Skip to content

Record Shop Profit Margin: New, Used and the Bins

Record shop profit margin worked through: new vinyl against used, the bargain bin, collectibles online, a month with rent, and a free calculator.

By Koa Sterling. Product specialist at TaroStack and small business owner. Yes, I am a real human, and I actually sit in front of a computer and write these articles. Reviewed November 21, 2026 · 6 min read

A record shop sells two different businesses from the same crates. New vinyl is bought from a distributor at a set cost and sold near a list price everyone can look up: in the made-up shop below, a new LP at $29.98 keeps 32.0%. Used vinyl is bought in collections for what the seller will take, then graded, cleaned and priced by the shop: a used LP at $14.00 keeps 59.5%. In this shop, new records bring people in and used records pay the rent. A shop that reads its sales total without splitting the two can have its best month for sales and lose money. Below are six lines, a month, what moves the number, and a calculator. Every figure is this shop's own.

The short version

  • A new LP keeps 32.0% of its price. A used one keeps 59.5%.
  • The bargain bin keeps 75.3% of three dollars: $2.26.
  • A collectible sold online keeps 49.3% after the marketplace's fee and postage.
  • A turntable keeps 25.5%, and sells sleeves and records after it.
  • This month sells $21,866 and has $1,923 left after rent and wages.
  • Used stock is only cheap if what you buy sells. Dead crates are cash.
  • TaroStack values the bins and shows what each kind of stock earns. More below.

Six lines

Product Sold where Price Cost Left Margin
New LP Shop $29.98 $20.40 $9.58 32.0%
Used LP, graded and cleaned Shop $14.00 $5.67 $8.33 59.5%
Used LP, bargain bin Shop $3.00 $0.74 $2.26 75.3%
Used LP, collectible Online marketplace $60.00 $30.40 $29.60 49.3%
Inner and outer sleeves, pack Shop $9.00 $4.47 $4.53 50.3%
Turntable, entry level Shop $179.00 $133.37 $45.63 25.5%

Cost is what the shop paid for the record or the goods, sleeves and mailers, the time to grade, clean, list and pack, and the fee a card processor or marketplace takes.

New. $19.50 in, $29.98 out, and 90 cents to the card processor. What's left is $9.58. The shop can't mark it up: the price is on the internet.

Used. A record from a bought collection costs this shop about $3.50, with $1.50 of time to grade and clean it and a new inner sleeve. It keeps $8.33, nearly as much as the new LP's $9.58, on less than half the price and a fraction of the cash.

The collectible. Sold online at $60.00, it loses 11% to the marketplace and $4.00 to listing and packing time, and still keeps $29.60. A few of these a month matter.

A month

Product, sold where Sold Sales Left after its own costs
New LP, shop 420 $12,592 $4,024
Used LP, graded and cleaned, shop 380 $5,320 $3,165
Used LP, bargain bin, shop 300 $900 $678
Used LP, collectible, online marketplace 24 $1,440 $710
Inner and outer sleeves, pack, shop 60 $540 $272
Turntable, entry level, shop 6 $1,074 $274
Total $21,866 $9,123
Fixed costs −$7,200
Left $1,923

Fixed costs here are rent, wages, utilities, insurance and the card terminal: $7,200 a month. At this mix the shop needs about $17,256 of sales to cover them.

New LPs are the biggest line by sales, $12,592, and leave $4,024. Used LPs sell less, $5,320, and leave $3,165. Swap 100 used sales for 100 new ones and sales rise $1,598 while what's left rises $125, with $1,950 more owed to the distributor.

What moves the number

  • The buy. A used record's margin is made when the collection is bought. Paying $3.50 a record for a crate that's half unsellable is paying $7.00 for the half that sells.
  • Dead stock. A used LP that sits for two years has kept nothing. Move it down to the bin on a schedule.
  • New release orders. New vinyl is paid for on terms and may not be returnable. Twenty copies of a record that sells eight is twelve times $19.50 on the wall.
  • Grading time. A dollar fifty a record is this shop's time. A collection of a thousand is a week.

Counting it all is in vinyl inventory spreadsheet. How fast stock turns is in inventory turnover example, and markup against margin in markup vs margin.

Get the calculator

Download the record shop profit margin calculator. One sheet and a read-me: a row for each line, with price, cost, sleeves, time and fees, and the cost, gross profit, margin and markup worked out. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.

Where this stops working

The calculator knows what a used LP keeps when it sells. It doesn't know that the shop has 4,000 of them, bought over six years, and which 600 have been in the same crate since they were priced. Margin by line is the easy half. The hard half is what's on the floor, what it cost, and how long it's been there.

How TaroStack does it

TaroStack works the margin out from what you actually paid.

Receiving records each delivery at what it cost, freight included, so a price rise shows up the week it happens.

Margins by product, on real cost. New and used are seen side by side, as different stock.

A price-creep report by supplier shows what went up and by how much.

Counting works on a phone, and a count shows what each difference is worth.

A reorder list in days of cover, with each supplier's lead time and minimum.

The question A sheet typed once In TaroStack
What a record costs today The price from the last time you typed it From the last delivery
Which product earns the most Last quarter's guess Margins by product
What went up Compare invoices Price creep, by supplier
What's on hand, and what it's worth Count and multiply Stock value

TaroStack doesn't run the till or list records on a marketplace. It connects to Square. Stock, receiving, counts and margins are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (50 items) or $39 a month (3,000 items). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.

Questions people also ask

What is the profit margin on vinyl records?

In this example a new LP keeps 32.0% of its price and a used LP 59.5%, before rent and wages.

Is a record store profitable?

This made-up shop sells $21,866 in a month and has $1,923 left after $7,200 of fixed costs, before the owner's pay. Used records, with the bins and collectibles, leave more than new ones on far lower sales.

Why do record shops sell used vinyl?

Because the shop sets both the buying and the selling price. Here a used LP costs $3.50 and sells for $14.00, while a new one costs $19.50 and sells for $29.98.

We use AI to help with the research for these articles. Every one is read, checked against its sources and edited by Koa before it's published. Spot a mistake? Tell us and we'll fix it and say so. How we write these.

Let’s get your stack in order.

Get TaroStack

Sign up now for your free 14 day trial. No credit card required.