Vinegar is one of the safest foods a small maker can bottle, because the thing that makes it vinegar is also what preserves it. That's the reason a vinegar plan is short, and the reason its main number matters: acidity. FDA's policy is that vinegar contains at least 4 grams of acetic acid per 100 mL. A cook who pickles with your vinegar is counting on the strength your label gives. After acidity, the real hazards are what's added to the bottle, such as garlic, herbs or fruit, and glass. Under FDA's preventive controls rule the document is called a food safety plan. Below is a plan for a made-up small vinegar maker, one day's log, and a worksheet.
The short version
- Measure acidity in every tank before bottling: at least 4 grams of acetic acid per 100 mL.
- If you dilute, measure again. Never below 4 percent, and the label says the percent.
- Garlic, herbs and fruit are low-acid foods. Keep them covered and measure the finished pH.
- Filter. FDA treats vinegar eels in a finished bottle as adulteration.
- Glass gets a breakage procedure at the filler.
- Lot code on every bottle, with the tank it came from.
- TaroStack records each tank, each bottling and where it went. More below.
What FDA says about strength
There's no standard of identity for vinegar in federal regulations. What FDA has is a policy for labeling, in its Compliance Policy Guide:
| Point | What the guide says |
|---|---|
| Natural strength | Vinegars as they come from the generators normally contain more than 4 grams of acetic acid per 100 mL |
| Each variety | Cider, wine, malt, sugar, glucose and spirit vinegar should each contain 4 grams per 100 mL |
| Diluted vinegar | The label must say "diluted with water to ___ percent acid strength", and never less than 4 percent |
| Names | Cider vinegar is made from apple juice. Vinegar from dried apples, cores or peels is labeled as made from those |
Four grams per 100 mL is the same as 4 percent acidity. It's a labeling policy, not a safety limit. A customer who pickles will ask what strength yours is, so measure it and print it.
The hazards, step by step
| Step | Hazard | Control |
|---|---|---|
| Cider, wine, fruit, herbs coming in | Residues, stems, stones | Supplier specification; fruit washed |
| Fermentation | None of concern once acid forms | Acidity measured as it rises |
| Before bottling | Vinegar too weak | At least 4 g per 100 mL, by titration |
| Diluting | Diluted too far; not labeled | Measured after; label states the percent |
| Infusing | Low-acid pieces in the bottle | Covered; finished pH against the maker's limit |
| Filtering | Sediment; vinegar eels | Filter checked; bottles looked at against a light |
| Bottling | Glass | Bottles rinsed; breakage procedure |
| Labeling | Sulfites not declared; no lot code | Label against the recipe |
Measuring acidity
Acidity is measured by titration: a measured sample, an indicator, and a standard base added until the color turns. Kits for wine and vinegar makers do this at a bench. A pH meter doesn't replace it. pH tells you how acidic the liquid behaves, and titration tells you how much acid is in it, which is the number FDA's policy and your label use.
Infusions
A sprig of rosemary or a clove of garlic is a low-acid food sitting in an acid one. This maker keeps every piece fully under the vinegar, measures the pH of each infused batch once it has settled, and holds any batch above its own limit. That limit is this maker's, set with outside advice. What makes a food acid or acidified is in acid food vs acidified food.
Eels, sediment and glass
Vinegar eels are tiny worms that can live in vinegar. FDA's guide says finding them in a maker's bulk tanks isn't a problem by itself, and that finished vinegar in a consumer bottle containing any is adulterated. Filtering is the control, and a look at filled bottles against a light is the check.
Glass is the one hazard here that can injure someone. After any break at the filler: stop, discard the open bottles near it, clean, and sign the restart.
One day's log
| Time | What | Reading | Limit | OK? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8:00 | Apple cider vinegar, tank 2 | 5.2 g/100 mL | 4.0 or more | Yes |
| 9:30 | Red wine vinegar, tank 4 | 6.1 g/100 mL | 4.0 or more | Yes |
| 11:15 | Cider vinegar, diluted, lot 1120 | 3.7 g/100 mL | 4.0 or more | NO: act |
| 2:00 | Raspberry vinegar, lot 1120R | 4.6 g/100 mL | 4.0 or more | Yes |
At 11:15 the diluted lot was under strength: too much water. It was blended back with undiluted vinegar from tank 2 and read 4.3 at 11:50. Its label says "diluted with water to 4.3 percent acid strength".
This is general information, not legal advice. Wine vinegars can carry sulfites: see sulfites labeling. Writing a plan from the start is in how to write a HACCP plan, and the business side in vinegar business plan.
Get the worksheet
Download the vinegar food safety plan worksheet. Three sheets and a read-me: the hazard analysis from fruit to label, the plan with its acidity, infusion and glass controls, and a monitoring log that marks a reading under 4.0. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
Three months on, a shop asks about a bottle from lot 1120. Which tank was it, was that the diluted one, what did it measure, and which other shops have it? The titration was written in a notebook by the tanks. The bottling day and the deliveries are somewhere else.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the tank, the bottling and the deliveries in one record.
A bottling run is a batch. It takes vinegar from a tank's lot and bottles, caps and labels from stock, and notes which lots it used, automatically.
Your checks are fields on the batch record: acidity, pH for an infusion, dilution percent, bottles looked at.
Every run is a lot. Lot labels print with the code.
What ships is recorded by lot, so one report shows which shops got lot 1120 and what's left. Starting a recall holds it.
| The shop's question | Notebook | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Which tank was lot 1120 | Remember | The lots the run used |
| What it measured | Find the page | A field on the batch |
| Who else has it | Read the invoices | One report |
| What's left here | Count | Stock by lot |
TaroStack doesn't titrate, and it doesn't write your plan. Recipes, batches, lots and recalls are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
