Skip to content

Cheese Make Sheet: pH, Times and Yield for Every Vat

A cheese make sheet for a small creamery: what to record for every vat, from milk lot and culture to pH at each step and yield, with four makes and a file.

By Koa Sterling. Product specialist at TaroStack and small business owner. Yes, I am a real human, and I actually sit in front of a computer and write these articles. Reviewed November 19, 2026 · 6 min read

A make sheet is the record of one vat of cheese. It has what went in: the milk, by weight and by pickup or tank, whether and how it was pasteurized, and the culture and rennet with their lot numbers. It has what happened: the set temperature and the pH at set, at draining and at salting. And it has what came out: the weight of cheese, the yield, and the first date it can be sold. Cheese is slow, so the sheet matters more than most batch records. The wheel you open in March was decided on a morning in November, and the sheet is all that's left of that morning. Below are the columns, four makes with one slow vat, and a file.

The short version

  • One row a vat, filled in as the make goes.
  • Milk by weight, with its pickup or tank.
  • Culture and rennet lots, every time.
  • pH at set, at drain and at salting, against the target for that cheese.
  • Weigh the cheese. Yield is the first sign of a problem with the milk.
  • TaroStack records each vat with its lots, holds it while it ages, and dates it. More below.

What to record

Column Why
Make date, batch, cheese The batch code goes on every wheel or tub
Milk (lb), milk lot Which pickup or tank. Milk changes with season and feed
Pasteurized (temperature, time) As your plan requires; from the chart, not from memory
Culture and lot, rennet and lot A tired culture is the usual cause of a slow vat
Set temperature It drives how fast acid develops
pH at set, at drain, at salting The curve of the make
Highest pH allowed at salting Your make procedure's target for that cheese
Salt, cheese out, yield Yield is cheese over milk, by weight
Earliest sale Aging, where it applies

Four makes

A made-up farmstead creamery. The pH targets are its own.

Batch Cheese Milk Culture pH at set At drain At salting Target Check Out Yield
CH-1103 Cheddar 860 lb M-212 6.60 6.15 5.40 5.45 OK 86 lb 10.0%
FC-1105 Fresh cheese 430 lb F-031 6.55 4.65 4.55 4.60 OK 75 lb 17.4%
CH-1110 Cheddar 860 lb M-212 6.62 6.30 5.62 5.45 SLOW ACID 84 lb 9.8%
FC-1112 Fresh cheese 430 lb F-031 6.56 4.62 4.52 4.60 OK 74 lb 17.2%

The slow vat

CH-1110 reached salting at pH 5.62 against a target of 5.45. The note on the sheet: culture M-212 was near its date. The same culture lot made CH-1103 a week earlier without trouble, so it was fading, and the sheet caught it on the second vat and not the fifth.

The creamery held the batch for review. A cheddar that's slow to make acid holds more moisture and ages differently, and the sheet is what lets someone decide what to do with it on purpose. It also shows what to do next: open a new culture lot.

Yield

Cheddar came out at 10.0% and 9.8% of the milk's weight, and fresh cheese at 17.4% and 17.2%. Fresh cheese keeps more of its water, so more of the milk ends up as cheese. Watch the trend within one cheese. A cheddar yield that slides from 10% to 9% over a month says something about the milk, the cut or the cook, and at 860 lb of milk a vat, one point is 8.6 lb of cheese.

Yield also costs each batch: the same milk bill divided by fewer pounds. The sum is in how to price cheese.

Dates

The last column is the first day a batch can be sold. For fresh cheese that's the next day. For aged cheese it's the make date plus the aging time. This creamery ages its cheddar 60 days by its own choice. When aging is a legal requirement and not a choice, as with raw-milk cheese, the rules and the pasteurization limits are in cheese HACCP plan. The make sheet records what was done. It doesn't set either one.

Get the sheet

Download the cheese make sheet. One row a vat; the pH check says OK or SLOW ACID against the target you type, and yield works itself out. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers. Moving from a kitchen pot to a vat is in how to make cheese in bulk, and how long each cheese keeps in cheese shelf life.

Where this stops working

There are 40 wheels in the cave from nine makes. The make sheet knows what happened in each vat. It doesn't know which wheels have been sold, which are past their earliest sale date and still sitting there, or which customers bought the cheddar from the slow vat. Those are on labels, in a sales book, and in someone's head.

How TaroStack does it

TaroStack records the vat and then keeps track of the cheese.

Each make is a batch. Record it and the milk, culture, rennet and salt come off the lots you used, noted on the batch record automatically. The cheese goes into stock under its own lot code.

Your readings are fields. Pasteurization, set temperature, the three pH readings and initials go on the batch-record form, with sign-off.

On hold while it ages, or while you decide. A lot on hold is kept out of what you can sell until you release it.

Dates on every lot. Each lot carries its dates, the soonest to expire sells first, and an alert flags lots close to their date.

Recipe truth. From your own batches, TaroStack shows whether a cheese really yields what its recipe claims.

The job Make sheet In TaroStack
Culture and rennet lots Written each time Noted on the batch automatically
pH readings Columns Fields on the batch record
Still aging, or under review A tag on the shelf On hold
Yield, vat after vat Work it out and compare Recipe truth

TaroStack doesn't set a pH target or a pasteurization time. Recipes, batches and lots are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.

Questions people also ask

What is a make sheet in cheesemaking?

The record of one vat: the milk, the culture and rennet, temperatures, times, pH at each step, and the cheese that came out.

What pH readings should a cheesemaker record?

At least at set, at draining and at salting or hooping. Each cheese has its own targets, from your make procedure.

How do you calculate cheese yield?

The weight of cheese divided by the weight of milk. 86 lb of cheddar from 860 lb of milk is 10%.

We use AI to help with the research for these articles. Every one is read, checked against its sources and edited by Koa before it's published. Spot a mistake? Tell us and we'll fix it and say so. How we write these.

Let’s get your stack in order.

Get TaroStack

Sign up now for your free 14 day trial. No credit card required.