Dinner rolls are the cheapest thing a baker makes and among the slowest. A dozen butter rolls has $1.72 of ingredients in it. It also has forty-eight pieces of dough to weigh and shape for every batch of four dozen, and with mixing, panning, brushing and packing that's eighty minutes of hands-on work: $6.67 a dozen at $20 an hour. With the pan and a share of the oven, a dozen costs $9.73. At $8 a dozen, the price people expect because supermarket rolls are $4, you lose $1.73 on every order, which is to say you pay to bake them. In the example below, $14 for a holiday pre-order leaves $3.85 a dozen and $12 at a market leaves $1.91. Below are the sums, the batch size that fixes them, and a calculator.
The short version
- A dozen costs about $9.73. Ingredients are $1.72 of that.
- Shaping is the cost. Weigh the pieces and work in rows.
- Double the batch: time a dozen falls by a third.
- Holiday orders are pre-paid and pre-counted. Price them properly.
- Sell in the pan they baked in.
- TaroStack keeps the cost current as butter moves. More below.
What a dozen costs
A made-up home baker. One dough, four dozen rolls.
| What goes in | Amount | You pay | Cost in the batch |
|---|---|---|---|
| All-purpose flour | 4 lb | $24.00 for 50 lb | $1.92 |
| Milk | 32 fl oz | $4.10 for 128 fl oz | $1.03 |
| Butter | 8 oz | $4.80 for 16 oz | $2.40 |
| Sugar | 6 oz | $8.50 for 160 oz | $0.32 |
| Eggs | 2 each | $4.20 for 12 each | $0.70 |
| Instant yeast | 1 oz | $6.50 for 16 oz | $0.41 |
| Salt | $0.10 | ||
| Ingredients, the batch | $6.87 |
| For one dozen | |
|---|---|
| Ingredients | $1.72 |
| Time: 80 minutes a batch at $20 an hour | $6.67 |
| Oven and kitchen: $3.00 a batch | $0.75 |
| Foil pan with lid, or bag, label | $0.60 |
| Full cost | $9.73 |
Without your time a dozen costs $3.07. That's the figure that makes $8 look fine, and it's the figure you'd use if you were paying someone else nothing either.
The batch that fixes it
Shaping forty-eight rolls takes about twenty-five minutes. Ninety-six takes forty-five. Mixing, washing up and the oven hardly change.
| Batch | Hands-on time | Time a dozen | Full cost a dozen | Left at $14 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 dozen | 80 minutes | $6.67 | $9.73 | $3.85 |
| 8 dozen | 110 minutes | $4.58 | $7.28 | $6.30 |
| 12 dozen | 145 minutes | $4.03 | $6.60 | $6.98 |
Eight dozen needs a mixer that holds the dough and an oven that takes four pans, or two bakes. Most home ovens manage it with the second set of pans proofing while the first bakes.
Bake in what you sell in. Rolls proofed and baked in a foil pan go out in that pan with a lid. No transferring, no bag, and they arrive looking like something from an oven.
Three prices
| Where it sells | Price a dozen | Fees | Left a dozen | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Holiday pre-order | $14.00 | 3% | $3.85 | 27% |
| Farmers market | $12.00 | 3% | $1.91 | 16% |
| The $8 a dozen you were about to quote | $8.00 | −$1.73 | -22% |
$14 for a holiday dozen is the right order of price for something made by hand, to order, for the most important meal of the year. Take orders with a deadline and a deposit: the form is in bakery order form template.
$12 at a market leaves $1.91 on the small batch. Rolls are a hard sell by the dozen at a stall. Half-dozens at $7 move faster.
$8 a dozen loses $1.73. If twelve orders are already promised at that price, honor them, bake them as one batch of twelve dozen, and reprice for Christmas.
Before you sell
Plain yeast rolls are covered by most cottage food laws: see can you sell bread from home. The label lists wheat, milk and egg. Par-baked or frozen rolls may fall outside the rules in your state, so ask before offering take-and-bake.
Plan the bake day backwards from pickup time: a sheet for that is in bread production sheet. Related sums: how to price bread and how to price homemade cinnamon rolls.
Get the calculator
Download the dinner roll price calculator. Two sheets and a read-me: the batch cost, to type your own recipe and prices over, and the prices with what each leaves. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
You quote in early November from last year's calculator. The butter you buy the week of Thanksgiving is the dearest of the year, and the foil pans doubled. With thirty dozen promised, the difference is real money, and the first you see of it is the receipt.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the cost of a dozen current without anyone opening a spreadsheet.
The recipe is by weight. Flour, milk, butter, sugar, eggs, yeast, a bag and a label. Units convert, so what you buy by the sack and use by the gram is one item.
Cost follows what you paid. Each batch is costed from the deliveries it used. When a price goes up, the next batch costs more, and you see it.
"What could I make right now" says how many batches the ingredients and packaging on hand allow before a big order.
Allergens on Growth. With allergen tracking on, a batch can't start if its label leaves out an allergen its ingredients contain: wheat, milk and egg here.
Lots and dates. Each batch gets a lot code and a best-by, and lot labels print with both.
| The job | Calculator | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Cost a dozen today | Retype the prices | From what you paid |
| Enough on hand for the order? | Check the cupboard | What could I make right now |
| Orders against what's on hand | Count the flour | What could I make right now |
| Which batch is this dozen? | Unknown | Its lot code |
TaroStack costs ingredients and packaging. Your time is yours to add, as above. Recipes, batches and true cost are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes); allergen tracking is on Growth at $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
