To price a knitted piece, add the yarn, the trims and packaging, a little overhead, and your hours at a wage you'd accept. Then look at the total without flinching. In the example below, a cabled merino hat uses $23.90 of yarn and a pom-pom and takes three and a half hours. At $18 an hour it has cost $89.85. Similar hats sell for about $55. That gap is the whole problem of selling hand knitting, and no formula closes it. "Three times the yarn" would price this hat at $72 and pay you about $13 an hour before fees. Below is the honest sum, the three ways knitters make it work, and a calculator.
The short version
- Time yourself on one piece, start to finish. Most people underestimate by a third.
- Cost = yarn + trims + packaging + overhead + hours × your wage.
- Multiples of the yarn cost ignore the hours, and hours are most of it.
- If the market won't pay your cost, change the piece, not the wage.
- Fees are a cost: about a tenth of an online sale.
- TaroStack tracks yarn by dye lot and what each piece's materials cost. More below.
What a hat costs
A made-up knitter's cabled merino hat with a faux fur pom-pom.
| What goes in | Amount | You pay | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Worsted merino yarn | 85 g | $24.00 for a 100 g skein | $20.40 |
| Faux fur pom-pom | 1 | $3.50 | $3.50 |
| Materials | $23.90 |
| For one hat | |
|---|---|
| Materials | $23.90 |
| Time: 3.5 hours at $18 | $63.00 |
| Overhead: needles, patterns, listing | $2.00 |
| Woven label, hang tag, bag | $0.95 |
| Full cost | $89.85 |
Time is 70% of it. The yarn everyone agonizes over is a quarter.
What three prices leave
| Where it sells | Price | Fees | Left | What you earned an hour |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Online | $95.00 | 9.5% | -$3.88 | about $16.90 |
| Craft fair | $85.00 | 3% | -$7.40 | about $15.90 |
| What similar hats sell for | $55.00 | 3% | -$36.50 | about $7.60 |
"Left" is after paying yourself $18 an hour. The last column turns it round: what the sale paid you for your time once materials, packaging and fees were covered. At $55, this hat pays $7.60 an hour.
That isn't an argument against selling. It's the number to know before you agree to twenty of them for a shop.
Three ways it works
1. Knit something faster. The same knitter's chunky ribbed hat: $14 of yarn, one hour.
| Cabled merino | Chunky ribbed | |
|---|---|---|
| Materials and packaging | $24.85 | $14.95 |
| Hours | 3.5 | 1 |
| Full cost at $18 an hour | $89.85 | $34.95 |
| A price the market pays | $55 | $48 |
| Earned an hour | $7.60 | about $29.60 |
Thick yarn, simple stitches and small pieces are what sell at a profit. Cables and fine-gauge sweaters are for commissions and for love.
2. Sell the piece as what it is. A hand-knit merino hat at $95 isn't overpriced. It needs a buyer who knows that, which means good photographs, the fiber and the hours named in the listing, and a market or shop where $95 hats are sold. It won't sell beside $25 acrylic ones.
3. Sell the design. A pattern takes far longer to write than the hat takes to knit, and then sells again and again for no further work. Many knitters who earn a living do it this way and knit samples.
Commissions
For made-to-order work, quote from the sum: materials at cost, plus your hours, with the estimate written down and half paid up front. If the buyer balks, offer a simpler piece at a lower price before you offer a lower wage. And buy all the yarn for a piece at once, from one dye lot: the same colorway from two lots can differ enough to show as a stripe.
Crocheted pieces follow the same arithmetic, in how to price crochet items, and the general method for anything handmade is in how to price handmade items.
Get the calculator
Download the knitting price calculator. Two sheets and a read-me: the cost of one piece, to type your own yarn, minutes and wage over, and the prices with what each leaves. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers. Stash by fiber and dye lot is in yarn inventory spreadsheet.
Where this stops working
Once there are thirty pieces in stock, made from skeins bought over two years at different prices, nobody knows what any one of them cost in yarn. The calculator has today's skein price. The hat on the table was made from a skein bought on sale, or from the dear one, and the margin is a guess either way.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the materials side exact, so the only estimate left is your time.
Yarn by dye lot. Each purchase is a lot with its colorway, dye lot, weight and what you paid. Units convert: bought by the skein, used by the gram.
Each design is a recipe. 85 g of worsted, a pom-pom, a label, a tag. Record the pieces you made and the yarn comes off the lot you used.
Cost follows what you paid. A hat from a sale skein costs less than one from a full-price skein, and each piece's record says which.
"What could I make right now" says how many of a design the yarn on hand allows, in one dye lot.
A reorder list for labels, tags and the yarns you always keep.
| The job | Calculator | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Yarn cost of this hat | Today's skein price | The lot it was knit from |
| Enough of one dye lot for six? | Dig through the stash | What could I make right now |
| Which dye lot is in this piece | Unknown | On its record |
| Labels running low | Notice | The reorder list |
TaroStack costs materials and packaging, not your time. For knitting that's the smaller part, so keep the hours sum yourself. Stock, lots and recipes are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
