Beef stew has five critical control points, and one of them causes nearly all the trouble. Cooking is easy: a stew simmers for hours, far above any minimum. Hot holding is 135°F or above. Cold holding is 41°F or below for seven days at most, and reheating is 165°F within two hours. The hard one is cooling. Stew is thick, it's made in big pots, and a big pot of thick food cools slowly from the outside in. The spores of Clostridium perfringens and Bacillus cereus survive the simmer, and as the middle of the pot drifts down through warm temperatures they wake up and multiply. The FDA Food Code's limit is 135°F to 70°F within two hours, and to 41°F within six hours in all. A full stockpot in a walk-in won't make it. Below are the five points, how to cool a stew that passes, and a worksheet.
The short version
- Simmered properly, stew is well cooked. That isn't where it goes wrong.
- Hold hot at 135°F or above. Stir before you probe.
- Cool to 70°F in 2 hours and 41°F in 6. Never in the pot it was cooked in.
- Shallow pans, an ice bath, or both.
- Keep 7 days at most at 41°F. Reheat to 165°F within 2 hours.
- TaroStack dates each batch and keeps its cooling readings. More below.
The five points
| CCP | Limit (Food Code) | Checked | If it's missed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Cooking | 145°F for 15 seconds is the minimum for pieces of beef; a simmer is far above it | Probe the center after stirring | Keep cooking |
| 2 Hot holding | 135°F or above | Stir, probe, every 2 hours | Find the time; reheat once to 165°F or discard |
| 3 Cooling | 135°F to 70°F within 2 hours; to 41°F within 6 hours in all | Center of the deepest pan, at 2 and 6 hours | Missed 2: reheat to 165°F once and cool in shallower pans, or discard. Missed 6: discard |
| 4 Cold holding | 41°F or below; dated; 7 days at most | Cooler twice a day; dates each morning | Time unknown or past its date: discard |
| 5 Reheating | 165°F for 15 seconds, within 2 hours | Probe; note the start time | Discard |
This made-up kitchen's own cooking standard is a simmer at 185°F or above for the recipe's time. That's for tenderness. It's written on the plan beside the legal minimum so nobody confuses the two.
Why cooling is the one
Three things about stew work against you.
It's thick. Thin liquids cool by moving: warm soup rises, cool soup sinks, and the pot stirs itself. Stew doesn't. Heat has to creep out through the gravy.
It's made big. A five-gallon stockpot is about a foot across. The middle is six inches from any cold surface.
It's cooked long. That kills ordinary bacteria and leaves spore-formers with no competition.
The first stage is the urgent one. Between 135°F and 70°F growth is fastest, which is why the code gives it two hours and the whole job six.
Cooling a stew that passes
| Method | How |
|---|---|
| Shallow pans | Two inches deep at most. A 5 gallon batch is four full-size hotel pans |
| Ice bath | Stand the pot or pans in a sink of ice and water to the level of the food. Stir every few minutes |
| Ice wand | A frozen paddle stirred through the pot |
| Ice as an ingredient | Make the stew thick, with part of the liquid held back, and add that part as ice at the end |
| Blast chiller | If you have one, in shallow pans |
| Then the walk-in | Uncovered or loosely covered, on a top shelf, not stacked, until 41°F. Then cover and date |
Usually two of those together: an ice bath in the pot to get under 100°F, then shallow pans in the walk-in.
Don't put a hot stockpot straight into the walk-in. It won't cool in time, and it warms everything around it.
A day's log
| When | What | Reading | Limit | OK? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 16, 1:30 PM | Stew, 8 gal, cooking | 196°F | 185°F or above (kitchen's standard) | Yes |
| Nov 16, 4:00 PM | Stockpot in the walk-in, 2 hours | 104°F | 70°F or below | NO: act |
| Nov 16, 6:20 PM | Shallow pans, 2 hours after restart | 62°F | 70°F or below | Yes |
| Nov 16, 10:20 PM | Shallow pans, 6 hours | 39°F | 41°F or below | Yes |
| Nov 17, 11:10 AM | Reheated for the line | 174°F | 165°F or above | Yes |
At 4:00 the five gallons kept for the week had been in the walk-in, in the stockpot, for two hours and read 104°F. The corrective action allows one rescue: the stew was reheated to 165°F, split into four two-inch pans over an ice bath, and the clock restarted. It passed both stages the second time. Had it been found at six hours and not two, it would have gone in the bin.
Probe the middle. The edge of a pan reads cold long before the center does. And probe the deepest pan.
The other four, briefly
Hot holding. A steam well keeps the bottom hot and lets the top cool. Stir, then probe.
Dates. The day the stew was cooked is day 1. Stew cooked Monday is used or discarded by Sunday, and if Tuesday's leftovers are added to it, the date stays Monday's. See date marking in the Food Code.
Reheating. On the stove, to 165°F, within two hours, then into the well. Not in the well. Reheating kills bacteria that grew, and it doesn't reliably destroy toxins some of them leave behind, which is why a stew that cooled too slowly can't be rescued days later by boiling it.
Allergens. Flour in the roux, celery, sulfites in wine, Worcestershire sauce (often fish). Stew hides its ingredients: keep the chart current.
Your state may use an older edition of the Food Code; FDA's adoption page showed 14 states on the 2022 edition when I read it. This is general information, not legal advice. Your health department has the last word. More on the cooling limits in critical limits for cooling, a log in cooling log template, and the same treatment for other foods in critical limits for ground beef.
Get the worksheet
Download the beef stew critical control points worksheet. Three sheets and a read-me: the hazard analysis from receiving to service, the five control points with their limits, and a monitoring log that checks each reading. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The cooling log says a batch of stew passed on the 16th. On the 21st there are three pans of stew in the walk-in. Which are the 16th's? The log is on a clipboard by the door, the pans have tape with "stew" on it, and one says "Tue". The two-hour and six-hour readings were taken, and nothing connects them to the food on the shelf.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack puts the readings and the date on the batch itself.
Each pot is a batch, with a lot code and a use-by seven days out. A lot label prints for every pan.
The cooling readings are fields on the batch record: time and temperature at two hours and six, and who took them.
The batch notes which lots went in, automatically: the beef, the stock.
An alert before day seven, in the app and by email.
A batch that failed cooling can be put on hold, so it isn't served while someone decides.
| The job | Clipboard and tape | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Which pan is which batch | "Stew", "Tue" | The lot label |
| That batch's cooling readings | Find the sheet | On the batch record |
| Day 6 or 7 | Read the tape | An alert |
| Which beef went in | Unknown | On the batch record |
TaroStack doesn't take a temperature or cool anything. Recipes, batches, lots and expiry are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
