A handmade plushie is forty-five minutes of someone's skilled time wrapped around five dollars of fabric. The materials for an 8 inch sewn animal (minky, stuffing, safety eyes, thread) come to $4.73. Cutting, sewing, turning, stuffing, closing and adding a face takes three hours for a batch of four, which is $15.00 each at $20 an hour. With a bag, a tag and a share of the machine, one plushie costs $20.93. That's the number a price has to clear, and it's why $15 plushies don't come from people who sew them. In the example below, $38 at a craft fair leaves $15.93, $40 online after fees leaves $15.07, and a shop paying $20 loses 93 cents. Below are the sums, how to sew faster, and a calculator.
The short version
- A plushie costs about $20.93: $4.73 of materials, $15.00 of time.
- Time is 72% of the cost. Speed is the only real lever.
- Sew in batches: cut four, sew four, stuff four.
- Price by size and by how many pieces the pattern has.
- Toys for children have safety rules. Read them before you sell.
- TaroStack takes fabric and eyes off stock when you make a batch. More below.
What a plushie costs
A made-up maker. Four 8 inch plushies, sewn as a batch.
| What goes in | Amount | You pay | Cost in the batch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minky fabric | 1 yd | $14.00 a yd | $14.00 |
| Polyester stuffing | 12 oz | $7.50 for 32 oz | $2.81 |
| Safety eyes | 8 each | $6.50 for 100 each | $0.52 |
| Thread, felt and embroidery floss | $1.60 | ||
| Materials, the batch | $18.93 |
| For one plushie | |
|---|---|
| Materials | $4.73 |
| Time: 180 minutes a batch at $20 an hour | $15.00 |
| Machine, needles and patterns: $3.00 a batch | $0.75 |
| Clear bag, hang tag | $0.45 |
| Full cost | $20.93 |
Minky is the main material cost and the hardest to sew: it stretches and sheds. A yard makes four of this pattern with careful layout. Careless cutting makes three, and the fabric in each goes from $3.50 to $4.67.
Sewing faster
| How you work | Minutes each | Time each | Full cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| One at a time, start to finish | 60 | $20.00 | $25.93 |
| Batches of four (the example) | 45 | $15.00 | $20.93 |
| Batches of eight, embroidered face | 35 | $11.67 | $17.09 |
Batching saves the setting-up: one thread change, one pattern tracing, one session at the machine, one evening stuffing. An embroidered face in place of felt pieces and safety eyes saves ten minutes and a small part.
Size and pieces. Price doesn't scale with height. A 16 inch plushie has four times the fabric of an 8 inch one and perhaps twice the time. A pattern with twelve pieces takes far longer than one with four at the same size. Time your own patterns, once each, and price from that.
Crochet is a different sum: yarn is cheaper than minky and the hours are much longer. See how to price crochet items.
Three prices
| Where it sells | Price a plushie | Fees | Left a plushie | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Craft fair | $38.00 | 3% | $15.93 | 42% |
| Online, with marketplace fees | $40.00 | 10% | $15.07 | 38% |
| Wholesale to a shop | $20.00 | −$0.93 | -5% |
$38 at a craft fair leaves $15.93. Handmade plush sells on character: the one with the lopsided smile goes first. Don't price below the full cost because a factory toy is $12.
$40 online leaves $15.07 after about 10% in marketplace and payment fees, before the mailer and your packing time. Charge shipping separately.
$20 wholesale loses 93 cents each. With batches of eight and an embroidered face the cost is about $17.09 and the order leaves $2.91: thin, and only worth it for a shop that reorders. Most plush makers sell direct for this reason.
Before you sell
A plush toy for children is a children's product, and in the United States that brings federal safety rules: tracking labels, limits on certain substances, and, for toys for children under three, rules about small parts such as eyes that could come off. Read CPSIA tracking label requirements and the Consumer Product Safety Commission's guidance for small makers before you sell. Embroidered eyes can't come off, which is why many makers use them on anything a baby might be given.
The general method is in how to price handmade items, other sewn work in how to price sewing projects, and a sheet for any craft in craft pricing calculator.
Get the calculator
Download the plushie price calculator. Two sheets and a read-me: the batch cost, to type your own recipe and prices over, and the prices with what each leaves. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
A custom order for six in a client's colors: is there enough of the grey minky, are there twelve 9 mm eyes left, and what did that fabric cost when it was bought? The calculator has one fabric at $14 a yard. The bins have eleven fabrics bought at eleven prices.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the cost of a plushie current, and takes the materials off stock when you make one.
Each design is a recipe. A quarter yard of minky, three ounces of stuffing, two eyes, a tag. Units convert, so what you buy by the yard or the box and use by the inch or the piece is one item.
Cost follows what you paid. Each batch is costed from the materials it used, at what they cost you.
"What could I make right now" says how many you can make from what's on the shelf, and which material stops you.
Finished pieces are stock, counted on a phone, so what you list or pack for a fair is what you have.
| The job | Calculator | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Cost a plushie today | Retype the prices | From what you paid |
| Enough materials for the order? | Look in the bins | What could I make right now |
| Enough grey minky for six | Unroll and measure | Stock by fabric and color |
| How many are finished | Count the table | Stock, by design |
TaroStack costs materials and packaging. Your time is yours to add, as above. Stock, recipes and true cost are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes, 50 items) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
