Whether Etsy is worth it comes down to one number that Etsy's dashboard doesn't show: what an hour of your time earns. Sales are easy to see and flattering. To get from sales to an hourly figure you take off four things (Etsy's fees, the shipping label, your materials, and the monthly costs that belong to no single order), and then divide by all the hours: making, photographing, listing, packing, the trip to the post office. For the made-up potter below, a $38 mug brings in $44.50 with shipping and keeps $25.62. Thirty orders a month, a few refunds and $76 of monthly costs later, $645 is left for 25 hours of work: about $26 an hour. That's a real wage, and it's this shop's. Change the price, the item or the hours and the answer changes. Below are the sums, what moves them, how Etsy compares with other places to sell, and a worksheet.
The short version
- Count what you keep, not what you sell.
- An order keeps what's left after fees, label and materials: here 58% of what the buyer paid.
- Divide by every hour, not just the making.
- Small, cheap, slow-to-make items rarely pay. The fixed parts of an order eat them.
- Etsy's value is that buyers are already there. You pay for that in fees.
- TaroStack keeps materials and what each piece costs to make. It doesn't connect to Etsy. More below.
One order
| Item price | $38.00 |
| Shipping charged to the buyer | $6.50 |
| Etsy's fees on the order | −$4.63 |
| Shipping label | −$7.85 |
| Materials and packaging | −$6.40 |
| Kept | $25.62 |
| As a share of what the buyer paid | 57.6% |
The fees here are from one of this shop's own order records. Take yours the same way. They depend on the price, the shipping, the buyer's location and whether the sale came through one of Etsy's ads, and they've changed over time. A sheet for recording them order by order is in Etsy bookkeeping spreadsheet.
The month
| Orders | 30 |
| Kept from orders, after 4% refunded or lost | $720.76 |
| Monthly costs: ads, listing renewals, photo props, kiln upkeep | −$76.00 |
| Left | $644.76 |
| Hours: 35 minutes making and 15 minutes selling, for each order | 25 |
| What an hour earned | $25.79 |
Three orders cover the month's fixed costs. Everything after that is wages.
The hours are the honest part. Fifteen minutes an order for listing, photographing, answering messages, packing and posting is lean. New shops spend far more, with far fewer orders to spread it over. In the first months the hourly figure is usually terrible, and the question is whether it climbs.
What moves it
| Change | An hour earns |
|---|---|
| As above | $25.79 |
| Price up $4, same sales | $29.96 |
| Free shipping, label paid from the price | $19.02 |
| Half the orders arrive through Etsy's ads at a higher fee | About $23 |
| Batch the making: 25 minutes a mug, not 35 | $32.24 |
| 15 orders a month, not 30 | $22.75 |
| A $14 item that takes 20 minutes to make | About $10 |
Price. Four dollars more is about $4 more an hour. Most handmade sellers underprice, and a buyer choosing a handmade mug isn't choosing on $4.
Free shipping. It's a marketing decision that costs $6.50 an order here. Build it into the price or accept the lower wage.
The $14 item. Fees have a fixed part, a label costs the same whatever's in the box, and packing takes the same fifteen minutes. A cheap item pays all of that from a small price. This is why Etsy shops drift towards higher prices, sets and bundles.
Etsy against the alternatives
| Etsy | Your own website | Craft fairs | Wholesale to shops | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who brings the buyer | Etsy, mostly | You | The fair | The shop |
| What it costs | Fees on every order; ads | A subscription; your own marketing | A stall fee; a whole day | Half the retail price |
| Your time | Packing and messages | The same, plus finding buyers | Travel and standing | One delivery, many pieces |
| Good for | Starting; searchable items | Repeat customers you already have | Things people need to hold | Volume, once you can make it |
They aren't either-or. Many makers use Etsy to be found, a fair to be seen, and their own site for the customers who come back. Run the same hourly sum for each. A fair's version is in how much inventory for a craft fair, and pricing for shops in how to price handmade items for wholesale.
When it isn't worth it
When the hourly figure is under what you'd accept and isn't rising after six months. When the item can't carry the fixed costs of an order. When one copied listing or one search change halves your sales and you have no other way to reach buyers. The last is the real risk of any marketplace: the customers are its customers. Keep your own list of buyers where the rules allow it, and a second place to sell.
This is general information. Pricing is in how to price handmade items, and stock for the shop in Etsy inventory spreadsheet.
Get the worksheet
Download the Etsy worth-it worksheet. Type ten figures: price, shipping charged, fees, label, materials, minutes to make and to sell, orders a month, monthly costs and the share refunded. The Result sheet works out what an order keeps, what the month leaves and what an hour earns. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The worksheet rests on "materials: $6.40" and "35 minutes". Both were true when you measured them. Clay goes up, a glaze gets discontinued, a firing loses a third of its mugs, and the real figures drift while the worksheet's stay put. Six months on, the $26 an hour is a memory of a good month.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack doesn't connect to Etsy: orders and listing quantities there are still yours to enter. What it keeps current is the half of the sum Etsy can't know.
Each kind of piece is a recipe; each firing or making session is a batch. It takes clay, glaze and boxes from stock at what they cost.
The batch records how many good pieces came out. The cracked ones are in the cost of the rest. Recipe truth shows whether a firing yields what you plan on.
The cost of a piece is this month's, with a price-creep report by supplier.
Finished pieces are stock, counted on a phone, so a listing's quantity matches the shelf.
Margins by product on real cost, so you can see which items are worth listing.
| The figure | Worksheet | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Materials in a piece | Measured once | From each batch |
| Pieces lost in making | Not counted | In the batch's yield |
| Which items pay | One item at a time | Margin by product |
| Etsy's fees and orders | Typed in | Still typed in |
Stock, recipes and costing are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
