Finding a manufacturer is two jobs, and the second is the one that goes wrong. The first is getting a list: companies that already make something close to your product. The second is choosing from it, and that comes down to a few numbers every manufacturer will give you if you ask the same way: the minimum order, the unit price at that minimum, any setup or tooling fee, the freight, the lead time, and the payment terms. Put together they tell you two things a unit price hides: what a unit really costs landed at your door, and how much cash the first order ties up. Below are seven steps from a product idea to a first order, with a made-up lip balm brand comparing three quotes, and a sheet that does the comparison.
The short version
- Look for makers who already produce your kind of product.
- Write a one-page brief before you contact anyone.
- Have a confidentiality agreement signed before you send a formula or a design.
- Ask every maker the same questions, so the answers line up.
- Compare the landed cost of a unit and the cash for the first order.
- Pay for samples. Judge the sample, not the brochure.
- TaroStack tracks what you've ordered, what arrived and what it cost. More below.
Step 1: decide what you're asking for
Manufacturers offer different deals under the same word.
| Arrangement | Who designs it | Who buys the materials |
|---|---|---|
| Private label | The maker: you choose from its range and add your brand | The maker |
| Contract manufacturing | You: your formula or design | The maker, usually |
| Toll manufacturing | You | You supply them, the maker charges for the work |
Private label is the fastest start and the least your own. The three are compared, with examples, in contract manufacturing examples.
Step 2: write a one-page brief
Before the first email, write down:
- What the product is, with a photo, a sketch or a sample of something close.
- The materials or formula, as far as you'll share before an agreement is signed.
- The packaging: container, closure, label, case count.
- How many you want in the first order, and in a year.
- The price you need to pay for a unit, and when you need it.
- Any certification the maker must hold.
A brief that answers a maker's first questions gets a real reply. For a food product, the same list is in how to get a recipe manufactured.
Step 3: build the list
- Makers of products like yours. A product's label or case sometimes names who made or packed it.
- Trade shows for your industry, where makers take stands to find brands like you.
- Industry directories and associations.
- Other brands. A founder who isn't a competitor may tell you who makes for them.
- Your suppliers. The company that sells you tins or fabric knows who buys them by the pallet.
For food and drink, see how to find a co-packer. For skincare and cosmetics, cosmetic co-packer.
Step 4: protect the idea, then ask the same questions
Have a confidentiality agreement signed before a formula or a technical drawing changes hands: see recipe NDA template. Then ask each maker:
- Do you make this kind of product now? For whom, if you can say?
- What's your minimum order?
- What's the unit price at that minimum, and at two larger quantities?
- Is there a setup, tooling or development fee?
- Who buys the materials and packaging?
- What will freight cost to my door, and duty if it's imported?
- How long from order to delivery?
- What do samples cost, and how long do they take?
- What are the payment terms?
- Who owns the formula, mold or pattern afterward?
Step 5: compare on landed cost
Three made-up quotes for a lip balm.
| Maker A, in state | Maker B, domestic | Maker C, overseas | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum order | 1,000 | 5,000 | 10,000 |
| Unit price at minimum | $1.40 | $0.95 | $0.60 |
| Setup fee | $250.00 | $400.00 | $0.00 |
| Freight and duty | $60.00 | $280.00 | $1,900.00 |
| First order, total | $1,710.00 | $5,430.00 | $7,900.00 |
| Cost a unit, landed | $1.71 | $1.09 | $0.79 |
| Lead time | 4 weeks | 6 weeks | 12 weeks |
Maker C's $0.60 becomes $0.79 landed, still the lowest. It also asks for $7,900.00 before a single balm is sold, and ten thousand of them. If this brand sells 300 a month, that's nearly three years of stock, paid for now, whatever the balm's shelf life turns out to be. Maker A costs more than twice as much a unit and lets the brand find out whether the product sells for $1,710.00.
So the cheapest unit can be the most expensive decision. The sums behind this are in landed cost formula and minimum order quantity.
Step 6: samples, then a small first order
Pay for a sample from the two best. Check it against your brief, use it, and show it to people who'd buy it. Then place the smallest order the maker allows, even at a worse unit price. A first run finds problems a sample doesn't: the label that's off-center, the fill that's short, the cartons that crush.
Step 7: put it in writing
Before the deposit: who owns the formula or tooling, what happens to a run that's out of specification, how price changes are notified, and how either side ends it. A starting point is in co-packing agreement template.
Get the comparison sheet
Download the manufacturer comparison sheet. One sheet and a read-me: a row for each manufacturer, with the first order's total and the landed cost of a unit worked out from the quote. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The comparison ends when you choose. Then there's a purchase order for 1,000 units due in four weeks, a deposit paid, and labels you ordered separately that have to reach the maker first. The run arrives 40 short. The second order's price is 6% higher. Which of this is written down anywhere but your inbox?
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps what you ordered beside what arrived.
Purchase orders to each supplier, and receiving against them: what came, how many, at what cost, freight included.
Each supplier carries its lead time and minimum order, and the reorder list uses them.
A price-creep report by supplier shows whose prices have moved.
Each delivery is a lot, with its date, so a problem with one run can be traced to who received it.
If you supply the materials, the maker's premises can be one of your sites, on Business, and what you send there stays your stock.
| The question | Inbox and a spreadsheet | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| What did I order, and what arrived | Compare emails | The order and its receipts |
| What does a unit cost me now | The first quote | From what was received |
| When do I reorder | When it looks low | Days of cover, with the maker's lead time |
| Who got units from that run | Unknown | The recall report |
TaroStack doesn't find a manufacturer or negotiate for you. Purchasing, receiving, costs and the reorder list are on every plan, from $9.99 a month. More than one site is on Business at $89 a month. The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
