"Natural preservative" isn't a term FDA's labeling rule uses. The rule draws a different line, and it's a useful one for a small maker. Under 21 CFR 101.22, a chemical preservative is any chemical added to food that "tends to prevent or retard deterioration", except a short list: common salt, sugars, vinegars, spices, oils extracted from spices, and wood smoke. A food that relies on those six has no chemical preservative to declare. Anything else you add to make food keep, including familiar names like ascorbic acid (vitamin C), citric acid and tocopherols (vitamin E), is a chemical preservative under the rule, and the label has to say what it is and what it's for. Below are both lists, how each goes on a label, and why the ingredient is only part of why a food keeps.
The short version
- Salt, sugars, vinegars, spices, spice oils and wood smoke aren't chemical preservatives under the rule.
- Everything else added to slow spoilage is, however natural its source.
- A chemical preservative is declared by name and by function: "citric acid (to help protect flavor)".
- FDA's own list of preservative names includes ascorbic acid, citric acid and tocopherols.
- An ingredient doesn't set shelf life alone. Acidity, water and the process do.
- Test the shelf life before you print a date.
- TaroStack keeps each batch's ingredients, lot and date. More below.
What the rule excludes
From 21 CFR 101.22(a)(5): the term chemical preservative "does not include common salt, sugars, vinegars, spices, or oils extracted from spices, substances added to food by direct exposure thereof to wood smoke, or chemicals applied for their insecticidal or herbicidal properties."
| Excluded by the rule | Where a small maker meets it |
|---|---|
| Common salt | Brines, cures, ferments, sauces |
| Sugars | Jams, syrups, candied fruit |
| Vinegars | Pickles, hot sauce, dressings |
| Spices | Rubs, sauces, sausage |
| Oils extracted from spices | Flavored products |
| Wood smoke, by direct exposure | Smoked fish, meat, cheese |
These go in the ingredient list under their own names, like any ingredient. A hot sauce of peppers, vinegar and salt lists three ingredients and no preservative, because under the rule it has none.
What FDA lists as preservatives
FDA's Types of Food Ingredients describes two jobs. Antimicrobials "prevent food spoilage from bacteria, molds, fungi, or yeast." Antioxidants "slow or prevent changes in color, flavor, or texture and delay rancidity." The names it gives as examples found on labels:
| On FDA's list | |
|---|---|
| Ascorbic acid | Vitamin C |
| Citric acid | |
| Tocopherols | Vitamin E |
| Sodium benzoate | |
| Potassium sorbate, calcium sorbate | |
| Calcium propionate | |
| Sodium erythorbate | |
| Sodium nitrite | |
| BHA, BHT | |
| EDTA |
Ascorbic acid, citric acid and tocopherols may sound more natural than the rest. The rule doesn't treat them differently: a chemical that tends to prevent or retard deterioration is declared the same way, whatever its source.
How a preservative goes on the label
Paragraph (j) of the same rule: a food with a chemical preservative added must "bear a label declaration stating both the common or usual name of the ingredient(s) and a separate description of its function". The rule gives the wording to choose from.
| Function wording from the rule | Example in an ingredient list |
|---|---|
| "preservative" | potassium sorbate (preservative) |
| "to retard spoilage" | sodium benzoate (to retard spoilage) |
| "a mold inhibitor" | calcium propionate (a mold inhibitor) |
| "to help protect flavor" | citric acid (to help protect flavor) |
| "to promote color retention" | ascorbic acid (to promote color retention) |
So adding vitamin C to keep cut apples from browning means the label says "ascorbic acid (to promote color retention)", and a "no preservatives" claim on the front would contradict it. If you're unsure whether an acid or a vitamin in your recipe counts, ask your regulator before you print. More on this is in preservative labeling, and on front-of-pack words in all natural label claim.
Why the ingredient isn't the whole answer
Salt, sugar and vinegar don't preserve by being present. They work by changing the food: salt and sugar tie up water, and vinegar makes the food acid. A splash of vinegar in a low-acid sauce and a brine that's too weak both appear on the label and neither keeps the food safe. What decides it is measured in the finished product.
- How acid it is: pH testing for acidified foods.
- How much water is free: water activity for food makers.
- How long it really lasts: shelf life testing.
A recipe change counts too. Cutting the sugar in a jam or the salt in a ferment to make it "healthier" removes part of what was preserving it. Treat that as a new product, and test it again.
Get the worksheet
Download the preservative worksheet. One sheet and a read-me: the rule's six exclusions and the names from FDA's list, with whether each is a chemical preservative under the rule, how it goes on the label, and a column for whether it's in your product and why. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
A worksheet says what's in the recipe. It doesn't say what was in Tuesday's batch. The vinegar was a different brand at 4% and not 5%. Someone weighed the salt by eye. The shelf life on the label was tested on a recipe from two versions ago. Preservation is a property of a batch, and the first time anyone checks is when a jar comes back with mold in it.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the recipe and every batch made from it.
Recipes are by weight, with versions. When the salt or vinegar changes, that's a new version, and each batch says which one it used.
A batch notes the lots it used, automatically: which vinegar, from which delivery.
Batch records carry your own checklist fields, so a pH reading you take is recorded with the batch.
Each finished lot has its date, with an alert before it arrives, and stock goes out first-expired-first-out by default.
Every lot is traced to the customers that got it.
| The question | Recipe card and memory | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Which version of the recipe made this jar | Unknown | On the batch |
| Which vinegar went in | The brand you usually buy | The lot the batch used |
| What was the pH that day | A notebook, if written | A field on the batch |
| Who has jars from that batch | Unknown | The recall report |
TaroStack doesn't test pH or shelf life, and it doesn't write your label. Recipes, batches, lots and the recall report are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
