A fulfillment center stores your product, packs each online order and hands it to the carrier. For a food maker, handing that over is two decisions in one. The first is price, and a quote hides it across five or six fees, so two quotes can't be compared until they're turned into one number: what an average order of yours costs. The second is whether the place can handle food: keep lots apart, ship the oldest date first, hold the right temperature, and tell you within hours which orders got a given lot. A cheap quote can fail the second test, and the day you find out is the day of a recall. Below is how to turn quotes into a cost per order, with a comparison of three made-up quotes, the questions to ask, and the file.
The short version
- Turn every quote into the cost of your own average order.
- Add storage and check the monthly minimum: at low volume the minimum is the price.
- Ask whether they track lots, and ask to see a report.
- Ask whether they pick the oldest date first.
- Ask what temperatures they hold, in summer.
- Keep your own record of which lots you sent them.
- TaroStack keeps lots by site, so a center is one of your sites. More below.
The fees in a quote
| Fee | Charged | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Receiving | By the pallet or the hour, when stock arrives | What counts as a pallet; what if cases arrive unlabeled |
| Storage | By the pallet, bin or cubic foot, each month | How a part pallet is charged |
| Pick and pack | By the order, with a fee for the first item | Whether an insert or a sticker is extra |
| Each added item | By the item after the first | Whether a multi-pack is one item |
| Box and fill | By the order | Whether you can supply your own boxes |
| Monthly minimum | A floor on the month's fees | What it covers |
| Postage | By the parcel, at their rate or yours | Whose carrier account |
Postage can be the biggest line, and it's left out of the sums below because it depends on your box and your customers, not on the center. Compare it separately, on the same parcel to the same three zip codes.
Three quotes, one number
This maker sends 300 orders a month, averaging 2.4 items, and keeps 3 pallets at the center.
| Center A | Center B | Center C | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Storage, a pallet a month | $22.00 | $35.00 | $18.00 |
| Pick and pack, first item | $2.75 | $3.10 | $2.25 |
| Each added item | $0.60 | $0.45 | $0.75 |
| Box and fill | $0.85 | $0.00 | $1.10 |
| Monthly minimum | $500 | $250 | $1,500 |
| An average order costs | $4.44 | $3.73 | $4.40 |
| A month's bill | $1,398.00 | $1,224.00 | $1,500.00 |
| Per order, all in | $4.66 | $4.08 | $5.00 |
| Tracks lots | Yes | No | Yes |
| Picks oldest date first | Yes | No | Yes |
| Temperature | Ambient only | Ambient only | Refrigerated and frozen rooms |
The sum. An average order costs the first item, plus each added item × 1.4, plus the box. For Center A that's $2.75 + $0.84 + $0.85 = $4.44. The month is 300 × $4.44 + 3 pallets × $22.00 = $1,398.00.
The minimum. Center C has the lowest pick fee and the highest bill. Its fees come to $1,374.00, under its $1,500 minimum, so the minimum is what's charged. At 600 orders a month the minimum no longer applies, and C's bill would be $2,694.00 against A's $2,730.00. A quote is only cheap at a volume.
The last three rows. Center B is $174.00 a month cheaper than A. It doesn't track lots and doesn't pick by date. For granola with a nine-month shelf life, sold with a best-by date, that's the wrong place at any price.
The questions for a food maker
Lots. Do you record the lot of each case received, and the lot on each order shipped? Can I get a report of every order that received lot G1109, today? Ask to see one. More on what that means is in what buyers mean by lot tracking.
Dates. Do you pick first-expired-first-out, or first-in-first-out, or whatever is nearest? Will you stop shipping a lot when it has fewer than a number of days left that I set? The difference is in FEFO vs FIFO.
Temperature. What does the building reach in August? Is there a cooled room, and what does it cost?
Other people's products. What else is stored near mine: allergens, strong smells, chemicals?
Counts and losses. How often do you count? What happens when your count and mine differ, and who pays for what's missing or damaged?
A recall. If I phone at 4 PM to hold a lot, how fast is it held, and how do I know?
Short-dated stock. What do you do with stock near its date: tell me, return it, destroy it?
Paperwork. Are you registered and inspected as a food warehouse? May I see the last inspection report and your pest control log?
Your side of it
The center's records don't replace yours. Send every shipment with a packing list that names the lots and their dates, and keep a copy: see packing list template. Then you know what's there without asking, and you can check their count against it. Selling through a marketplace's own warehouses is a different arrangement: see how to sell food on Amazon.
Get the comparison sheet
Download the food fulfillment center comparison. One sheet and a read-me: type each quote's fees, your average order and your monthly orders, and it works out what an average order costs, the month's bill with the minimum applied, and the all-in cost per order, beside the columns for lots, dates and temperature. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers.
Where this stops working
Once stock is at the center, you have two inventories: what you think is there and what they say is there. They drift. A pallet you sent in October with two lots on it is, in their system, one line of "granola, maple". When a customer writes about a stale bag, their order history says which box shipped. It doesn't say which batch you baked.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps your own record of what's at the center, by lot.
Sites and transfers, on Business. The center is a site. A transfer moves named lots from your kitchen to it, so what's there is known by lot and date.
Every batch is a lot with a best-by date, from the recipe and the day it was made.
What ships is recorded by lot, whether the order is entered by hand or brought in by CSV import, which shows a preview first.
One report for a lot: where it went, and what's left at each site. Starting a recall holds it.
Counting works on a phone, so the center's count can be entered and compared.
| The question | Their portal | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Which of my lots are at the center | If they track lots | Stock by lot, by site |
| What I sent in October | A receiving line | The transfer |
| Which batch a customer's bag came from | Not known | The lot's history |
| Stock near its date, there and here | Ask them | An alert |
TaroStack doesn't connect to a fulfillment center's system: orders and counts come in by import or by hand. Sites and transfers are on Business at $89 a month. Recipes, batches and lots are on every plan, from $9.99 a month. The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
