A list of things you could make and sell is easy to find and no help in choosing. What separates one idea from another is five numbers: what the equipment costs, what one unit leaves after materials and packaging, how many units it takes to reach the money you want, how many hours that many take to make, and which rules apply before you can sell the first one. Put eight ideas on those numbers and they stop looking alike. In the made-up comparison below, a lip balm keeps 81% of its price and needs 548 sales a month to leave $2,000. A candle keeps 70% and needs 159. Below is the comparison, how to read it, what it leaves out, and a sheet to fill in with your own figures. Every number here is invented for the example: yours will differ, and yours are the ones that count.
The short version
- Compare ideas on the same numbers, not on how they sound.
- Left a unit = price − materials and packaging.
- Units a month = the money you want ÷ what a unit leaves.
- Hours a month = those units ÷ what you can make in an hour.
- A high margin on a cheap item still means many sales.
- Read the rules for each idea before buying equipment.
- TaroStack tracks materials, batches and what each product really costs. More below.
Eight ideas, the same five numbers
The target in every row is $2,000 left in a month.
| Idea | Made where | Equipment to start | Price | Cost | Left a unit | Margin | Units a month | Made an hour | Hours a month |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Soy candles, 8 oz | Home workshop | $600 | $18.00 | $5.40 | $12.60 | 70.0% | 159 | 12 | 13.3 |
| Bar soap | Home workshop | $500 | $8.00 | $2.10 | $5.90 | 73.8% | 339 | 30 | 11.3 |
| Hot sauce, 5 oz | Commercial kitchen | $2,500 | $9.00 | $2.60 | $6.40 | 71.1% | 313 | 40 | 7.8 |
| Granola, 12 oz | Home or commercial kitchen | $800 | $9.00 | $3.40 | $5.60 | 62.2% | 358 | 30 | 11.9 |
| Roasted coffee, 12 oz | Rented time on a roaster | $1,500 | $16.00 | $7.20 | $8.80 | 55.0% | 228 | 40 | 5.7 |
| Dog treats, 8 oz | Home kitchen where allowed | $400 | $10.00 | $3.00 | $7.00 | 70.0% | 286 | 20 | 14.3 |
| Jam, 9 oz | Home or commercial kitchen | $700 | $8.00 | $2.90 | $5.10 | 63.8% | 393 | 24 | 16.4 |
| Lip balm | Home workshop | $300 | $4.50 | $0.85 | $3.65 | 81.1% | 548 | 60 | 9.1 |
Reading it
Margin isn't the answer. Lip balm has the best margin on the sheet and needs the most sales: 548 a month, because 81% of $4.50 is $3.65. Coffee has the worst margin and needs 228, because 55% of $16.00 is $8.80. What a unit leaves in dollars, not percent, sets how many customers you have to find.
Units are customers. 159 candles a month is about 40 a week. 548 lip balms is 137 a week. Before choosing, ask where that many buyers would come from: one market stall, three shops, a website. Selling is the part of the month that isn't on the sheet.
Hours are yours. Making takes between 5.7 and 16.4 hours a month here. That looks small because it's only the making: buying, labeling, packing orders, standing at a market and answering messages are on top. Still, the column compares the ideas fairly. Jam takes nearly three times the making hours of coffee for the same $2,000.
Equipment is the smallest difference. $300 to $2,500. The hot sauce costs most to start because it's made in a rented commercial kitchen with a filler and a pH meter. None of these is a decision made by the equipment budget.
What the sheet leaves out
- Rules. Each row has a set to read first, and for food it starts with where you're allowed to make it. That can decide the idea before the numbers do.
- How long it keeps. A product that keeps for a year can be made ahead and sold slowly. One that keeps for weeks can't, and what goes out of date is a cost.
- Whether people buy it twice. Coffee and dog treats get used up. A candle might be a gift bought once.
- Seasons. A product bought as a gift sells unevenly through the year.
- Your own pay. $2,000 left after materials isn't $2,000 of profit. Fees, insurance, a stall and your hours come out of it.
Where to read more on each
- Candles: how to start a candle business and candle business plan.
- Soap: how to start a soap business.
- Hot sauce: how to start a hot sauce business.
- Granola: granola business plan.
- Coffee: how to start a coffee roasting business and co-roasting space.
- Dog treats: how to start a dog treat business.
- Jam: jam business plan.
- Lip balm: lip balm profit margin.
Get the sheet
Download the ideas comparison sheet. One sheet and a read-me: type each idea's equipment, price, cost a unit, how many you can make in an hour and the money you want left a month, and it works out what a unit leaves, the margin, the units a month and the hours. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The sheet runs on one guess for each cost. Once you're making the thing, the wax goes up, a batch of jam yields 22 jars where the recipe said 24, and a case of jars arrives with four broken. The real cost of a unit drifts away from the number on the sheet, and the sheet has no way to know. The comparison got you started. It can't tell you how the one you chose is doing.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the real numbers for the idea you chose.
Receiving records each delivery as a lot, at what you paid.
Recipes are by weight, with versions. A batch scales the recipe and takes the materials off stock by lot.
Every batch is costed from what it used, so a short batch or a dearer delivery shows in that batch's units.
Margins by product on real cost, so the candle and the lip balm are seen side by side as they really are.
A reorder list in days of cover, with each supplier's lead time and minimum.
| The question | Comparison sheet | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| What a unit really costs | A guess made before starting | From each batch |
| What a batch yielded | Assumed | Used and made, on the batch |
| Which product earns the most | Estimated | Margins by product |
| When to buy more jars | When they run out | A reorder list |
TaroStack doesn't find customers or pick the idea. Recipes, batches and costs are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
