On paper, yes: a natural deodorant stick is a few ounces of butters, oils, wax and powder in a tube, and it sells for many times what's in it. In the example below, a made-up maker's 2.5 oz stick costs $3.05 to make and keeps 71.6% of its price at a craft market and 56.4% sold to a shop. The margin isn't where the difficulty is. A stick lasts a customer two or three months, so the business is in how many people buy a second one, and in the hours it takes to sell each first one. Below are five lines with their margins, a month of sales against fixed costs, what moves the number, and a calculator. Every figure is the example's own.
The short version
- A 2.5 oz stick here costs $3.05: $1.35 of materials, 95 cents of tube and label, 75 cents of time.
- At a market it keeps $8.59 of $12.00. To a shop it keeps $3.95 of $7.00.
- The month sells 500 units for $4,860 and leaves $2,049 after fixed costs.
- That $2,049 has to pay for the selling hours. The cost of a stick counts only making it.
- Repeat buyers decide it. One sale every two or three months, per customer, is the ceiling.
- TaroStack costs each batch from what you paid and keeps it as a lot. More below.
Five lines
| Product | Sold where | Price | Cost | Left | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Deodorant stick, 2.5 oz | Own website, shipped | $14.00 | $4.74 | $9.26 | 66.1% |
| Deodorant stick, 2.5 oz | Craft markets | $12.00 | $3.41 | $8.59 | 71.6% |
| Deodorant stick, 2.5 oz | To shops | $7.00 | $3.05 | $3.95 | 56.4% |
| Deodorant cream, 2 oz jar | Own website, shipped | $12.00 | $3.92 | $8.08 | 67.3% |
| Travel stick, 0.5 oz | Craft markets | $5.00 | $1.50 | $3.50 | 70.0% |
Cost is materials, packaging, the time to make, pour, label and pack, and the fee a card processor or an online store takes.
The stick. $1.35 of shea butter, coconut oil, wax, arrowroot, baking soda and scent. 95 cents for a push-up tube and a label. 75 cents of time, at $20 an hour, when sticks are poured sixty at a go. That's $3.05 before it's sold.
Online adds $1.69. A mailer is 50 cents, packing the order is 35 cents more of time, and the store and card fees are 6% of $14.00, 84 cents. The customer pays the postage. The website price is $2.00 higher than the market's and leaves only 67 cents more.
The travel stick. A fifth of the product and nearly 60% of the packaging: a small tube costs 55 cents. It keeps $3.50, and it's what a market visitor buys to try. Its job is the second sale.
The shop. $7.00 is half the website price, because the shop doubles it. The stick keeps $3.95, less than half of what it keeps at a market, with no market day spent selling it.
A month
| Product, sold where | Sold | Sales | Left after its own costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stick, own website | 90 | $1,260 | $833 |
| Stick, craft markets | 140 | $1,680 | $1,203 |
| Stick, to shops | 180 | $1,260 | $711 |
| Cream, own website | 30 | $360 | $242 |
| Travel stick, craft markets | 60 | $300 | $210 |
| Total | 500 | $4,860 | $3,199 |
| Fixed costs | −$1,150 | ||
| Left | $2,049 |
Fixed costs here are market fees ($420), a share of a workspace ($200), marketing and samples ($200), insurance ($110), bookkeeping ($100), the website ($60) and software ($60): $1,150 a month. At this mix the business needs about $1,747 of sales to cover them.
What the $2,049 pays for. Making 500 units is about 20 hours, and that time is already in the cost. Four market days, shop deliveries, photos, emails and the books aren't. If those come to 48 hours, the month pays about $43 for each. If they come to 100, it pays about $20. A maker who doesn't count them will think the business earns more than it does.
Shops against markets. Shops take the most units, 180, and leave $711. Markets take 140 sticks and leave $1,203. Moving 100 sticks from shops to markets would add $464, if the market had 100 more buyers, which is what a market can't promise. Shops reorder without anyone standing at a table.
What moves the number
- Repeat buying. A stick lasts this maker's customers about ten weeks. A customer is worth five sticks a year at best. The cheapest sale is the reorder, so the card in the mailer and the email in the tenth week matter more than the next market.
- Batch size. The 75 cents of time assumes sixty sticks a pour. Pouring twenty at a time, with the same setup and cleanup, is this maker's $1.60 a stick, and the shop margin drops from 56.4% to 44.3%.
- Summer. This maker's stick softens in a hot mailbox. A firmer summer batch, or a refund, is a cost that shows up in July and nowhere on the calculator.
- Ingredient prices. Materials are 44% of a shop stick's cost. A 20% rise adds 27 cents and takes the shop margin to 52.6%.
What the product is in the eyes of a regulator depends on what it claims to do. That, the label, and the full plan are in deodorant business plan and cosmetic labeling requirements. Margins for the wider trade are in cosmetic business profit margin, and the sum behind a shop's price in markup vs margin.
Get the calculator
Download the deodorant profit margin calculator. One sheet and a read-me: a row for each product and channel, with price, materials, packaging, time and fees, and the cost, gross profit, margin and markup worked out. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The calculator has one cost for a stick. The business has batches. The shea butter bought in March cost more than January's, Tuesday's pour made 54 sticks and not 60, and a shop phones about a stick that's gone grainy. Which batch was it, what went into it, and who else has one? A margin sheet doesn't know any of that, and neither does a list that says "212 sticks on hand".
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the batch behind each stick.
Recipes with true cost, from what you actually paid for each butter, oil and tube.
Each batch is a record that notes which ingredient lots it used and how many sticks it made, against what the recipe says it should.
The sticks are a lot, with your batch code and dates, so a complaint leads back to a pour.
Customers and sales orders for the shops, with what ships recorded by lot.
Margins by product and by customer, on what each batch actually cost.
| The job | Calculator | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| What a stick cost in this batch | One number, typed in | From the lots it used |
| Sticks made against sticks expected | Not there | On the batch |
| Which shops got a batch | Not there | On the lot's report |
| Which line earns most | Typed estimates | Margins from real costs |
TaroStack doesn't count your selling hours. Recipes, batches and lots are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
