Contract manufacturing means one company makes a product for another, which sells it under its own name. That covers very different deals, and the differences come down to three questions. Whose recipe is it? Who buys the materials? And so who owns the stock while it's being made? A co-packer that buys everything and invoices for finished bottles is doing one thing. A co-packer that's handed the peppers, the bottles and the labels and charges a fee to fill them is doing another, and its price will look six times lower for the same bottle. Below are five arrangements with a made-up example of each, the questions that tell them apart, and a comparison to fill in for your own deal.
The short version
- Turnkey co-packing: your recipe, they buy the materials, you buy finished goods.
- Toll manufacturing: your recipe and your materials, they charge a fee to make it.
- Private label: their product, your name on it.
- Custom formulation: they develop it for you. Settle who owns the formula.
- Packaging only: you send finished product in bulk, they pack it.
- A quote means nothing until you know which of these it's for.
- TaroStack tracks your materials at a co-packer, or a client's goods at yours. More below.
Five examples
1. Turnkey co-packing. A granola brand gives a co-packer its recipe. The co-packer buys the oats, honey and bags, makes the granola, and invoices the brand $2.95 for each finished bag. The brand never owns an oat. It owns bags of granola when it pays for them.
2. Toll manufacturing. A hot sauce brand buys its own peppers, bottles, caps and labels and has them delivered to a co-packer. The co-packer cooks, fills and cases 5,000 bottles and charges $0.45 a bottle for the work. Everything on the co-packer's floor belongs to the brand the whole time: the peppers before, the sauce after.
3. Private label. A grocery co-op wants granola under its own name. A maker that already sells granola puts the co-op's label on its existing recipe and sells it at $4.20 a bag. The recipe stays the maker's. The co-op is the brand.
4. Custom formulation. A new skincare brand has an idea and no formula. A cosmetics lab develops a face cream for it, charges a development fee, and then makes the cream in runs of 2,000 jars. Who owns that formula afterward is whatever the agreement says, and if it says nothing, expect an argument.
5. Packaging only. A coffee roaster roasts its own beans and sends them in bulk to a packer with pod-filling equipment. The packer fills, seals and boxes single-serve pods for a fee per pod. No recipe changes hands at all.
Side by side
| Whose recipe | Who buys materials | Who owns the stock | What's paid | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Turnkey co-packing | The brand's | The manufacturer | The manufacturer, until sold to the brand | A price a finished unit |
| Toll manufacturing | The brand's | The brand | The brand, throughout | A fee a unit made |
| Private label | The manufacturer's | The manufacturer | The manufacturer, until sold | A price a unit |
| Custom formulation | As agreed | The manufacturer | The manufacturer, until sold | A development fee, then a price a unit |
| Packaging only | The brand's product | The brand | The brand | A fee a unit packed |
Why the two quotes were both right
Two co-packers quote for the same bottle of sauce: $2.95 and $0.45.
| A bottle | Turnkey | Toll |
|---|---|---|
| The co-packer's invoice | $2.95 | $0.45 |
| Ingredients, bottle, cap and label you buy yourself | $2.10 | |
| Freight to get them there | $0.12 | |
| Your cost, landed at the co-packer | $2.95 | $2.67 |
Toll looks cheaper by $0.28 a bottle here, and it is, if you buy well. In exchange you carry the cash in materials, the ordering, the freight, and the risk that a pallet of bottles arrives late and the line you booked sits idle. Turnkey costs more because the co-packer does all that and marks it up. Neither is the better deal in general. Compare them at the same line: your cost of a finished unit, on their dock. More on reading a quote is in how much does a co-packer cost, and the co-packer's side of the sum in contract manufacturing cost model.
What each one needs in writing
| Arrangement | The clause that matters most |
|---|---|
| Turnkey | Substitutions: may they change a supplier or an ingredient without asking? |
| Toll | Yield and loss: how much of your material may go missing before they owe you for it? |
| Private label | Exclusivity: may they sell the same product to your competitor? |
| Custom formulation | Ownership of the formula, and whether you can take it elsewhere |
| Packaging only | Damage and count: who pays for product spoiled on their line? |
All of them need a confidentiality agreement before the recipe is shared, covered in recipe NDA template, and a main agreement, in co-packing agreement template. The words themselves are untangled in co-manufacturing vs co-packing and what is private label food.
Get the comparison
Download the contract manufacturing comparison. One sheet and a read-me: the five arrangements with whose recipe, who buys, who owns and what's paid, and an example of each. Fill in the same columns for a deal you're offered. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
On paper, toll manufacturing is simple: your materials go in, your product comes out. In practice 400 pounds of your pepper mash and 6,000 of your bottles are in someone else's building. After three runs, how much is left, which lots went into which run, and does the 4,900 on their invoice match what you shipped in? The agreement says they owe you for loss beyond 3%. Nobody can show what the loss was.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps your goods as yours, wherever they are.
If you're the brand, the co-packer's premises can be one of your sites. What you send there is a transfer, shown in transit until it arrives, and it stays your stock.
Each run is a batch. It notes which of your lots it used, automatically, and what it made, so yield is a number.
If you're the manufacturer, every item says whose it is. A client's goods are received at no cost to you, kept apart, and left out of your stock value. A run for a client uses that client's goods and yours, never another client's.
Billing a client puts the fee per unit made and your materials at cost onto a sales order, each line naming its run.
| The question | Agreement and emails | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| How much of my mash is at the co-packer | Ask them | Stock at that site |
| What a run used, and its yield | Their paperwork | The batch's lots and output |
| Whose pallet is this | A marker on the wrap | Every item says whose it is |
| The bill for a toll run | Typed from the quote | Fee and materials, from the run |
TaroStack isn't a contract and doesn't negotiate one. More than one site, and working for clients, are on Business at $89 a month. Recipes and batches are on every plan, from $9.99 a month. The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
