Peanut brittle is cheap to make and slow to make, and pricing it from the ingredients alone is how people end up working for nothing. One pot makes about two and a half pounds, which is five 8 oz bags. The ingredients come to $1.12 a bag. Add the bag and label, forty-five minutes at the stove and the counter, and a little for the kitchen, and each bag has cost $4.67. So $5 a bag pays you 33 cents. In the example below, $9 at a farmers market leaves $4.06 a bag, and a gift shop paying $5.50 leaves 83 cents. Below are the sums, what to do about the time, and a calculator.
The short version
- Ingredients are about a quarter of the cost. Your time is more than half.
- One pot is one batch: brittle doesn't double well.
- Weigh the finished brittle. Bags come from that, not from the recipe.
- Price by the bag, at a round number above your full cost.
- Wholesale only works if you can make it faster.
- TaroStack keeps the cost current as peanut and butter prices move. More below.
What a bag costs
A made-up home candy maker. One pot, about 2.5 lb, five 8 oz bags.
| What goes in | Amount | You pay | Cost in the batch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sugar | 0.88 lb | $8.50 for 10 lb | $0.75 |
| Corn syrup | 11.5 oz | $4.20 for 32 oz | $1.51 |
| Raw peanuts | 1 lb | $14.00 for 5 lb | $2.80 |
| Butter | 1 oz | $4.80 for 16 oz | $0.30 |
| Baking soda, vanilla, salt | $0.25 | ||
| Ingredients, the batch | $5.61 |
| For one bag | |
|---|---|
| Ingredients | $1.12 |
| Time: 45 minutes a batch at $18 | $2.70 |
| Kitchen, power, thermometer: $2 a batch | $0.40 |
| Bag, label and tie | $0.45 |
| Full cost | $4.67 |
Peanuts are half the ingredient cost. Buy them five pounds at a time, not by the jar, and that line halves.
Why the time is the problem
Brittle has to be cooked to hard crack, stirred, poured and pulled thin while it's hot. A bigger pot cooks unevenly and sets before you can spread it, so most makers stay at one pot. Five bags every forty-five minutes is the pace, and at $18 an hour that's $2.70 a bag before anything else.
There are three honest ways to bring it down:
| Change | Effect |
|---|---|
| Two pots, staggered ten minutes apart | Ten bags in about an hour: time falls to $1.80 a bag |
| Weigh out dry ingredients for six batches at once | Saves five minutes a batch |
| Bag everything at the end, not after each pot | Saves the same again |
Or accept the time and charge for it. Handmade brittle from a named kitchen isn't competing with the tin at the drugstore.
Three prices
| Where it sells | Price a bag | Card fees | Left a bag | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Farmers market | $9.00 | 3% | $4.06 | 45% |
| Holiday order, 4 bags for $32 | $8.00 | 3% | $3.09 | 39% |
| Wholesale to a gift shop | $5.50 | $0.83 | 15% |
$9 a bag is $18 a pound, which is in the range for handmade candy at a market. If that feels high, remember that $5 a bag left 33 cents.
The gift shop will sell it at $10 or $11 and wants to pay about half. At $5.50 you keep 83 cents a bag. With the two-pot method the cost falls to about $3.77 and the same sale leaves $1.73. Wholesale candy is a production problem before it's a pricing one.
A tin for the holidays. Two bags' worth in a $2.50 tin costs $10.94 to make. At $24 it leaves about $12.34, better than selling the two bags apart, and it's what people are looking for in December.
Before you sell
Brittle is one of the foods most cottage food laws allow from a home kitchen, but the rules differ by state, and a label is nearly always required. Peanuts are a major allergen, and so is the milk in the butter: both go on the label, in plain words. Whether candy needs a licence where you are is in license to sell candy. Humidity is brittle's enemy: seal the bags the day it's made.
Other candies, costed the same way: how to price toffee, how to price pralines and how to price candy.
Get the calculator
Download the peanut brittle price calculator. Two sheets and a read-me: the batch cost, to type your own recipe and prices over, and the prices with what each leaves. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The sheet was right in October. In November butter went up, the peanuts came from a different shop, and the December batches used a new bag that costs twice as much. Nobody reprices a candy mid-season, and the calculator sits unopened while the 83 cents turns into nothing.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the cost of a bag current without anyone opening a spreadsheet.
The recipe is by weight. Sugar, syrup, peanuts, butter, a bag and a label. Units convert, so peanuts bought by the five-pound bag and used by the pound are one item.
Cost follows what you paid. Each batch is costed from the deliveries it used. When butter goes up, the next batch costs more, and you see it.
"What could I make right now" says how many batches the peanuts, syrup and bags on hand allow before the holiday order.
Allergens on Growth. With allergen tracking on, the item says peanuts and milk, and a batch can't start if its label leaves one out.
Lots and dates. Each batch gets a lot code and a best-by, and lot labels print with both.
| The job | Calculator | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Cost a bag today | Retype the prices | From what you paid |
| Enough peanuts for 40 bags? | Check the cupboard | What could I make right now |
| Peanuts and milk on the label | Remember | Checked before the batch starts (Growth) |
| Which batch is this bag? | Unknown | Its lot code |
TaroStack costs ingredients and packaging. Your time is yours to add, as above. Recipes, batches and true cost are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes); allergen tracking is on Growth at $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
