There are two ways to state a brine, and they give different amounts of salt. Salt by total weight takes the percent of everything in the jar: (vegetables + water) × the percent. Brine strength takes the percent of the water alone. For 4,000 g of cucumbers under 3,000 g of water, "3.5%" is 245 g of salt the first way and 105 g the second. Recipes rarely say which they mean, and that's where most brine mistakes come from. Both use weight, never spoons. Below are the two sums, worked examples for each, and an Excel file with a sheet for each method.
The short version
- By total weight: salt = (food + water) × percent. The food ends up at that saltiness.
- By brine strength: salt = water × percent. The food ends up less salty than the brine.
- Dry-salted ferments such as sauerkraut have no water: salt = cabbage × percent.
- Weigh the salt. A spoonful of flaky salt can weigh half what a spoonful of fine salt does.
- Find out which method your recipe means before you weigh anything.
- TaroStack keeps the recipe by weight and scales the salt with the batch. More below.
Method 1: salt by total weight
Weigh the food and the water you'll add. Multiply the sum by the percent.
| What's being brined | Food | Water | Percent | Salt |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sauerkraut, dry salted | 10,000 g | none | 2% | 200 g |
| Fermented hot sauce mash | 5,000 g | none | 3% | 150 g |
| Carrot sticks in brine | 2,500 g | 2,000 g | 2.5% | 113 g |
| Whole cucumbers in brine | 4,000 g | 3,000 g | 3.5% | 245 g |
| Chicken, brined to a set saltiness | 2,000 g | 2,000 g | 1.75% | 70 g |
Given time, salt spreads evenly through the food and the water. So the percent you choose is the saltiness you end up with, however long it sits. That's why this method suits ferments, and why it's forgiving for meat: the chicken in the last row can't get saltier than 1.75%.
Method 2: brine strength
Weigh the water only. Multiply by the percent.
| Brine for | Water | Strength | Salt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Topping up a crock | 1,000 g | 2% | 20 g |
| Dill pickle brine | 3,000 g | 5% | 150 g |
| Feta storage brine | 2,000 g | 8% | 160 g |
| Poultry brine, overnight | 4,000 g | 6% | 240 g |
Vegetables and meat are mostly water themselves, so they dilute the brine. A brine made this way is always stronger than the food will end up. With a strong brine and a short soak, time is the control: the bird comes out before it gets as salty as the liquid.
Some recipes work strength as salt ÷ (water + salt). At kitchen strengths the gap is small: 5% of 3,000 g of water is 150 g one way and 158 g the other.
The same jar, both ways
| By total weight | By brine strength | |
|---|---|---|
| Cucumbers | 4,000 g | 4,000 g |
| Water | 3,000 g | 3,000 g |
| "3.5%" means | 3.5% of 7,000 g | 3.5% of 3,000 g |
| Salt | 245 g | 105 g |
| Salt in the whole jar | 3.4% | 1.5% |
A pickle made at 1.5% when the recipe meant 3.5% is a different ferment. If a recipe gives only a brine percent and doesn't say, look for the words "of the water" or "of the total weight", or work out which one its own example quantities match.
What the calculator doesn't decide
The percents above are common in recipes. They aren't safety limits, and this sheet only does arithmetic. Salt is one of the things that keeps a ferment safe, along with keeping the food under the brine and the acid the ferment makes. Use a tested recipe, and check a ferment's pH: a log for that is in fermentation log sheet. Curing meat with nitrite is a different sum with much tighter limits, and this isn't for that.
The steps around the salt are in sauerkraut production process and how to make pickles in bulk.
Get the calculator
Download the brine calculator. Two sheets and a read-me. On the first, type the food's weight, the water and the percent, and it gives the salt by total weight. On the second, type the water and the strength. It's an ordinary Excel file with no macros, and it works in Google Sheets, LibreOffice and Numbers. To scale the rest of a recipe along with the salt, use the recipe multiplier calculator.
Where this stops working
Cabbage doesn't arrive in round numbers. Monday's batch is 9,400 g trimmed, Thursday's is 11,250 g, and each needs its own salt weight. Somebody does the sum on the back of a box, and three weeks later nobody can say what percent the sour batch really got.
How TaroStack does it
TaroStack keeps the salt in the recipe and the recipe on the batch.
The recipe is by weight. Cabbage, salt, caraway: each with its amount for the recipe's batch size. Record a batch of 9,400 g or 11,250 g and the salt follows in proportion.
What went in is on the record. The batch notes the lots it used automatically: which delivery of cabbage, which bag of salt.
Your own fields. Salt percent, pH on day 3 and day 7, and initials are fields you add to the batch-record form.
On hold while it ferments. A crock on hold is kept out of what you can sell until you release it.
A lot and a date when it's packed. Each batch goes into stock with its lot code and best-by date, and the soonest to expire sells first.
| The job | Back of a box | In TaroStack |
|---|---|---|
| Salt for today's cabbage | A sum each time | The recipe, scaled to the batch |
| What percent did that batch get? | Lost | On the batch record |
| pH readings | A separate sheet | Fields on the batch |
| Not ready yet | A date on tape | On hold |
TaroStack doesn't set your salt level or test your recipe. Recipes, batches and lots are on every plan, from $9.99 a month (5 recipes) or $39 a month (50 recipes). The first 14 days are free, with no credit card. If you'd like a hand setting up, ask, and we'll do it with you.
