For a bean-to-bar chocolate maker, the food safety plan turns on one fact: cocoa beans arrive raw from farms and can carry Salmonella, and roasting is the only step that kills it. Nothing after the roast gets hot enough, and Salmonella survives for a long time in finished chocolate because chocolate is dry and fatty. So the plan has three jobs. Make sure the roast works, and prove it. Keep raw beans and their dust away from everything roasted. And control allergens, since milk and nuts are in half the bars and share the molds with the rest. Under FDA's rule the document is called a food safety plan with preventive controls, not a HACCP plan, but it's built the same way. Below are the controls, an example, and a worksheet.
The short version
- The roast is the kill step. Its time and temperature need validating for your roaster and beans.
- After the roast, nothing raw crosses over: separate tools, bins, and cleaning.
- Milk powder, nuts and inclusions aren't heated by you, so their safety comes from the supplier.
- Allergens: order of production, cleaning between changes, and the right wrapper on each bar.
- A recall plan is part of the food safety plan.
- TaroStack records each roast and each bar's lots, and checks the label's allergens. More below.
The plan, by kind of control
Section 117.135 names the kinds of preventive control. A chocolate maker uses all of them.
| Control | In a chocolate plan |
|---|---|
| Process control | The roast: a minimum time and bean temperature |
| Sanitation control | Raw side and roasted side kept apart; cleaning that keeps bean dust out of finished chocolate |
| Supply-chain control | Milk powder, nuts and inclusions from approved suppliers, with a certificate for each lot |
| Food allergen control | Preventing cross-contact, and the right label on every bar |
| Recall plan | Written, with who does what |
Step by step
| Step | Hazard | Control |
|---|---|---|
| Bean receiving | Salmonella on raw beans; stones, metal, wood | Roasted here; sorted and screened |
| Roasting | Salmonella surviving | Process control: the validated roast |
| Cracking and winnowing | Raw dust reaching roasted nibs | Sanitation control: zones |
| Grinding and conching | None controlled here | Nothing raw enters after the roast |
| Adding milk powder, nuts, inclusions | Allergens; Salmonella in the ingredient | Supply-chain and allergen controls |
| Tempering and molding | Cross-contact between bars | Allergen control: order and cleaning |
| Wrapping | The wrong wrapper | Allergen control: check at each change |
The roast, and why its number isn't here
A process control needs a minimum value. For roasting, that's a time and a bean temperature that have been shown to do the job in your roaster, with your batch size and your beans. Showing it is validation, and under 21 CFR 117.160 it's done before the plan is put to use, or within 90 days of starting production, by or under a qualified person. The evidence is a study, a published reference that fits your process, or a process authority's letter.
A flavor roast isn't automatically a kill step. Light roasts are popular, and a light roast on a drum roaster may or may not deliver enough heat for long enough. That's the question validation answers.
The worksheet's example shows 250°F at the end of the roast. That figure is invented to make the log work. Don't use it.
A week of roasts
| Roast | Beans | End-of-roast bean temp | This maker's minimum | OK? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| R-311 | Lot B-207 | 262°F | 250°F | Yes |
| R-312 | Lot B-207 | 258°F | 250°F | Yes |
| R-313 | Lot B-211 | 244°F | 250°F | NO: act |
| R-314 | Lot B-211, roasted again | 261°F | 250°F | Yes |
R-313 fell short because of a burner fault. It was roasted again as R-314 and never went forward as it was. Both rows are on the log.
Allergens
Validation isn't required for allergen controls, but the controls are. In a small shop they come down to three habits.
Order. Bars without milk or nuts first, after a full clean. Milk bars next. Nut bars last.
A real clean between changes. Chocolate can't be washed out with water mid-run, so most makers flush or scrape and then accept that the next bar may contain traces, or do a full clean. Decide which, and label to match.
The wrapper check. At every change, someone compares the wrapper with the bar and signs. A dark bar in a dark-milk wrapper is an inconvenience. The reverse is a recall.
This is general information, not legal advice. Whether the full rule applies to a business of your size, and how a food safety plan differs from HACCP, are in preventive control plan vs HACCP. Recording that a control was validated is in HACCP validation template, and a written allergen program in allergen control plan template.
Get the worksheet
Download the chocolate food safety plan worksheet. Three sheets and a read-me: the hazard analysis step by step, the plan with its four controls, and a monitoring log that checks each roast against the minimum you type. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers. Stock of beans, cocoa butter and wrappers is in chocolate inventory spreadsheet.
Where this stops working
A bar is made from a melanger batch, which was made from two roasts, which came from one sack lot, plus a lot of milk powder and a lot of hazelnuts. If the hazelnut supplier recalls a lot, the bars to pull are found by walking back through four notebooks. The plan says a recall plan exists. It doesn't make the walk any shorter.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the chain from sack to bar as linked lots.
Each step is a batch. Roasting, grinding and molding are recipes. Recipes can contain other recipes, so the roasted nibs from one batch are an ingredient of the next. Record a batch and the lots it used are noted automatically.
Your readings are fields. End-of-roast temperature, roast time, the zone check and the wrapper check go on the batch-record form, with sign-off.
Allergens are checked before a batch starts. On Growth, with allergen tracking on, a batch can't start if its label leaves out an allergen its ingredients contain.
Suppliers' lots at receiving. Each delivery records the supplier, the lot and the dates, with your own receiving checks, such as "certificate received".
The recall report. From a lot of hazelnuts to every batch and bar that used it, the customers who got them, and what's still on your shelves.
| The job | Notebooks | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Which roasts are in this bar | Walk back by hand | Linked on the batch records |
| Roast readings | A log sheet | Fields on the batch |
| Allergens on the wrapper | Checked by eye | Checked before the batch starts (Growth) |
| Bars that used a recalled lot | Four notebooks | The recall report |
TaroStack doesn't write your food safety plan or validate a roast. Recipes, batches, lots and recalls are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes); allergen tracking is on Growth at $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
