Garlic can be profitable on a small piece of ground, and the margin on a sale looks almost too good: a pound of culinary garlic sold at $14 keeps 87.4%, and a pound of seed garlic at $24 keeps 86.0%. They look that way because the growing isn't in them. Planting, mulching, weeding, harvest and curing are fixed costs, paid whether the bulbs sell or not, and a fifth of every harvest goes back in the ground as next year's seed. The honest test is the year. On the made-up half-acre farm below, a selling year brings $38,190 of sales and $31,602 of gross profit, and after $9,900 of fixed costs $21,702 is left, before the grower is paid for a year's work. Below are a sale costed, the four products, the year, and a calculator.
The short version
- A sale keeps 74% to 87% of its price, because the growing is a fixed cost.
- The year is the test: $21,702 on $38,190 of sales, before the grower's pay.
- Seed garlic leaves $20.65 a pound against $12.23 for culinary. Grade for it.
- A fifth of the crop is next year's seed. Don't sell it.
- Sales come from July to December. The cash has to last through May.
- TaroStack counts the crop by variety and grade, and what each product leaves. More below.
A pound, costed
What a sale costs is the work after the harvest.
| A pound of culinary garlic at a market | Cost |
|---|---|
| Cleaning, trimming and grading, 4 minutes at $18 an hour | $1.20 |
| Bag and label | $0.15 |
| Card fee, 3% of $14 | $0.42 |
| Cost | $1.77 |
Nothing in that table grew the garlic. The land, the mulch, the field help and the curing barn come to $825 a month whether a bulb sells or not, and the seed came out of last year's crop. That's why the margin on a pound says little, and the year says everything.
Margins by product
| Product | Sold | Price | Cost | Gross profit | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Culinary garlic, a pound | Markets and restaurants | $14.00 | $1.77 | $12.23 | 87.4% |
| Seed garlic, a pound | Shipped to gardeners | $24.00 | $3.35 | $20.65 | 86.0% |
| Softneck braid, 10 heads | Markets | $28.00 | $7.14 | $20.86 | 74.5% |
| Black garlic, 2 oz jar | Markets and online | $10.00 | $2.60 | $7.40 | 74.0% |
Seed garlic is the same bulb, graded for size and sold to gardeners in the weeks before planting. It leaves $20.65 a pound where culinary garlic leaves $12.23.
Braids and black garlic keep less of their price, because they add work: twenty minutes to braid, three weeks to ferment and then the peeling. What they do is sell garlic in the months when fresh bulbs are scarce, and use the small heads that don't grade.
The selling year
| Product | Sold in the year | Sales | Gross profit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Culinary garlic, a pound, markets and restaurants | 920 | $12,880 | $11,252 |
| Seed garlic, a pound, shipped to gardeners | 552 | $13,248 | $11,399 |
| Softneck braid, 10 heads, markets | 184 | $5,152 | $3,838 |
| Black garlic, 2 oz jar, markets and online | 691 | $6,910 | $5,113 |
| Year | $38,190 | $31,602 | |
| Fixed costs | −$9,900 | ||
| Left | $21,702 |
Fixed costs are $825 a month, $9,900 a year: land rent, straw mulch and fertilizer, field help for planting, weeding and harvest, power for the curing barn, market fees, insurance and the website. Sales aren't spread like that. August and September bring $8,300 each, May brings nothing, and from March to June the farm spends more than it takes.
Break-even
| Fixed costs a year | $9,900 |
| Gross profit on each dollar of sales | 83 cents |
| Sales needed to cover fixed costs | $11,964 |
| As a share of the year's sales | 31% |
The farm needs about $11,964 of sales in the year to cover its fixed costs, 31% of what it sells. So a poor year still pays its costs. What a poor year doesn't do is pay the grower.
What moves it
| Change | Effect on the year |
|---|---|
| A fifth less to sell: a wet spring, or bulbs lost in storage | −$6,320 |
| Culinary garlic sells at $12 a pound, not $14 | −$1,785 |
| 100 pounds graded up from culinary to seed | +$842 |
| Selling the seed you should have planted | A better year, then no crop |
Seed is the stock. A garlic farm's most valuable inventory is the fifth of the harvest it replants. Count it, grade it and store it apart from what's for sale, by variety.
The grower's pay. The $21,702 is what's left before the grower is paid. Half an acre of garlic is a good second income, or one crop on a bigger farm. It isn't a full-time wage.
The year, month by month, is in garlic farm business plan, pricing by the pound and the head in how to price garlic, and what a stall really costs in cost to sell at a farmers market.
Get the calculator
Download the garlic profit margin calculator. One line for each product and where it sells: price, materials, packaging, labor and fees. It works out the cost, the gross profit, the margin and markup, and the price a target margin would need. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The margin table has four products. The barn has six varieties in three grades, some set aside as seed, some promised to a restaurant, and some going soft in a corner. How many pounds of seed-grade garlic are left to sell in October, without touching what's to be planted, isn't a number a calculator holds.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the crop as stock, by variety and grade.
Each harvest is a lot, by variety, with its date. Seed stock and stock for sale are separate items, so one isn't sold as the other.
Braids and black garlic are recipes. A batch takes its heads from stock and records what came out.
Every adjustment carries a reason: sprouted, soft, composted. What storage cost you is a number in spring.
Margins by product on real cost, so a jar of black garlic can be compared with a pound of bulbs.
Counting on a phone, in the barn, with no signal.
| The job | Calculator | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Pounds left to sell, by variety | Weigh the crates | Stock by item |
| Seed kept for planting | A marked corner | Its own item, counted |
| What storage losses cost | Unknown | Adjustments by reason |
| Which product pays | A feeling | Margin by product |
TaroStack doesn't plan your beds or forecast the weather. Stock, lots, recipes and costing are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
