A subscription box keeps about a third of its price, and shipping is why. A $45 monthly box has $14 of contents in it, six items at wholesale. The box, tissue and card are $2.20, packing is $2, payment fees $1.58, and shipping is $9.50. Delivered, it costs $29.28 and keeps 34.9%: $15.72 a subscriber a month. Then the cost of finding that subscriber comes out of it. In a full-speed month the made-up snack box below sells $13,735, keeps $4,999, and has $3,544 left after $1,455 of fixed costs, most of it marketing, with the packing paid at $20 an hour. Below are a box costed, the four kinds of sale, the month, and a calculator.
The short version
- A $45 box costs $29.28 delivered and keeps 34.9%.
- Shipping is $9.50 of it: two thirds of what the contents cost.
- A subscriber leaves $15.72 a month. How many months they stay is the business.
- Add-ons ride in a box that's already paid for and keep 46.5%.
- Marketing is the largest fixed cost. Count it per subscriber won.
- TaroStack counts the items by lot and date and what each box leaves. More below.
A box, costed
A monthly snack box of six items, shipped to a subscriber.
| A monthly box | Cost |
|---|---|
| Contents: six items at wholesale | $14.00 |
| Box, tissue and story card | $2.20 |
| Shipping | $9.50 |
| Packing, 6 minutes at $20 an hour | $2.00 |
| Payment fees, 3.5% | $1.58 |
| Cost | $29.28 |
The six snacks are less than half of the cost. Shipping is the line to design around: the box is the cheapest size and weight that fits six items, and one heavy jar can move it into the next rate.
Margins by product
| Product | Sold | Price | Cost | Gross profit | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly box, subscription | Shipped | $45.00 | $29.28 | $15.72 | 34.9% |
| Three-month gift, prepaid | Shipped | $129.00 | $87.62 | $41.38 | 32.1% |
| One-time box | Shipped | $52.00 | $29.52 | $22.48 | 43.2% |
| Add-on item | In a box already shipping | $12.00 | $6.42 | $5.58 | 46.5% |
The one-time box costs the same to send and sells for $7 more, so it leaves $22.48. The gap is the nudge toward subscribing.
A three-month gift is $129 of cash now for three boxes owed later. The money isn't earned until the third box ships, so set the items aside when it's sold.
An add-on leaves $5.58 with no box and no postage. Sixty a month add $335.
A month at full speed
| Product | Units | Sales | Gross profit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly box, subscription, shipped | 200 | $9,000 | $3,144 |
| Three-month gift, prepaid, shipped | 15 | $1,935 | $621 |
| One-time box, shipped | 40 | $2,080 | $899 |
| Add-on item, in a box already shipping | 60 | $720 | $335 |
| Month | $13,735 | $4,999 | |
| Fixed costs | −$1,455 | ||
| Left | $3,544 |
Fixed costs are $1,455 a month: marketing, ads, samples and referral credits ($1,000), packing space ($200), photos and content ($100), subscription software and the website ($80), insurance ($40), and other software ($35).
Break-even
| Fixed costs a month | $1,455 |
| Gross profit on each dollar of sales | 36 cents |
| Sales needed to cover fixed costs | $3,998 |
| As a share of a full-speed month | 29% |
The business covers its fixed costs at about $3,998 of sales a month. On subscriptions alone that's about 93 subscribers. In the plan this example comes from, the first year ends about $16,600 ahead on $93,700 of sales.
What moves it
| Change | Effect on a month |
|---|---|
| Shipping up $1 a box | −$285 |
| 20 subscribers cancel and aren't replaced | −$314 |
| One subscriber in three takes an add-on, not one in four | +$140 |
| A box priced at $48, with no one lost | +$579 |
Churn. A subscriber who stays six months leaves $94.32. One who cancels after two leaves $31.44. If winning a subscriber costs $25 in ads, the second one has barely paid for herself. Track how long people stay before raising the ad budget.
Dates. Snacks have best-by dates, and a box goes out a month before it's eaten. Buy to the subscriber count, and ship the oldest stock first.
The first year, month by month, is in subscription box business plan. Putting a box together from separate items is in kitting for gift boxes, costing the box and tissue in packaging cost per unit, and how much stock to hold in how much inventory to keep on hand.
Get the calculator
Download the subscription box profit margin calculator. One line for each product and where it sells: price, materials, packaging, labor and fees. It works out the cost, the gross profit, the margin and markup, and the price a target margin would need. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
October's box needs 255 of each of six items. One supplier shipped 240. Fifteen three-month gifts were sold in September, so their November and December items should be on a shelf somewhere. And the trail mix from August is two months from its date. A margin table can't say whether October's boxes can be packed.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the items counted and the box as a recipe.
Each delivery is a lot with its best-by date. Stock goes out first-expired-first-out by default, with an alert before a date arrives.
The month's box is a recipe: six items, a box, tissue, a card. Record the boxes packed and each item comes off stock.
"What could I make right now" says how many boxes the items on hand allow, and which item stops you.
A reorder list with supplier lead times and minimums, so October's items are ordered in September.
Margins by product on real cost, from what each month's items really cost.
| The job | Calculator | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Boxes you can pack today | Count six shelves | What could I make right now |
| Which item is short | Found at box 240 | The item that stops you |
| Stock close to its date | Check the labels | Expiry alerts |
| What October's box cost | The budget | From what you paid |
TaroStack doesn't bill subscribers or print postage. Stock, lots, recipes and costing are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
