A carbonated soft drink is acidic, sweet and sealed, which makes it one of the safer things to bottle, and its plan is short. Four things can still hurt someone. The water, which is most of the bottle. The syrup, where an ingredient weighed wrong changes the acidity or the preservative. Glass, when a bottle breaks at the filler. And one hazard that's designed in or out at the recipe: benzene, which can form when a drink contains both a benzoate preservative and vitamin C. Under FDA's preventive controls rule the document is a food safety plan, with process, sanitation and supply-chain controls. A drink with juice in it may fall under a different rule. Below is a plan for a made-up craft soda bottler, a morning's log, and a worksheet.
The short version
- Know your water: the supplier's report, your filters, a change schedule.
- Weigh syrup ingredients with a second person checking. Measure pH and Brix every batch.
- A broken bottle at the filler stops the line. Bottles around it are thrown away.
- No recipe has a benzoate and ascorbic acid together.
- Store out of heat and light. Code every bottle.
- Juice in the drink: read the juice HACCP rule.
- TaroStack records which ingredient lots went into each syrup batch. More below.
The hazards, step by step
| Step | Hazard | Control |
|---|---|---|
| Water | Contaminants in the supply | Municipal report; carbon filter and UV, maintained |
| Receiving ingredients | Wrong or mislabeled ingredient | Specification and certificate for each lot |
| Formulating | Benzene from a benzoate with ascorbic acid | No recipe uses both |
| Syrup making | Yeasts and molds; too much preservative | Weights checked; pH and Brix measured |
| Carbonating | Contaminants in the gas | Beverage-grade carbon dioxide with a certificate |
| Filling and capping | Glass from a break; a loose cap | Breakage procedure; cap checks |
| Storage | Benzene forming; no lot to trace | Cool and dark; a lot code on every bottle |
Benzene
FDA's questions and answers on benzene explain it. Benzene can form, at parts-per-billion levels, in beverages that contain both benzoate salts (sodium or potassium benzoate, used as preservatives) and ascorbic acid (vitamin C) or erythorbic acid. Heat and light speed it up. In FDA's survey of almost 200 drinks, nearly all had none or less than 5 parts per billion, the limit EPA sets for drinking water. Ten were above it, and their makers reformulated.
For a small bottler this is a recipe rule, checked once for each formula: a benzoate and ascorbic acid never appear in the same drink. Watch for the hidden versions. Vitamin C added "for freshness" is ascorbic acid. Cranberry carries benzoates of its own: one of the ten drinks in FDA's survey was a cranberry beverage with added vitamin C and no added benzoate. Then store finished cases away from heat and sun, which is good for the flavor too.
Syrup
The syrup is where a soda is made, and where a mistake is made. This bottler's rule: every syrup batch is weighed from a batch sheet, a second person initials the acid and preservative weights, and the finished syrup is measured for pH and Brix against the recipe's range. The pH limit below is this bottler's own, from its recipes. An acid weighed short is the commonest fault, and a pH meter finds it in a minute.
Glass
Glass bottles break under pressure at the filler. When one does, fragments can land in the open bottles beside it. The procedure is written before it's needed: stop the line, throw away every open bottle within the distance the procedure names, clean the filler head and the area, and have someone sign the restart. Each break goes in a log. The wider policy is in glass and brittle plastic policy.
A morning's log
| Time | What | Reading | Limit | OK? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6:30 | Cola syrup batch 114, pH | 2.9 | 3.2 or below | Yes |
| 8:15 | Ginger beer syrup batch 115, pH | 3.5 | 3.2 or below | NO: act |
| 10:00 | Lemon-lime syrup batch 116, pH | 3.0 | 3.2 or below | Yes |
Batch 115 read 3.5. The citric acid had been under-weighed: the scale was set to ounces and the sheet is in grams. The batch was held, the acid brought up to the recipe's weight, and it read 3.1 at 8:40. The fix was five minutes. Without the reading, the batch would have been bottled.
Juice
A soda made with real fruit juice may be a juice product under FDA's juice HACCP rule, which has its own requirements. Read juice HACCP plan before adding juice to a recipe. This is general information, not legal advice. Writing a plan from the start is in how to write a HACCP plan, and the business in soda business plan.
Get the worksheet
Download the soft drink food safety plan worksheet. Three sheets and a read-me: the hazard analysis from water to storage, the plan with its glass, syrup and recipe controls, and a monitoring log that marks a reading outside its limit. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
A flavor house recalls a lot of ginger extract. It went into syrup, the syrup into three bottling runs, the runs onto pallets, and the pallets to a distributor and four cafés. Each of those steps is on a different sheet of paper, and the batch sheet for syrup 115 says "ginger extract, 1.2 kg" with no lot.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack follows a lot from the extract to the café.
Receiving records each ingredient lot and the supplier's own lot number beside yours.
Syrup is a sub-recipe. Record a syrup batch and it notes which ingredient lots it used, automatically. Record a bottling run and it notes which syrup batch it used.
Your checks are fields on the batch record: pH, Brix, second-person initials.
One report for a lot: which syrup batches and bottling runs used it, which customers got those cases, and what's left. Starting a recall holds it.
Lot labels print with the code for each case and pallet.
| The recall | Batch sheets | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Which syrup used that extract | "Ginger extract, 1.2 kg" | The lots on the batch |
| Which bottling runs used that syrup | Dates, roughly | The runs that used it |
| Which customers got them | Invoices | One report |
| The syrup's pH | A clipboard | A field on the batch record |
TaroStack doesn't test water, measure pH or write your food safety plan. Recipes, batches, lots and recalls are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
