ones vary more.
Hot fill. Acid stops botulism. It doesn't stop mold or yeast, which is what the heat is for. Your letter gives the temperature and the hold.
Glass. A breakage rule belongs in the plan's prerequisites: see glass and brittle plastic policy.
Records
For an acidified food, the rules ask for records of pH and other critical factors for each batch, with the product code, date and container size; any departure from the process in a separate log with what was done about it; and records of where each lot first went. They're kept three years from the date of manufacture.
A few days of readings
| When | Batch | Check | Reading | Limit | OK? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 16, 9:40 AM | MS-1116 marinara | pH | 4.08 | 4.2 or lower | Yes |
| Nov 16, 10:05 AM | MS-1116 marinara | Hot fill | 188°F | 185°F or above | Yes |
| Nov 16, 10:35 AM | MS-1116 marinara | Hot fill | 186°F | 185°F or above | Yes |
| Nov 17, 9:50 AM | MS-1117 marinara | pH | 4.31 | 4.2 or lower | NO: act |
| Nov 17, 10:40 AM | MS-1117 marinara | Hot fill | 187°F | 185°F or above | Yes |
On the 17th the kettle read 4.31: under the legal 4.6, over the process limit of 4.2. Citric acid was added as the process allows, the kettle was mixed for ten minutes and it retested at 4.12. It went in the deviation log, and the cause was found: the onions had been over-weighed by two pounds.
This is general information, not legal advice. A process authority and your regulator have the last word. A sister plan for a fresh-vegetable product is in salsa HACCP plan, and how long a jar keeps in pasta sauce shelf life.
Get the worksheet
Download the tomato sauce HACCP plan worksheet. Three sheets and a read-me: the hazard analysis from receiving to shipping, the plan with its three control points, and a monitoring log that checks each reading against its limit. Put your own process limits in place of the example's. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
Three years of batch sheets is a filing cabinet. A buyer's auditor picks a jar off the shelf, reads the code, and asks for its pH, its fill temperature, the lot of tomatoes that went in, and where the rest of the batch was shipped. Each answer is on a different piece of paper, and the clock is running.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack puts all four answers on one batch.
Each kettle is a batch with a lot code. Recording it takes the tomatoes, onions and jars from stock and notes which lots went in, automatically.
pH and fill temperature are fields on the batch record, with initials and a sign-off. The form prints with your own checklist.
Recipes are versioned. The recipe the process authority reviewed is the one the batch is made from, weighed out in grams, and a change makes a new version.
Allergens on Growth. With allergen tracking on, a batch can't start if its label leaves out an allergen its ingredients contain: the cream in the vodka sauce.
One report for a recall or an audit. Which supplier lots went into which batches, and which customers got them.
| The auditor asks | Filing cabinet | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| The pH of this jar's batch | Find the sheet | On the batch record |
| Which tomatoes went in | The receiving log, by date | On the batch record |
| Where the batch went | Invoices | One report |
| Which recipe was used | Whichever copy was on the wall | The version on the batch |
TaroStack doesn't write your plan, set a limit or act as a process authority. Recipes, batches, lots and recalls are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes, with allergen tracking). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
