It can be, and how profitable depends on what the tallow is sold as. Rendered beef fat is cheap to make: in the example below, suet at $1.50 a pound gives tallow at $2.14 a pound, because 70% of the suet's weight is left after rendering. Sold as cooking tallow, a 14 oz jar keeps 62% of $12.00 at a market and 44% of $7.50 in a butcher shop. Sold as balm, the same tallow earns about fourteen times as much for each ounce. And the whole business rests on one input that isn't the renderer's to control: how much suet a butcher will part with, and at what price. Below are five lines with their margins, a month of sales, what moves the number, and a calculator. Every figure is the example's own.
The short version
- Tallow cost a pound = what you paid for suet ÷ your rendering yield.
- A 14 oz jar here costs $4.18 before fees: $1.88 of tallow, $1.10 of jar and label, $1.20 of time.
- Cooking tallow keeps 62% at a market and 44% to a shop.
- Balm keeps 76% at a market, on an ounce and a half of tallow.
- The month sells $3,020 and leaves $1,030 after fixed costs.
- Suet supply and price are the risk. Agree both with the butcher.
- TaroStack costs each rendering from what you paid and keeps it as a lot. More below.
What a pound of tallow costs
| A rendering | |
|---|---|
| Suet in | 20 lb |
| Paid, at $1.50 a pound | $30.00 |
| Tallow out, filtered | 14 lb |
| Yield | 70% |
| Tallow cost a pound | $2.14 |
| Jars of 14 oz filled | 16 |
| Tallow in a jar | $1.88 |
The yield is this renderer's own, from kidney suet rendered slowly and filtered twice. Trim fat with meat in it gives less. Weigh the suet in and the tallow out on every rendering: that one number sets the cost of everything below.
Five lines
| Product | Sold where | Price | Cost | Left | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cooking tallow, 14 oz jar | Farmers market | $12.00 | $4.54 | $7.46 | 62.2% |
| Cooking tallow, 14 oz jar | To a butcher shop | $7.50 | $4.18 | $3.32 | 44.3% |
| Tallow balm, 2 oz tin | Own website, shipped | $16.00 | $4.68 | $11.32 | 70.8% |
| Tallow balm, 2 oz tin | Farmers market | $14.00 | $3.34 | $10.66 | 76.1% |
| Tallow soap, 4.5 oz bar | Farmers market | $8.00 | $2.64 | $5.36 | 67.0% |
Cost is materials, packaging, the time to render, filter, pour, label and pack, and the fee a card processor or an online store takes.
The jar. $1.88 of tallow, $1.10 for a glass jar, lid and label, and $1.20 of time at $20 an hour. The jar and the time together cost more than what's in it.
The balm. A 2 oz tin holds about 1.4 oz of tallow, 19 cents' worth, with 58 cents of olive oil, beeswax and scent. The tin and label are 95 cents and the time is $1.20. It sells for more than the jar.
An ounce of tallow, two ways. In a jar at the market, 14 oz of tallow leaves $7.46: 53 cents an ounce. In a tin of balm, 1.4 oz leaves $10.66: $7.61 an ounce. When suet is the thing in short supply, that's the comparison that decides what to make with it.
The butcher shop. $7.50 a jar, no fee, no market day. It leaves $3.32, less than half of what a jar leaves at the market.
A month
| Product, sold where | Sold | Sales | Left after its own costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cooking tallow, farmers market | 60 | $720 | $448 |
| Cooking tallow, to a butcher shop | 80 | $600 | $266 |
| Balm, own website | 40 | $640 | $453 |
| Balm, farmers market | 50 | $700 | $533 |
| Soap, farmers market | 45 | $360 | $241 |
| Total | $3,020 | $1,940 | |
| Fixed costs | −$910 | ||
| Left | $1,030 |
Fixed costs here are market fees ($320), rented kitchen time ($250), insurance ($120), supplies and samples ($100), bookkeeping ($80) and the website ($40): $910 a month. At this mix the business needs about $1,416 of sales to cover them.
The month uses about 137 lb of tallow, which is 196 lb of suet. This renderer's butcher saves about 50 lb a week. That's the ceiling: the business can't grow past what one butcher's trim allows without a second supplier.
Balm is 90 of the 275 units sold and $986 of the $1,940 left: a third of the units and half of the money. The $1,030 at the bottom pays for four market days and the deliveries, which aren't in any product's cost.
What moves the number
- The price of suet. It was free until somebody noticed it was selling. At $3.00 a pound, tallow costs $4.29 a pound and a jar's tallow costs $3.75. The butcher shop jar then leaves $1.45, 19.3%, and the market jar $5.59, 46.6%. The balm barely moves.
- Yield. At 60% and the same $1.50 suet, tallow is $2.50 a pound, the jar's tallow is $2.19, and the shop jar leaves $3.01, 40.2%.
- Batch size. The $1.20 of time assumes 16 jars from a rendering. Half a batch takes nearly the same hours.
- The mix. Every jar sold to the shop is 14 oz of tallow that could have been ten tins of balm, if there were buyers for ten more tins.
Before the price
Whether tallow you render may be sold as food, from which kitchen and under whose inspection, comes before any of this. Ask your State's meat inspection program and your food regulator. Balm and soap are sold under different rules from food and from each other: start with cosmetic labeling requirements and FDA soap regulations. Margins for neighboring products are in soap business profit margin and lip balm profit margin, and the percentages are explained in markup vs margin.
Get the calculator
Download the beef tallow profit margin calculator. One sheet and a read-me: a row for each product and channel, with price, materials, packaging, time and fees, and the cost, gross profit, margin and markup worked out. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The calculator has one cost for tallow. The renderer has renderings. Tuesday's 20 lb of suet gave 14 lb and last week's gave 12.5, the butcher's price changed in between, and the tallow from both is in the same pails. What a jar cost depends on which pail it was filled from, and a balm customer with a complaint is asking which rendering her tin came from.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps each rendering as a batch.
Suet comes in as a lot at what you paid that day.
The rendering is a batch: suet in, tallow out. The batch records both, so the yield is on the record and the tallow's cost comes from it.
Tallow is a sub-recipe in the jar, the balm and the soap, so each product's cost follows the tallow's.
Each product batch notes the lots it used, automatically, and what it makes carries your batch code.
Recipe truth: from your own batch history, whether a rendering yields what you think it does.
| The number | Calculator | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| What suet cost | One price, typed in | What you paid for each lot |
| The rendering yield | Typed in once | From each batch |
| What a tin of balm cost | An estimate | From the tallow and oils it used |
| Which rendering a tin came from | Not there | The lots on the batch |
TaroStack doesn't cost your time: labor stays a line you add. Recipes, batches and lots are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
