A fresh fish business works on thin margins, for a plain reason: the fish is most of the price. A fillet that sells for $25.99 a pound has $15.48 of fish in it before anyone wraps it. In the example below, a made-up fish stall keeps 32% to 36% of what it sells over the counter, 18% on a restaurant order, and 51% on the one thing it makes, a smoked fish dip. Its month sells $37,836 and leaves $5,405 after the stall's costs and the fish that didn't sell in time, before the owner is paid. Below are six lines with their margins, the month, what moves the number, and a calculator. Every figure is the example's own.
The short version
- Fillets and shrimp keep about a third of their price at the counter.
- Fish is 87% to 91% of the cost of every line but the dip.
- A restaurant order at $18.50 a pound keeps 17.8%: volume, not margin.
- A made product keeps the most: smoked fish dip, 50.9%.
- Fish that doesn't sell by its day comes straight off the month.
- The month here: $37,836 of sales, $5,405 left before the owner's pay.
- TaroStack keeps each delivery as a lot at what you paid, with its date. More below.
Six lines
| Product | Sold where | Price | Cost | Left | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Snapper fillet, a lb | Stall | $25.99 | $17.76 | $8.23 | 31.7% |
| Salmon fillet, a lb | Stall | $21.99 | $14.36 | $7.63 | 34.7% |
| Shrimp, peeled, a lb | Stall | $17.99 | $11.54 | $6.45 | 35.9% |
| Whole fish, scaled and gutted, a lb | Stall | $11.99 | $8.18 | $3.81 | 31.8% |
| Fillet to a restaurant, a lb | Delivered | $18.50 | $15.20 | $3.30 | 17.8% |
| Smoked fish dip, 8 oz tub | Stall | $9.00 | $4.42 | $4.58 | 50.9% |
Cost is the fish at what it cost for each pound sold after cutting, ice, wrap and bags, the time to cut and wrap, and a 3% card fee at the stall.
The fish in a fillet. Snapper bought whole at $6.50 a pound gives this stall 42% fillet, so a pound of fillet has $15.48 of fish in it. The sum is worked through in how to price fish. Add 25 cents of ice and wrap, $1.25 of cutting time and a 78 cent card fee, and it's $17.76.
Whole fish keeps the same share and a third of the dollars. 31.8% of $11.99 is $3.81 a pound, against $8.23 for fillet. It also takes a fraction of the knife time.
The dip. Trim and unsold fillet, smoked, with $2.60 of fish and cream cheese in a tub, 45 cents of tub and label, and $1.10 of time. It keeps half its price, and it's made from fish that would otherwise be a loss.
The restaurant order
Five hundred pounds a month at $18.50 looked like the order that would make the year. Here's what it is.
| A lb | 500 lb a month | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $18.50 | $9,250 |
| Fish | $13.90 | $6,950 |
| Ice, wrap, cutting, delivery | $1.30 | $650 |
| Left | $3.30 | $1,650 |
It's a quarter of the stall's sales and 14% of what's left after product costs. That's still $1,650 the stall wouldn't have, on fish the chef has promised to take, with nothing unsold at the end of the day. Two things decide whether it's a good order.
Does it get paid on time? The stall pays the boats this week. A restaurant on 30-day terms owes $9,250 before the first payment arrives.
Does the price follow the dock? $3.30 a pound is the whole cushion. If the dock price rises 10%, the fish in a pound goes from $13.90 to $15.29 and the $3.30 is $1.91. Agree a price that moves with the market, or a price for a set time.
A month
| Product | Sold | Sales | Left after its own costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Snapper fillet | 260 lb | $6,757 | $2,140 |
| Salmon fillet | 420 lb | $9,236 | $3,205 |
| Shrimp, peeled | 380 lb | $6,836 | $2,451 |
| Whole fish | 300 lb | $3,597 | $1,143 |
| Fillet to a restaurant | 500 lb | $9,250 | $1,650 |
| Smoked fish dip | 240 tubs | $2,160 | $1,099 |
| Total | $37,836 | $11,688 | |
| Fixed costs | −$5,300 | ||
| Fish that didn't sell in time | −$983 | ||
| Left | $5,405 |
Fixed costs here are wages ($2,400), the stall's rent ($1,400), ice ($600), the van ($550), insurance ($260) and licenses ($90): $5,300 a month.
The fish that didn't sell. This stall finds that about 6% of what it buys for the counter isn't sold at full price by its day. On $15,393 of fish sold at the stall, that's $983 of fish bought and not paid for by a customer. It's the size of a wage, and it's the first thing to work on: buy closer to what sells, cut to order, turn the rest into dip.
The dip is 6% of sales and 9% of what's left. Every fish business has an equivalent: chowder, fish cakes, smoked fillets. It's where the margin is, and it's where the food safety rules get more involved.
What moves the number
- The dock price. It changes weekly and the board price changes monthly, if that. Reprice when the cost moves.
- Yield. Two points of fillet yield on snapper is 77 cents a pound. A cutting test each month costs ten fish and a scale: see butcher yield test.
- What doesn't sell. At 10% unsold, the $983 is $1,710 and what's left drops to $4,678.
- The mix. A pound of salmon fillet leaves $7.63 and a pound of whole fish $3.81. Which one the customer walks away with matters more than a dollar on either price.
Selling seafood comes with food safety rules of its own: what applies to a business that cuts, packs or smokes fish is in seafood HACCP plan and smoked fish HACCP plan. The stock sheet is in seafood market inventory sheet and the wider plan in fish market business plan.
Get the calculator
Download the fish market profit margin calculator. One sheet and a read-me: a row for each product and channel, with price, the cost of the fish, packaging, time and fees, and the cost, gross profit, margin and markup worked out. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The calculator has one cost for snapper and no calendar. The stall has Monday's fish and Thursday's fish in the same case at two prices, and the question every morning is what has to sell today. The 6% that doesn't sell is an estimate until somebody writes down every pound that's marked down, smoked or binned.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the fish by delivery and by date.
Each delivery comes in as a lot, at what you paid, with its date.
Cutting is a batch: whole fish in, fillet and trim out, with the yield on the record.
First-expired-first-out by default, and lots close to their date are flagged.
A forecast of what will expire unsold, and what it costs, while there's still time to smoke it.
Write-offs carry a reason, and margins come from what each lot actually cost.
| The question | Calculator | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| What has to sell today | Look in the case | Lots, by date |
| What this fillet cost | One typed number | From the lot and the cutting batch |
| How much didn't sell | "About 6%" | Write-offs, by reason |
| Is the restaurant price still worth it | Redo the sum | Margin by customer |
TaroStack connects to Square. It doesn't take temperatures or write a HACCP plan. Lots, expiry, batches and margins are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
