There are two ways a small maker gets a bar of soap to sell. Cold process starts from scratch: oils and lye are combined, and the reaction between them makes the soap. FDA describes ordinary soap exactly so, as fats or oils combined with an alkali such as lye. Melt and pour starts from a base someone else has already made: you melt it, add scent and color, and pour it into molds. For a business the two differ in three things that matter more than the chemistry. What a bar costs: in the example below, $2.92 against $3.45. How long before it can be sold: five weeks against a day. And what you can say you made. Below are both costed for a made-up soap maker, what the waiting does to stock, what each means for the label, and a calculator. Every figure is this maker's own.
The short version
- Cold process makes soap from oils and lye. Melt and pour starts from a made base.
- Here a cold process bar costs $2.92 and a melt and pour bar $3.45.
- The base costs more than the oils. Cold process takes more time.
- This maker's cold process bars cure five weeks before sale. Melt and pour bars are wrapped the next day.
- Lye needs care, space and a written routine. A base doesn't.
- Either way, the label follows what the bar is and what you claim for it.
- TaroStack keeps each batch's recipe, lots and cure date. More below.
What a bar costs
Twenty 4.5 oz bars each way, sold at $7.00.
| Melt and pour | Cold process | |
|---|---|---|
| Base, or oils | $38.00 | $16.60 |
| Lye | $0.00 | $1.80 |
| Fragrance and color | $6.00 | $6.00 |
| Wrap and label, a bar | $0.35 | $0.35 |
| Minutes of work | 60 | 90 |
| Materials, a bar | $2.55 | $1.57 |
| Labor, a bar, at $18.00 an hour | $0.90 | $1.35 |
| Cost of a bar | $3.45 | $2.92 |
| Left at $7.00 | $3.55 | $4.08 |
| Margin | 51% | 58% |
| Days before it can be sold | 1 | 35 |
Materials. The base is the price of someone else having made the soap. Here it's $38.00 for twenty bars' worth, against $18.40 of oils and lye.
Time. Cold process takes this maker half as long again: weighing oils and lye, mixing, pouring, cutting the next day, and turning bars as they cure. That closes some of the gap. It doesn't close all of it: 53 cents a bar is left in cold process's favor.
Fifty-three cents on 2,000 bars a year is $1,060. Whether that's worth it depends on the next section.
The five weeks
A cold process bar isn't ready when it's cut. This maker cures bars for five weeks, on racks, before wrapping. In that time they lose water, harden and get lighter, which is why a bar is weighed for its label after curing, not before.
For a business the cure is stock you've paid for and can't sell yet.
| Melt and pour | Cold process | |
|---|---|---|
| To have 200 bars for a fair on June 20, make them by | June 18 | May 16 |
| Bars curing at any time, selling 40 a week | 0 | 200 |
| Materials tied up in curing bars | $0.00 | $244.00 |
The fair in three weeks can be supplied by melt and pour and can't by cold process. That's the case for keeping both methods: cold process for the steady range, planned five weeks out, and melt and pour for a rush, a custom order or a seasonal shape.
The $244.00 is 200 bars at $1.22 of oils, lye and fragrance each. It isn't lost, only waiting, and it needs racks and a room.
Safety and space
Lye is caustic. Cold process needs gloves, goggles, a scale that's accurate, a space where children and pets aren't, and a routine written down and followed every time. Melt and pour needs a pot and a thermometer. A maker working at a kitchen table between other uses of the kitchen should weigh that before the 53 cents.
What it means for the label
FDA's definition of soap turns on what the bar is made of and how it's sold. To be regulated as soap, the bar is mainly the alkali salts of fatty acids, those are what clean, and it's labeled and sold only as soap. A cold process bar of oils and lye fits the first two. A melt and pour base may or may not: FDA says a product that contains synthetic detergents is a cosmetic, not a soap, so read your base's ingredient list. And either bar becomes a cosmetic if you sell it as moisturizing. What each label then carries is in how to label soap for sale and FDA soap regulations. This is general information, not legal advice.
One more difference a customer may ask about: with cold process you chose every oil. With melt and pour the base's maker did, and your label lists what's in their base.
Costing a recipe of your own is in soap making cost calculator, and pricing in how to price soap.
Get the calculator
Download the soap method cost comparison. One sheet and a read-me: a row for each method with what a batch uses, the minutes it takes and your rate, and the cost of a bar, what a price leaves and the margin worked out. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
Five weeks of cure across twelve scents means sixty batches on racks at any time, each with a date it's ready. Which lavender is sellable this week? Is there enough oatmeal curing for the fair? Which batch was the one made with the new supplier's olive oil? A calculator compares two methods. It doesn't know what's on the racks.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps each batch from the pot to the sale.
Recipes by weight, with versions, for a cold process bar and a melt and pour one alike.
Each batch notes the lots it used, automatically, and its cost comes from what you paid for them.
Your checks are fields on the batch record: the day it's ready, the cured bar's weight.
Every batch is a lot with a date, so bars still curing and bars ready to sell are told apart.
"What could I make right now" says how many batches the oils on hand will make.
| The question | Racks and memory | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Which batches are ready to sell | Read the cards on the racks | Lots, by date |
| What a bar of this batch cost | An estimate | From the lots used |
| Which batch used the new olive oil | Unknown | The lots on the batch |
| Enough oils for ten batches | Weigh the buckets | What could I make right now |
TaroStack doesn't formulate a recipe or check it for lye. Recipes, batches and lots are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
