A plan for farmed tilapia starts with a hazard that comes from outside the plant. What happened on the farm arrives with the fish. FDA calls animal drug residues "a primary food safety hazard of concern in aquaculture products", and the seafood HACCP rule lists drug residues among the hazards every processor has to consider. A processor can't see, smell or cook out a residue, so the control is at the back door: what does the farm's paperwork say, and is it here before the fish is unloaded? The plan below, for a made-up plant that fillets tilapia, has three critical points: receiving, metal detection and the label. Its limits are invented for the example. Which hazards are reasonably likely for your fish is your own analysis to make. Below are the rule as read today, the example plan, and a worksheet.
The short version
- Every seafood processor does a hazard analysis for each kind of fish it handles.
- A written plan is required when the analysis finds a hazard reasonably likely to occur.
- For farmed fish, consider drug residues: FDA names them a primary hazard of concern.
- This plant's control is a certificate from the farm with every lot, read before unloading.
- The plan lists hazards, critical control points, limits, monitoring, corrective actions, verification, records.
- It's signed and dated when accepted, when changed, and when verified.
- TaroStack keeps each lot with its farm and the paperwork it came with. More below.
What the rule asks for
From the seafood HACCP rule, 21 CFR 123.6.
| What it says | |
|---|---|
| Hazard analysis | Every processor conducts one, or has one conducted, for each kind of fish and fishery product, to determine whether food safety hazards are reasonably likely to occur. Hazards can be introduced "before, during, and after harvest" |
| When a plan is needed | Whenever the analysis reveals one or more hazards reasonably likely to occur. Specific to each location and each kind of fish |
| Hazards to consider | Natural toxins; microbiological contamination; chemical contamination; pesticides; drug residues; decomposition in certain species; parasites, where the fish will be eaten without a process that kills them; unapproved additives; physical hazards |
| What the plan lists | The hazards; the critical control points; the critical limits; monitoring procedures and their frequency; corrective action plans; verification procedures; a recordkeeping system with the actual values observed |
| Signing | By the most responsible person on site or a higher official: on acceptance, on any change, and on verification |
"Reasonably likely to occur" has a definition in the rule: a hazard for which a prudent processor would set controls, because experience, illness data, scientific reports or other information give a basis to conclude there's a reasonable possibility it will occur in that kind of fish without them.
On farmed fish, FDA's own page says this: only drugs approved by FDA may be given to aquatic animals in the United States, withdrawal periods and testing are enforced, and aquacultured fish, domestic and imported, is held to the same standards as wild-caught. For a processor that means the question at receiving is about the farm: what was used, and was the withdrawal time kept?
FDA publishes a long guidance document, the Fish and Fishery Products Hazards and Controls Guidance, that goes through hazards species by species and control by control. It's where a processor's hazard analysis starts, and it's the document to have open while reading the example below.
The example plan
A made-up plant that buys iced tilapia from two farms and sells fresh fillets. Everything in this table is the example's own.
| CCP | Hazard | Limit | Checked | If it's missed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Receiving | Unapproved drugs, or residues above tolerance | Each lot arrives with the farm's certificate that drugs were used only as approved and withdrawal times were kept | The certificate is read against the lot before unloading, every lot | No certificate: the lot is held or refused. Nothing is processed until it arrives |
| 2 Metal detection | Metal from knives and the skinner | No detectable metal; the detector is on and finds its test pieces | Test pieces at the start, every 2 hours and the end of the shift | Detector fails: stop. Everything packed since the last good test is run again |
| 3 Labeling | Undeclared fish allergen | Every pack carries the tilapia label, with fish declared | First and last pack of each run | Run held and relabeled |
Why receiving is a critical point. Nothing later in the plant affects a drug residue. If the control isn't at receiving, it isn't anywhere. A certificate is one way to do it. This plant backs it up by visiting each farm once a year and sending a sample to a lab each quarter, which is its verification.
What isn't a critical point here, and why. Bacteria on raw fish: these fillets are sold raw to be cooked, and the plant keeps them iced under its sanitation and temperature checks. Bones: a quality matter for this plant, with a statement on the pack. Each of those is a judgment written into this plant's hazard analysis, with its reason. Yours may come out differently: a plant that sells tilapia for raw dishes, smokes it, or vacuum packs it has other hazards to work through. See smoked fish HACCP plan and reduced oxygen packaging HACCP.
A week of records
| When | Lot | Check | Result | OK? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 16, 6:40 AM | T-1116, Farm A, 1,200 lb | Certificate with the lot | On file | Yes |
| Nov 16, 7:00 AM | T-1116 | Metal detector test pieces | 3 of 3 found | Yes |
| Nov 16, 9:00 AM | T-1116 | Metal detector test pieces | 3 of 3 found | Yes |
| Nov 18, 6:35 AM | T-1118, Farm B, 900 lb | Certificate with the lot | Missing | NO: act |
| Nov 18, 11:00 AM | T-1118 | Metal detector test pieces | 2 of 3 found | NO: act |
On the 18th the truck from Farm B arrived without its certificate. The lot stayed on ice, unprocessed. The farm emailed the certificate at 8:10, it was read and filed, and the lot was released at 8:20. Later that morning the detector missed its stainless test piece. The line stopped, the detector was reset and passed three of three at 11:15, and the 240 lb packed since the 9:00 test went through again. None was rejected.
Both went in the corrective action records, which is what the rule's "actual values and observations" means in practice: not a tick, the thing that happened.
The general seafood plan, built around a different fish and a different hazard, is in seafood HACCP plan. The steps of writing any plan are in how to write a HACCP plan. This is general information, not legal advice.
Get the worksheet
Download the tilapia HACCP plan worksheet. Three sheets and a read-me: a hazard analysis from receiving to shipping, the plan with its three control points, and a monitoring log that checks each entry against its limit. Replace the example's hazards and limits with your own. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The receiving log says lot T-1118 came from Farm B with a certificate. Three weeks later a lab result comes back on Farm B's quarterly sample, and the question is which lots from that farm were processed since the last clean result, and who bought them. That's a search through receiving logs, production sheets and invoices, by date, by hand.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the farm, the lot and the customer in one chain.
Receiving records the supplier and the lot, and your own fields on the receipt can hold "certificate on file" with initials.
Filleting is a batch that notes which lots went in, automatically, and the lot it makes carries your code.
Holds: a lot waiting for paperwork goes on hold and is out of what can be used or sold until you release it.
Sales orders record what shipped, by lot.
One report from a farm's lot forward: which batches used it and which customers got them.
| The question | Paper | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Which lots came from Farm B this quarter | Read the receiving log | Lots, by supplier |
| Was the certificate there | A tick, if made | A field on the receipt |
| What was made from lot T-1118 | Production sheets | The batches that used it |
| Who bought it | Invoices | One report |
TaroStack doesn't write your plan or judge which hazards are likely. Lots, holds and recalls are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
