A sourdough starter is flour and water, so a dough made with it has more of both than the recipe's flour and water lines say. A sourdough calculator that counts what's inside the starter gives the dough's true hydration: all the water over all the flour. Type five numbers, total flour, hydration, starter as a share of the flour, the starter's own hydration and salt, and it works out what to put on the scale: starter, flour to add, water to add and salt. For 1,000 g of flour at 75% with 20% starter, that's 200 g of starter, 900 g of flour, 650 g of water and 20 g of salt, for 1,770 g of dough. Below are three doughs for a made-up bakery, each sum, how to work back from the loaves you need, and the file.
The short version
- Total flour includes the flour in the starter. It's the 100%.
- Hydration = all the water ÷ all the flour.
- Flour in the starter = starter ÷ (1 + the starter's hydration).
- Flour to add = total flour − flour in the starter. The same for water.
- Dough weight = total flour × (1 + hydration + salt).
- To hit a number of loaves, work back from the dough weight.
- TaroStack keeps the formula by weight and scales each batch. More below.
Three doughs
| Country loaf | Wholesale batch | Stiff starter rye | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total flour | 1,000 g | 12,000 g | 2,000 g |
| Hydration | 75% | 72% | 80% |
| Starter, of the flour | 20% | 15% | 20% |
| Starter's hydration | 100% | 100% | 60% |
| Salt, of the flour | 2% | 2% | 2.2% |
| Starter | 200 g | 1,800 g | 400 g |
| Flour in the starter | 100 g | 900 g | 250 g |
| Water in the starter | 100 g | 900 g | 150 g |
| Flour to add | 900 g | 11,100 g | 1,750 g |
| Water to add | 650 g | 7,740 g | 1,450 g |
| Salt | 20 g | 240 g | 44 g |
| Dough weight | 1,770 g | 20,880 g | 3,644 g |
| Loaf weight | 885 g | 900 g | 900 g |
| Loaves | 2 | 23 | 4 |
The top five rows are what you type. The bold rows are what goes on the scale. The formulas are this made-up bakery's own.
The sums, for the country loaf
- Starter = total flour × starter share = 1,000 × 20% = 200 g.
- Flour in the starter = starter ÷ (1 + its hydration) = 200 ÷ 2 = 100 g. The rest, 100 g, is water.
- Flour to add = 1,000 − 100 = 900 g.
- Water to add = total flour × hydration − water in the starter = 750 − 100 = 650 g.
- Salt = 1,000 × 2% = 20 g.
- Dough = 1,000 + 750 + 20 = 1,770 g, which is two loaves at 885 g.
A starter's hydration is its water over its flour. One fed with equal weights of flour and water is at 100%. The rye's stiff starter is fed 60 g of water to 100 g of flour, so 400 g of it holds 400 ÷ 1.6 = 250 g of flour and 150 g of water.
Why the starter has to be counted
Look only at what's added and the country loaf reads 650 ÷ 900 = 72%. Its true hydration is 75%. The rye goes the other way: 1,450 ÷ 1,750 = 83% on what's added, 80% true. A liquid starter hides water. A stiff one hides flour.
That's how one recipe can make two doughs. A baker who swaps a liquid starter for a stiff one and keeps the same flour and water lines has changed the dough's hydration without changing a number on the page. With the starter counted, the hydration stays where it's set and the amounts to add move.
Counting the starter as a single ingredient is the other convention, and it's a fair one for a formula that never changes its starter: see baker's percentage calculator. Whichever you use, write down which.
Working back from loaves
An order is for loaves, not for flour. Dough weight is total flour × (1 + hydration + salt), so:
Total flour = dough wanted ÷ (1 + hydration + salt)
The wholesale batch makes 23 loaves at 900 g, with 180 g over. For 24 loaves the bakery needs 21,600 g of dough. At 72% and 2% that's 21,600 ÷ 1.74 = 12,414 g of flour. Type that as the total flour and the rest follows.
Two allowances. Some dough stays on the tub and the bench, so make a little over. And loaf weight here is dough on the scale. A loaf loses water in the oven: weigh a few of yours baked to learn what a 900 g piece of dough sells as.
From the calculator to the bake
The calculator says what to weigh. What happened afterward, the dough's temperature, the hours of bulk, how the loaves came out, goes on a record of the bake: see sourdough log sheet. Moving from a few loaves to a few dozen changes more than the arithmetic: see how to make sourdough bread in bulk. And what the flour in a loaf costs is where its price starts: see how to price sourdough bread.
Get the calculator
Download the sourdough calculator. One sheet and a read-me: type the total flour, hydration, starter share, the starter's hydration, salt and a loaf weight for each dough, and it works out the starter, the flour and water to add, the salt, the dough weight and the number of loaves. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The calculator knows the formula. It doesn't know the bakery. It can't say whether there's 11 kg of bread flour on the shelf for tomorrow's wholesale batch, which bag of flour went into Tuesday's loaves, or what that batch cost now that flour has gone up. And when the formula is changed, the old numbers are typed over, so nobody can say what last month's loaf was made to.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps formulas by weight and connects them to what's on the shelf.
Recipes are by weight, with versions. A changed hydration is a new version, and every batch records which one it used.
A batch scales the recipe to the amount you're making, and takes the ingredients from stock by lot.
Sub-recipes: a starter or a levain is its own recipe, used as an ingredient in others.
"What could I make right now" checks tomorrow's bake against the flour you have.
Every batch is costed from what it used, at what you paid for that flour.
| The job | Calculator | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Scale a formula | One dough at a time | Each batch, to the amount made |
| Is there flour for all of tomorrow | Add it up by hand | What could I make right now |
| A starter inside a dough | Two rows of sums | A sub-recipe |
| Last month's formula | Typed over | The version on each batch |
TaroStack shows recipe quantities by weight, not as baker's percentages: keep the percentage view in the spreadsheet. Recipes and batches are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
