A sandwich made to order is eaten in ten minutes. A pre-made one is wrapped, chilled, perhaps driven across town, and eaten up to several days later by someone who can't ask what's in it. That changes where the risks are. The critical control points for pre-made sandwiches are cooking any filling you cook, cooling it, the label (allergens and a use-by date), cold holding at 41°F, and, if the sandwiches leave your building, delivery. Nothing is cooked after assembly, so everything that goes between the bread has to be safe already and has to stay cold. Below are the five points with their limits from the FDA Food Code, a few days of readings, and a worksheet. Selling to other businesses may also change which regulator you answer to: ask before the first delivery.
The short version
- Cook chicken to 165°F. Cool it to 70°F in 2 hours and 41°F in 6.
- Tuna or egg salad mixed from room-temperature ingredients: 41°F within 4 hours.
- The use-by is counted from the oldest filling, not the day you wrapped it. Seven days at most.
- Every sandwich labeled: what it is, allergens, use-by.
- 41°F or below in the case and at the customer's door.
- TaroStack dates each batch of filling and carries the oldest date into the sandwich. More below.
The five points
| CCP | Limit (Food Code) | Checked | If it's missed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Cooking fillings | Chicken 165°F; hard-cooked eggs 155°F for 17 seconds | Probe each batch | Keep cooking |
| 2 Cooling | Cooked: 135°F to 70°F in 2 hours, 41°F in 6 in all. Mixed from room-temperature ingredients: 41°F in 4 hours | Probe at the limits | Discard, or for cooked food at 2 hours, reheat once and cool faster |
| 3 Labeling | Each sandwich carries its own label: allergens as in the recipe; use-by no later than day 7 of its oldest filling | First and last label of each run | Rewrap; recall any that left |
| 4 Cold holding | 41°F or below | Cooler and case, twice a day | Find the time; discard if unknown |
| 5 Delivery | 41°F or below at hand-over | One sandwich from the last box, each drop | That box isn't delivered |
The date is the oldest filling's
The code's seven days start when a ready-to-eat food that needs refrigeration is made, and a food combined from others keeps the earliest date. For a sandwich that means:
| Filling | Made | Day 7 |
|---|---|---|
| Chicken, cooked | Saturday | Friday |
| Chicken salad, mixed from that chicken | Monday | Friday |
| Sandwich, assembled from that salad | Tuesday | Friday |
A sandwich wrapped on Tuesday with "use by next Monday" on it is three days over. Most makers set a much shorter life anyway, two or three days, because bread and lettuce give out long before day seven. Whatever you choose, it can't be later than the oldest thing inside.
Opened deli meat and cheese work the same way: the day the pack was opened is day 1, and never past the maker's own date.
The four-hour rule for mixed fillings
Tuna salad is canned tuna, mayonnaise and celery, mixed at room temperature. Nothing was cooked, so the two-stage cooling rule doesn't apply, and a different one does: food prepared from ingredients at ambient temperature has to be at 41°F within four hours. A deep tub of tuna salad in a busy cooler may not make it. Chill the cans and the mayonnaise before you mix, mix in batches you'll use, and pan it shallow.
Assembly
Hands. No bare hands on anything ready to eat: gloves, tongs or tissue. Change gloves between tasks, not between sandwiches.
Time out of the cooler. Bring fillings out in the amount you'll use in half an hour. A hotel pan of chicken salad on the bench all morning has left temperature control.
Produce. Wash before cutting. Cut lettuce and cut tomato are foods that need refrigeration, like the chicken.
Allergens. Wheat is in nearly all of them. The ones that differ are egg, milk, fish, sesame, tree nuts and soy. Make the sandwiches with the fewest allergens first, change gloves and board between kinds, and keep pesto, which usually has nuts, on its own tools.
The label
For a wrapped sandwich the label is the only way the buyer learns anything. It carries the name, the allergens and the use-by date at the least. What else a package sold in a shop must say (ingredients in order, weight, your business name and address) depends on where and how you sell: see food labeling requirements for small business and food allergen labeling requirements.
The mistake to design against is the right label on the wrong sandwich: egg salad wrapped as tuna. Label one kind at a time, clear the bench between kinds, and check the first and last of each run.
A few days of readings
| When | What | Reading | Limit | OK? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 16, 7:20 AM | Chicken, cooking | 168°F | 165°F or above | Yes |
| Nov 16, 9:25 AM | Chicken, cooling, 2 hours | 63°F | 70°F or below | Yes |
| Nov 16, 2:30 PM | Tuna salad mixed at 10:30, 4 hours | 40°F | 41°F or below | Yes |
| Nov 17, 6:30 AM | Display case | 39°F | 41°F or below | Yes |
| Nov 17, 8:10 AM | Drop 2, last box | 45°F | 41°F or below | NO: act |
At the second drop the last box read 45°F: the ice packs hadn't frozen through. The twelve sandwiches in it weren't delivered, and were replaced from the cooler at 9:30. Ice packs now get a full day in the freezer.
Who regulates you
A cafe making sandwiches for its own case is a retail food establishment under its health department, and doesn't usually need a HACCP plan unless it uses a special process such as vacuum packing. Making them for other businesses to resell is often treated as food manufacturing, with a different licence and different rules. That line is drawn differently from state to state. Ask your health department and your state agriculture department before you agree to supply anyone.
Your state may also use an older edition of the Food Code; FDA's adoption page showed 14 states on the 2022 edition when I read it. This is general information, not legal advice. Sister plans are in HACCP plan for ready-to-eat meals and HACCP plan for a small cafe, and the date rule in date marking in the Food Code.
Get the worksheet
Download the pre-made sandwich HACCP plan worksheet. Three sheets and a read-me: the hazard analysis from receiving to delivery, the plan with its five control points, and a monitoring log that checks each reading. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
Eight kinds of sandwich, each from four or five fillings, each filling from its own batch on its own day. The use-by on every label depends on the oldest of them. At 5 AM, with sixty sandwiches to wrap, working that out from tape on tubs is where the wrong date gets printed. And when a coffee shop phones about Tuesday's chicken pesto, nothing says which chicken that was.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack works out the date from what went in.
Each filling is a batch with a lot code and a use-by: cooked chicken, chicken salad, sliced tomato.
The sandwich is a batch too, and its record notes which lots of filling it consumed, automatically. The oldest date among them is there to see.
Lot labels print with the code and the use-by.
Allergens on Growth. With allergen tracking on, a batch can't start if its label leaves out an allergen its ingredients contain: the nuts in the pesto.
Sales orders and delivery notes record which lots went to which shop, and one report answers a recall.
An alert before a date passes, so yesterday's unsold sandwiches come out of the case.
| The job | Tape and a label gun | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| The oldest filling in this sandwich | Read every tub | On the batch record |
| Allergens on the label | From memory | Checked before the batch starts (Growth) |
| Which chicken was in Tuesday's | Unknown | On the batch record |
| Which shops got it | Route sheets | One report |
TaroStack doesn't write a HACCP plan or take a temperature. Recipes, batches, lots and recalls are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes, with allergen tracking). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
