A preservative is what stands between a jar of cream and whatever falls into it. The FDA pages read for this article name no preservative to use, and FDA doesn't approve cosmetics before sale. What it does say is plain: companies and individuals who make or distribute cosmetics are responsible for the safety of their products, and that includes "making sure cosmetic products are free from harmful microorganisms." It names an ineffective preservation system as one of six ways a product becomes contaminated. So the question for a small maker isn't which preservative is on a list. It's whether this formula, in this package, made this way, stays safe for as long as a customer keeps it, and what record shows that. Below is what FDA says, the six ways in, where water comes into it, and a worksheet.
The short version
- You're responsible for a product free from harmful microorganisms.
- FDA requires no specific test. It does expect safety to be supported by records.
- For this maker the line was water: the first water-based product is the one that spoiled.
- Contamination has six routes, and the preservative is one answer among them.
- Choose and dose a preservative on your supplier's stated use level, and weigh it.
- Have a finished product tested, and keep the report.
- TaroStack records which preservative lot went into which batch. More below.
What FDA says
| Point | FDA's page |
|---|---|
| Approval | Cosmetic products and ingredients, except color additives, don't require FDA approval before sale |
| The duty | They must not be adulterated or misbranded: safe as used, properly labeled, not prepared, packed or stored so as to become contaminated |
| Who is responsible | Companies and individuals who manufacture or distribute cosmetics, including for freedom from harmful microorganisms |
| Tests | Neither the law nor FDA's regulations require specific tests to demonstrate safety |
| Records | Under MoCRA, a responsible person ensures and maintains records supporting adequate safety substantiation |
| Harm | Injuries from contaminated cosmetics aren't common but can be serious. FDA names tattoo inks, eye-area products, and lotions and mouthwashes used in hospitals |
Six ways microorganisms get in
FDA's list, with what a small maker can do about each.
| How they get in | What to look at |
|---|---|
| Contaminated raw materials, water or other ingredients | The water you use. Botanicals, clays and hydrosols, and what their supplier certifies |
| Poor manufacturing conditions | What's cleaned and sanitized before a batch, and who checks |
| An ineffective preservation system, particularly with ingredients that encourage growth | Whether the formula has water, what preserves it, at what level |
| Packaging that doesn't protect the product | A jar a finger goes into, against a pump or a tube |
| Poor shipping or storage conditions | Heat, in a van or on a market table |
| Consumer use, such as dipping fingers in | What the label tells the customer |
A preservative is the third row. It doesn't make up for the other five.
Where water comes in
A balm of oils, butters and wax has no water in it. A cream, a lotion, a toner or anything with aloe, hydrosol, milk or honey does. FDA's wording is "ingredients that encourage growth of microorganisms", and this maker reads that as anything with water in it. Its balms sold for two years without a problem. The first water-based product was the one that grew spots, because it was made the way the balms were.
That's the line to notice in your own range: the day a formula takes water, it needs a preservation system, a package that protects it, and evidence that the two work.
Choosing, dosing and testing
This page doesn't name a preservative for you. Which one suits a product depends on the formula and the package, and that's what a supplier's documentation and a laboratory are for. Three things are yours to do:
- Weigh it. A preservative is dosed by weight, at the supplier's stated level, on a scale that can read it.
- Record it. The preservative's name, lot and weight go on every batch record.
- Test the finished product. A laboratory can challenge a sample with microorganisms and report whether the system holds. FDA requires no particular test, and a report like that is the kind of record that supports a product's safety.
How long a cream should be sold and used for is in lotion shelf life, and the study behind a date in shelf life testing. The record itself is in cosmetic batch record template. This is general information, not legal or technical advice.
Get the worksheet
Download the cosmetic preservation worksheet. One sheet and a read-me: FDA's six routes of contamination, a question to ask of each product for each, a filled-in example for a made-up face cream, and a column for yours. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
The cream is reformulated with a preservative, tested, and passes. Eight months later a customer sends a photo of a jar with spots. Was that jar from before the change or after? Was the preservative weighed that day, and from which lot? Did the supplier change anything? The test report says the formula works. Only the batch record says whether that jar was the formula.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack ties each jar to what went into it.
Recipes by weight, with versions, so "before the preservative" and "after" are different versions, and each batch records which one it made.
Each batch notes the lots it used, automatically, the preservative's among them.
Your checks are fields on the batch record: pH, the preservative's weight, the package used.
Every batch is a lot with a date, with an alert before a date arrives, and one report shows who got it.
| The photo of a spotted jar | Notebook | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Before or after the change | Guess from the date | The recipe version on the batch |
| Which preservative lot | The bottle on the shelf | The lots on the batch |
| Was it weighed | Trust | A field on the batch |
| Who else has that batch | Read the orders | One report |
TaroStack doesn't choose a preservative, test a product or substantiate its safety. Recipes, batches, lots and recalls are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
